Help - Desktop (Linux, Mac and Windows)

Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Do you mean 
Reply
Music Fan
Fufu
Posts: 1
Registered: ‎07-05-2013
Accepted Solution

Unadvertised P2P feature

I am not very happy with Spotify right now. I was doing some work in my router when I noticed that Spotify had opened some ports via UPnP. I found this a little strange and after some googleing I discovered Spotify uses a P2P network for its content. The reason I am not happy is because this feature is not documented well, if at all. It is not stated anywhere in an easy to find place, and it's not even configurable. If you're going to use P2P technology, make it known. I do not like this sneaky behavior. As I said above it's not advertised anywhere and there is little to no documentation on it at all. I've already read through tons of complaints about bandwidth hogging. At least make this configurable! But I'm really more concerned about how secretive Spotify have been about this feature. I do not like sneaky suspicious behavior like this by applications. I will be canceling my premium subscription.

Moderator
Adam
Posts: 2,254
Registered: ‎07-12-2012

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

[ Edited ]

We’re sorry you feel like we’re hiding the fact we’re using P2P technologies. It’s in no way our intention to hide the fact this is the way Spotify works; rather, we’re proud of it!

 

Here’s how it works: Spotify is a hybrid model, streaming music centrally from our giant servers as well as incorporating peer-to-peer technology, which allows the music to be played instantly as if it was stored directly on your computer or mobile phone. By setting Spotify up in this way, we’re able to provide the smoothest streaming with no buffering times.

 

If you needed to reduce the amount of data uploaded from your computer, feel free to reduce the cache size setting in your Preferences. Alternatively, you could try our web player at play.spotify.com which typically uses less bandwidth. Note: that web player isn't yet available to everyone so you may not be able to use it just yet.

 

Edit: there's also some extra information here.

--------------------------------------------------------------

For common support questions, see support.spotify.com.
To judge my musical taste, check out my last.fm.
DBD
Music Fan
DBD
Posts: 1
Registered: ‎21-12-2013

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

I have, currently, found Spotify P2P feature as well. It forces me to switch Spotify off and completely kill it as it's eating ALL available network bandwith. And as there is nothing in Settings that will let set it up properly, it's main reason why not to use Spotify anymore, or just use it only when i don't need network connectivity.

 

Let me say, that i found disturbing, that there is nothing that will warn users, that their computer will act as P2P node and transfer loads of data, up to All available bandwith. 

 

Let me say, that i found disturbing, that it's not possible to throttle P2P functionality to only fraction of available network connectivity. 

 

And let me say, that by introducing P2P without user knowledge you might well make them pay money for connectivity or get their connectivity limited or even disabled. 

 

 

Garage Band
silbaco
Posts: 27
Registered: ‎05-05-2013

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

Spotify can eat through a considerable amount of data on capped connections. If you have satellite or wireless it can literally eat through the entire cap single handedly (and cost you $15 per GB in overages). I'd use the web player instead of the software player if caps are an issue or find another music service.

Award Winning Artist
hpguru
Posts: 6,060
Registered: ‎06-02-2012

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

Hey there.

 

I'm sorry that you have streaming problems.

 

Spotify for Mobile or Web doesn't use any P2P stuff. In mobile you can also stream with pretty low 96 kbps sound quality.

 

Just try these options out before you go mad ツ

 

Happy Spotifying!

Spotify for music listening, user since April 2009. Netflix for movie watching, user since July 2013. 100M/10M cable modem and 21M/5M mobile network. Pimp your life with streaming everywhere!
Music Fan
CraigCottam
Posts: 3
Registered: ‎25-10-2012

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

Unfortunately this means I wil have to stop my subscription as well as I can't use P2P at work where I mostly listen to it. Your loss.

Merik
Posts: 1,363
Kudos: 561
Solutions: 149
Registered: ‎30-07-2013

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature


CraigCottam wrote:

Unfortunately this means I wil have to stop my subscription as well as I can't use P2P at work where I mostly listen to it. Your loss.


I would hate to see you leave premium! :( Have you checked out the web player, which doesn't use P2P?


Spotify Rewards Card Last.fm Spotify Integrate Soundwave


Don't forget to add your kudos below!Big smile

Festival VIP
openstar53
Posts: 10
Registered: ‎27-09-2012

Re: Unadvertised P2P feature

Found this via search, wondering if P2P was used.  Thought I would add an update.

 

Update to this is that Spotify are removing the P2P element from April 2014.

 

http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/17/spotify-removes-peer-to-peer-technology-from-its-desktop-client/

Announcements
Rock Star Program
Want to be a Rock Star?
Read about our Rock Star Program.

Beta test Spotify for iOS
Hi there.
Would you like a chance to beta test upcoming versions of Spotify for iOS? If the answer is a resounding "yes!" then please click here to read more.

Did you know?

More

Please bear in mind that the Community is not an official Spotify support service. It's a place where we all help each other, whether we work for Spotify or not. So please use your discretion when using the forum.