I can't believe this hasn't migrated from the Get Satisfaction site - Spotify is in dire need of Smart Playlists. iTunes and Media Monkey have hgihly intelligent smart playlist functions, which is great for offlining big playlists in a useful way. I, for example, have a huge starred playlist which I simply can't offline without seriously compromising the speed of my iPhone and more particularly, the Spotify app. If I could restrict it to 100 random songs that I haven't played in the last 6 months, then I could just sync nightly, and listen to a selection of my favorite songs, without causing performance issues. Currently, I have to create playlists manually using Spotibot with my Last.fm loved tracks, which is hassle.
fez, have you used spotify onyour android? I ask because lots of people seem to have problems with it...
I was thinking about this too. Great idea!
Intelligent playlists based on my favorites.
The wheel has already been invented in iTunes.
Agreed
I'd be happy enough if Spotify imported (or better, synced) iTunes' Smart Playlists.
Smart Playlists are the key to shift people from iTunes to Spotify. A lot of iTunes users have their music life in a decent collection of music. And they don't see a way to take it over to Spotify.
Another thing that is keeping users at iTunes is the lack of a 5 star rating system at Spotify. There is something in between like or dislike a song.
I have to agree that the lack of smart playlist support is a deal killer for me. I was hoping to find a single music app that would do it all. I'm going to cancel for now.
Smart playlists so, for example, you can create a plylist with tarcks you have added within the last 2 months.
Also needs something as simple as an artist smart playlist (i.e., a playlist which contains everything by a given artist), so I can create a simple artist playlist which always contains everything spotify has available for that artist.
I think the Spotify-crew think that too big playlist will be created. One way to get around this is to make some kind of personal library where you add new songs you like. The smart playlist will only contain songs from your library. I really want to switch to Spotify but this is a big deal for me.
Perhaps you are right - I would not expect people to use smart playlists against the whole Spotify library, just against their own. In any case, a simple upper limit (eg 500 songs) should be achievable.
I'm not sure why this doesn't exist on such ad advanced app, but it doesn't 😞
What I'm referring to is the implementation of smart filters to create modular and dynamic playlists.
For example, if I like a song I star it, which gets added to my "Starred" playlist. This works well if I want to listen to just random songs that I like, but I can't filter the playlist down further.
Say I want to create a playlist of all my "Starred" tracks by "J. Cole" and "Drake", I can search within my "Starred" playlist for "J. Cole" and "Drake", then create a playlist with just their tracks. I've done this, but here is where my problem starts.
Now I'm listening to Spotify Radio and I hear a few "New" tracks by "J. Cole" and "Drake". I then "Star" them, which adds them to my "Starred" playlist. What DOESN'T happen is that these new awesome songs to get added to the new playlist I created earlier.
If there were smart filters or smart playlists, I could save out an advance search with the following paramaters: "Starred", Artist(s): "J. Cole" and "Drake", then this playlist would automatically add the songs that satisfy the search query. This would be extremely useful!
I use and application called, "Aperture" for my photographs, which has this feature. I think they call them, "Smart Albums." Needless to say, it makes the management of pictures MUCH EASIER.
I hope I have done a decent job explaining the problem and recommending a solution. If you like my idea, please +1 it!
Thanks,
Clyde
YES PLEASE!!!! This is my #1 wish list item for spotify!!!!
this would be the most killer feature for spotify improving it over all other music subscription services (except rhapsody which has this feature already, but rhapsody does not sync auto play lists between devices). it would be a unique feature that would help cement spotify's status as the best music subscription service!!
Once spotify implements this (on the desktop client & mobile apps with syncing between devices) I would gladly give spotify all my $$$.
Yes Smart Plylists are are needed they will probably be the reason why I don't be able to switch.
Once Smartlist exist Ic an probably make the switch.
But the ultimate comfort feature wuld be if Spotify could do an iTunesImport of all my playlist and Smartplay Lists.
But creating this import might be a bit difficult:
I believe first the song swhich exist in spotify should just be linked to the songs in the spotify global library.
Then the question is what to o about songs which are not in the global spotify library.
I guess there the user should have the option to either
- import the songs from iTunes and copy them into a spotify folder on the harddrive.
- or spotify should access the songs in the iTunes folder but I think this would be a bad solution as what happens when the song get deleted from iTunes?
- a third option might be if iTunes offers this API to always keep iTunes and Spotify in sync. So when songs are deleted form iTunes they will automatically also be deleted from spotify.
Anyway to say it short again: SmartPlaylists are need!!!
And with them also field have to come like, play count , skip count, last played date, last skipped date etc.
