I've been using Spotify on and off for a number of years but have never been able to justify the cost of Premium based on my fairly sporadic usage and my lack of need for features like offline play and high quality audio. All I really want to do is avoid the ads.
So I was thinking, what about charging for the premium features separately? So you'd have an Ad Free boost, an Offline boost and an HQ boost. You could charge say £3.99 per boost (per month) and customers could mix and match as they wish. Premium could still stay at £9.99 and be effectively a discounted price for taking all 3 boosts.
Sky TV seem to have been very successful with this approach. They have a basic subscription and then all manner of packages and add ons so you can pick and choose only what you need. If you like movies, you pay for movies. If you like sport, you pay for sport.
I appreciate that changing a pricing model is not something that you can do at the drop of a hat. However, it could work well for Spotify to get customers on board at a cheaper price point.