Very much like Selen4Gomez's Idea: https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Browse-Finding-more-languages-easier/idi-p/4939782
I believe that every song has its own traits/characteristics that are independent of each other. (eg Language, Genre) Songs should thus be tagged and classified according to those traits instead. This means that the classification systems that we use should also be independent of each other. (eg all songs can be classified under mutually exclusive groups in different ways ie all songs can be classified by language, all songs can be classified by genre.)
Every language has its own songs belonging to different genres, and genres can present itself in different languages, it would only make sense that every song be tagged with both its language and its genre. The language of the song should not be the only defining factor in deciding a song's genre.
This means that all songs would have to be classified based on both language and genre. For instance, Mayday's 将军令 is in Mandarin, but it is of Alt-Rock Genre, so it can be classified as a song in Mandarin, or an Alt-Rock song, or both.
This means if it were to be featured in Spotify playlists, the playlists could include:
- International Alt-Rock, featuring Alt-Rock songs of various languages (eg with Demons by Imagine Dragons, etc)
- Mandarin Songs, featuring Mandarin songs of all genres (eg Michael Wong's 童话)
- Mandarin Alt-Rock, featuring Mandarin Alt-Rock songs (eg along with Jam Hsiao's 王妃)
If you're wondering how this differs from Selen4Gomez's idea: Theirs is about giving smaller languages more priority, the same amount of features any major language would have.
Mine does encompass that idea yes, but my focus more of these things are independent and there being a way to subscribe to specific criteria (let's say I only want Rock, regardless of language, or I want rock, but only in French). My suggestion adds on to theirs.
Theirs categorises songs into languages then genres. If there were to be a flow chart, songs would go through a language filter then a genre filter. Mine are two independent tags. This means more of classifying things into a table form with vertical columns and horizontal rows that have independent variables. Classify songs by putting them into mutually exclusive groups (diff lang) then another set of mutually exclusive groups (genre).
An example in a way our ideas would differ: Her system will now allow for a genre playlist made by Spotify to include more than one language, but mine will.
Their sounds like about giving smaller languages more priority, the same amount of features any major language would have.
Mine does encompass that idea yes, but my focus more of these things are independent and there is a way to subscribe to specific. My suggestion adds on to theirs.
Theirs categorises songs into languages then genres. If there were to be a flow chart, songs would go through a language filter then a genre filter. Mine are two independent tags. This means more of classifying things into a table form with vertical columns and horizontal rows that have independent variables. Classify songs by putting them into mutually exclusive groups (diff lang) then another set of mutually exclusive groups (genre).
An example in a way our ideas would differ: Her system will now allow for a genre playlist made by Spotify to include more than one language, but mine will.
I am not sure what more detail you are looking for.
Hey again @jovingoh31,
Thanks for adding that, it was pretty helpful!
It might be good to update the description of your idea to clarify this as well.
In the meanwhile, we'll be updating the status of your idea!
If there's anything else we can help with, don't hesitate to give us a shout.
Have a lovely day 🙂
Updated on 2020-07-11
Hello and thanks for bringing your feedback to the Idea Exchange. We've marked this as a new idea.
Spotify Staff will look into this idea once it reaches the necessary amount of votes. More information about how the Spotify Idea Exchange works can be found here.
Updated on 2021-03-23
Hello @jovingoh31!
It looks like your idea was posted a while ago but, unfortunately, it hasn't gathered the minimum amount of votes to stay active in the Ideas Exchange (50 votes in the first 3 months). I'll mark your idea as "Closed - Not Enough Votes". You can learn more on how the Ideas Exchange works here.
Have a nice day 🙂
Updated on 2022-01-20
Hey! Thanks for coming to the Spotify Idea Exchange.
We've been keeping an eye on this submission for an extended period of time, and it doesn't seem this will reach the votes necessary to put it forward for prioritization.
As such, we're marking this case as closed. This includes any similar suggestions that are received.
If we do have any new information to share, rest assured we'll check back in here with a new status.
More information about it can be found here.
Updated on 2020-07-08
Hey there @jovingoh31,
Thank you for submitting this idea, we'll just need a bit more info to understand it first in order to give it the proper status.
Your idea sounds very similar to this idea shared by @Selen4Gomez that you mentioned. To make sure we're on the same page, could you share some additional details on how your idea differs?
We'll be keeping an eye out for your reply, thanks 🙂