[All Platforms] No Ads in Podcasts for Spotify Premium users

I pay for my subscription. Every month for years now. The main reason I am a paid-for subscriber with Spotify is so I don't have to hear ads. As I have shifted my podcast listening from other providers to Spotify to bypass ads, both from the platform as well as integrated into the content.

 

I expect not to hear ads on Spotify. I understand there are ads woven into the actual content of the podcast itself, but for as big of a company and the amount of leverage Spotify has, I expect to not hear ads so long as I am paying for the service.

 

I reached out to Spotify and got this lazy, generic answer from Joy in Spotify Customer Support: “if you're hearing ads on podcasts using this Premium account. It's possible that the podcaster integrated that ads to their podcast content”. Thanks for breaking your back on that response.

 

I KNOW what the ads I’m hearing are. And I understand they can’t ask podcasters to export two versions, one with integrated ads and one without. What I expect from Spotify is to either implement metadata that tags the beginning and ending of ad segments and bypass them for us, Premium subscribers, or require podcasters to give metadata timecodes that Spotify can identify to bypass them AUTOMATICALLY.

 

Just to be clear, even if these identifiers are put into the content, I don’t want to have to pull my phone out to hit any sort of “skip ads” button. This is literally the ONLY reason users have Premium. So get rid of the ads. It’s actually very simple. And let’s not get started on how archaic it is to continually hit the “15sec forward” button to bypass the ads, first over shooting, then undershooting the duration of the integrated ad, only to have to make peace with hearing the last ten seconds of the ad. At that point it’s not servicing either party in the transaction.

 

It’s 2020. You are a huge company with a lot of leverage and a huge developer budget. I honestly can’t believe I’m even having to write this suggestion.

 

tl:dr - Spotify, I am a Premium member. You made a promise to me that if I became a Premium member, I wouldn’t hear ads. I’m hearing ads on podcasts. Integrated or not, I don’t care. You have the technology and power to fix it. So fix it. And make it automatic. It’s 2020.

Child Item
Status: None
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

I just started listening to podcasts, specifically "Stuff You Should Know," and was annoyed that they were allowed to keep their ads on their podcasts. I'm sure they get paid for being on spotify and I am a Spotify Premium member so that I don't have to listen to ads. Spotify should put their own ads on the podcasts the same way they do with music.

Updated on 2017-08-10

Marked as new idea and edited the title slightly to make it easier to find via search. 😉

Imagine if Netflix had ads... this is a farse. Ruins the experience.

 

Update 2019-07-20: This idea has been reposted here.

Updated on 2018-08-08

Hello!

Your idea has been submitted a while ago but unfortunately hasn't gathered enough kudos (100 per year). In order to keep an overview of the active & recent ideas in this forum, we will close this idea for now. However this does not mean that your idea has been declined by Spotify.

If you still feel strongly about your request, we encourage you to post your idea in a little different form again! Maybe now is the right time to receive the support of our community for your suggestion! 😉

P.S: More information about how the ideas exchange works can be found here.

Updated on 2020-08-31

Marked as new idea, which is a repost of this inactive idea.

Someone beat me to the punch so I'm just going to add my two cents as well.

 

As a Premium user, I pay for ad-free music content, my podcasts should be ad-free too.

If content creators are embedding ads, we (the users) should be able to flag them so they are made to edit and remove them. The same way they would if they were explicit song tracks etc.

There is no excuse for embedded ads and it only opens the floodgates to music having ads embedded too. If creators have a huge backlog of podcasts maybe set a date and after X date they must follow this rule and have their history fixed. Also there’s no monetary gain for Spotify to allow this, so why?

As a long time user I hope you will consider addressing this. It drives me crazy and not really want to listen to podcasts at all. I hate ads! This is why I pay for Premium!

Thank you. Cheers.

I agree with DonnieDarkOh!


Spotify claims that my experience would be ad-free... but it isn’t!

Couldn't agree with you more.

I am hearing ads on the Your Daily Drive playlist made for me interspersed with news, sport and other spoken bulletins, but I am getting ads, and its really annoying me. I paid premium to get Spotify ad-free so why am I hearing ads. Incidentally, one of the ads was for another music streaming service, which is just plain old commercial self-harm.

