The track 'popularity' scores are biased by various factors. For anyone who is keen to hear the best songs by an artist without listening to their entire back catalogue, It would be better if the track 'popularity' scores were adjusted to give a more useful indication of which songs people really like the most.
Here are the three sections of my idea, with further explanation of the issues:-
Issue: A lot of people play the first few tracks of an album to see if they like the music. These tracks then get a higher 'popularity' score, but not because people actually like them more. This is unhelpful if you want to discover the best songs on an album.
Example album: 'Dance The ****' by The Frames.
Solution: Add weighting within each album, so that the 'popularity' score of the first few tracks is biased lower.
Issue: If you want to discover the best songs by an artist, it's unhelpful to have an artist view where all the tracks show extremely low 'popularity' bars. To be useful, the 'popularity' shown in such views should be relative to tracks by the same artist - not relative to the popularity of Justin Bieber tracks! In the extreme, wth lesser-known artists, a list of tracks sorted by popularity is just shown in alphabetical order - since they apparently all have zero popularity!
Example artist: Mecca Normal.
Solution: Add higher popularity weighting to tracks by less popular artists, so that, at least in certain views, the 'popularity' score of each track is shown relative to other tracks by that same artist.
Issue: Tracks on newer albums generally have a higher 'popularity' score. This is because people are keen to listen to new albums they haven't heard before, not necessarily because they like the tracks on the new albums a lot more. It's unhelpful if you are keen to discover all the best songs by an artist, to have Spotify show that the most popular songs are all from the latest album.
Example Artist: Muse.
Solution: Add higher weighting to tracks on older albums, so that the 'popularity' score of these tracks is more balanced with those on the latest albums.
Thanks for reading,
Mark
This idea has been submitted more than 1 year ago but unfortunately hasn't gained enough kudos during that time (10 kudos/year). In order to keep an overview of the active ideas in this forum, this idea will be closed for now. Note that this does not mean the idea has been declined by Spotify.
Please feel free to re-post this idea if you still feel you want this implemented. With a little change in presentation, maybe this time it will gain the necessary support from the community.