A more Definitive Rating System

A long time ago, I was a huge fan of the TiVo and its multiple thumbs rating system. I believe a similar system here could increase the effectiveness of a station for listeners.

The TiVo had a total of 7 ranks when considering a show ranging from 3 thumbs up (I LOVE THIS!) to three thumbs down (I'll commit suicide if I hear 'call me maybe' one more time).

 

My idea is to add a "pop up menu" of multiple thumbs and say a trash can or skull or what have you. When you tap the like/dislike button, you could then select your level of appreciation from the pop up menu. A trash can/skull for things you never want to hear again (on that station) and 3-5 thumbs indicating the level of appreciation and frequency you want to hear the song.

 

This would prevent a person from accidentally tapping the dislike button when they intended to like it.

 

Currently, all songs that are 'liked' are played often... But I like some songs less than others and greatly appreciate a higher level of impact on how often songs are played on the station.

 

When deciding to play new songs on the station, the rating s could assist in determining what 'new' tracks to play. Anything resembling tracks with a high rating could be intorduced/played often, while something close to the bottom could still be played seldomly. Anything with a skull/trash can should be removed entirely and similar tracks artists very raely added (unless other high rated tracks trigger them int the station)

 

I know this is poorly written but I believe the point gets across. I also understand that programming a system to identify multiple markers is much more than a handfull. Just curious what you think and if other listeners would preffer a more definitive station lieke me.

 

 

Child Item
Status: Active
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Case and point for the above post...

I "liked" the song I Would Walk 500 Miles by The Proclaimers a while ago. No matter how many more songs I like and add to the playlist, this song plays every time I open the station, lol.

 

I like the tune well enough and given a 1-5 option it would receive a 3 to start and if I felt I heard it too much it would be downgraded to a 2.

 

The same thing happens with numerous other songs I hear so often I'd rather dislike them and never hear them again than hear them 3-4 times a day. I keep adding thums and other songs to try and dilute the list and offer more diversity but many of the same tunes play far too often.

 

This idea has been submitted more than 1 year ago but unfortunately hasn't gained enough kudos during that time (10 kudos/year). In order to keep an overview of the active ideas in this forum, this idea will be closed for now. Note that this does not mean the idea has been declined by Spotify.

Please feel free to re-post this idea if you still feel you want this implemented. With a little change in presentation, maybe this time it will gain the necessary support from the community.

Child Item
Child Item