Shouldn't be too difficult to implement, but requires some more metadata on Spotify's side.. I think that's where the problem lies (such as nr. of listens and such..)
Richer metadata and we'll be able to filter better and create smarter playlists. Also, limit it to user playlists - not the whole collection. Ofc.. there might be problems with users adding *everything* to their playlists.. But make the smartness local to the user's computer then...
Spotify: This is worth investigating and spending money developing.
Smartplaylist is a must.
I usually buy a lot of stuff that I park for listening to later.
My favourite smartplaylist when on iTune was :
- status = downloaded/purchased in the last 60 days
- play count = 0
- max size = 4gb
This allowed me to then listen to new stuff when I was on the move and star it or filter it then and then.
It would make so much sense for Spotify to have such a feature.
It would allow to do your shortlist and then to review while on the move (online or offline) and decluster your playlists/star lists.
Lack of smart playlists is a DEAL BREAKER.
I understand more metadata is needed (for example the number of plays, and a better handling of track/playlist time length) this lack of metadata IS ANOTHER DEAL BREAKER.
Spotify - the metadata is EASY TO IMPLEMENT, it's already there for you to use!!
Implementing the metadata makes way for smart playlists to be implemented.
TAKE IT IN STEPS IF YOU NEED TO, BUT PLEASE DO NOT IGNORE THE NEED FOR THIS IDEA TO BE IMPLEMENTED. THE SOONER THE BETTER, THIS IS THE NUMBER 1 REASON WHY THE MASSES STAY WITH ITUNES INSTEAD OF SWITCHING TO SPOTIFY.
Hello there!
First at all, truly sorry for the delay on updating this...we know it has been around for a while now but we have tons of ideas which come in to the community everyday and sometimes it is quite hard to prioritize.
We´ve been discussing this with the design team and we all love the idea. We want to implement it as soon as we can. At the moment, we are focusing on fixing the offline syncing and other related issues. Once we are done with this we will start building features as the Smart Playlists (we know how important it is as well).
So please, check this thread out for next updates.
Thanks for your awesome feedback!
@Rocio, Please encourage your developers to look at Media Monkey or iTunes for inspiration when designing this. Key points are, it should be easy to use, and flexible. Everyone will have a different idea of how best to use this, the important thing would be to make sure as many people as possible can do what they want. It will probably be important to up the number of tags (genre, number or plays, last played, etc etc)
We also need Spotify to support syncing with iTunes' own Smart Playlists! Right now, it only imports regular playlists.
Thanks!
I don't understand why Itunes playlist importation is a problem for smart playlists. mSpot worked flawlessly. Unfortunately, mspot is no more. I was hoping that Spotify had improved.
@rocio you suggestion does NOT work.
when you select another playlist it gets added to the end of the queue. It does not replace it.
This is the single most glaring gap in Spotify, and I'm amazed it hasn't been sorted by now. For me, I want a playlist that will show me tracks I have starred in the past x months, or in a specific date range (e.g. Starred in 2011). Come on Spotify, this can't be that hard!
How can this not be considered an essential feature. As a subscription feature at the very least it is so basic yet makes offlining songs onto mobile so much easier to use. I don't want to download every song I've ever added or have to manually create a new playlist everytime I want to listen to something new!!
Smart Playlists would be perfect, and I'm missing them pretty badly. However, I'm sure that if it's implemented missing a few things such as date-added or date-released or last-played then users will go ape schitt.
You will do this one eventually, won't you Spotify??
@Rocio - how can this be marked as "not right now".... how far off are we from having smart playlists? if spotify wants to compete with itunes and mediamonkey, this needs to be implemented ASAP. I would consider this one of the MAJOR FEATURES THAT SPOTIFY IS LACKING AGAINST COMPETITORS.
There was a time when SPL didn't exist and the world still turned. I'd love this feature but what are you going to do. Maybe its already built into spotify??? Ever think about that. Well you can listen to your top tracks? in Top Lists Just change Everywhere to For Me.
^^ This.
I think this is a deal-breaking feature for me. I've evaluated Spotify for about a month, and I like it, but on my drive home, I want to hear "songs in my 'Good songs' playlist that I haven't heard or skipped in the past 4 months in order of play count", like I can easily do on my iPod using iTunes. I don't want to put any more effort into a Spotify switchover unless this is coming up. I really do want to switch, as I'd like to use my Android phone instead of my iPod for music.
Is something like this on the roadmap? Is there some workaround? Or are enough people just satisfied with "shuffle this playlist", which starts the shuffle over every time, that you're not going to implement it?
Thanks.