[All Platforms][Other] Explain why features won't be implemented when closing an Idea

I genuinly find it insulting that so many ideas get closed and the only response is "We're not going to do it". I think you would find far less frustration from your users if you actually gave the technical reasons why a feature won't be implemented.

 

For example, a lot of users are still asking for proper Chromecast support in the desktop application. Why doesn't the answer mention that the reason there's no support is because Google has not released an SDK for desktop chromecast development?

 

What about the 10k song limits? Or the 3333 offline playlist limits? Why can't you spend a few paragraphs explaining the technical reasons behind the decision not to increase the limits? Don't dumb it down and just say "the user experience will be bad", explain what's going on. I wanna hear the dirty details involving database storage, local storage, or the cpu/bandwidth involved with serializing 10k vs 20k songs in a playlist.

Child Item
Status: Active
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Wrt the offline limitations, the reason appears to be legal rather than technical. This was mentioned by Spotify in the recently closed thread about that topic.

It is a truly frustrating limitation, especially now when 128GB of storage on smartphones are pretty standard. I'd say that the legal rather than engineering nature of that limitation is also manifest for the unreasonable maths behind those numbers. The limitation is a total of 10k tracks across 3 devices, but effectively it turns out that the real limit is 9,999 tracks and not 10k.

I know little about the topic of legal agreements in music, but from other documented cases it appears that it's quite difficult to renegotiate them. The hip hop masterpiece by De La Soul is still missing from streaming services even though De La Soul would be happy to make it available: http://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-37020559

 

Updated on 2018-03-17

Hey @rossisdead

 

I concur that sometimes explanations could be more elaborate, but most of the times Spotify staff makes an effort to give an explanation for the status of an Idea.

 

For more info on how the Ideas Board work, this post here can help. 🙂

Child Item
Child Item