Such a pain!

It really is shocking that this hasn’t been given more attention and shameful that Spotify won’t even engage in the conversation. Clearly this is a topic that concerns the business model so why not engage and be transparent about things. Personally I’m on the edge of cancelling my account solely on this matter because to me it fundamentally goes against the idea of paying for the service.

Somebody's got to say it: this is a bad idea which would result in some podcasts disappearing from Spotify or dying completely. There's no way Spotify would want or likely be able to give podcast producers anything like the revenue that they get from direct sponsorship.

 

Perhaps there's middle-ground where deals could be made with some, probably larger, podcasts to appear on the platform exclusively without ads, but it couldn't work accross the board without ruining things.

 

Podcasts aren't part of Spotify's premium offering; they're a (generally) free resource that Spotify provides access to for convenience.

I certainly agree that it’s rocky ground and a difficult thing to navigate whilst allowing podcast producers a way to earn enough revenue to survive. I have to disagree that Spotify are providing podcasts as a convenience. They are building big business on an outlet that is becoming huge. Even if it just keeps its users in its ecosystem then it would be financially beneficial to them.

 

Please correct me if I’m wrong somebody but doesn’t Spotify add adverts to podcasts when listened to without a subscription?

 

So where would you draw the line? Music producers placing adverts in their recordings? If the podcasts are allowed to use the system this way then why not them too? There are many creative ways to earn revenue that aren’t about bombarding consumers with advertising. I’ve never been uncomfortable with a podcast being sponsored. A quick mention of a supporting company. Seems reasonable and actually much better exposure for that single sponsor than ads that people skip and get irritated by. Akin to some product placements in a Netflix show. I’m not overly a fan of such things as I think it cheapens the production but for certain genres it actually doesn’t detract so much. 

Then, let’s not forget that the most profitable avenue these days is from profiling users. We are giving away extreme amounts of valuable data to Spotify and all sorts of companies and platforms constantly. Sometimes in exchange for a product/service but also many times when we are already paying a subscription for a service.

 

I have no intention or desire to belittle anyone’s opinion here. It’s a grey area for sure but one where a certain compromise is surely possible to be found so that podcasts and all content can be enjoyed as they are intended.

 

So please, let’s keep the dialogue going and please join in Spotify team. There’s no harm in some honesty and transparency, it would actually make you more likeable and increase loyalty I believe.

ajdinmore,

This is not about the podcasters, this is about the users of a platform who pay for an ad-free experience.

 

The whole point of this "Idea" is to open the discussion and flag it with Spotify, it is not our jobs to solve it as users. It is most certainly NOT a bad idea. Spotify has figured out ad-free music. YouTube has figured out ad-free music. Apple music/ Google Play etc. Netflix & Prime have provided ad-free movie & TV experiences. We are not asking for the impossible. No one is asking Podcasters to remove ads from all their other platforms. Also, re-read the top, original idea that suggests Spotify create an algorithm to bypass the ads all together.

 

stewey also brings up good points. Here's mine:

I don't know how long you've been a user but Premium users have been told long before podcasts existed that if we pay for Spotify service, our experience would be ad-free. This is now untrue.

1) I am not happy I am paying to listen to ads. If I were using Spotify free as a free member - sure, I support ads all the way. But again, I am not. WE are PAYING money to listen to ads. - Do you not see how messed up that is?

2) We are PAYING money to listen to ads we have no say in. E.g. Offensive ads, covid related, campaigning or other political issues, etc. Spotify cannot intervene with the content of these ads. This is not okay.

3) This opens floodgates for musicians to embed ads, which I also do not want.

4) No one is asking them to stop self-promo within their podcasts, i.e. promoting their Patron (where you can donate money if you truly want to support your Podcaster) or following them on Instagram, etc, I can't speak for all users but the mentioning of these do not bother me.

I think one of things that surprises me the most is that Spotify have managed to step in and replace a huge part of the market where traditional record companies were failing because they weren’t willing to create new strategies for a very changing landscape. I feel Spotify are risking getting stuck in the same rut as them and opening up an opportunity for new competitors to step in.

 

The way and reasons why I personally listen to podcasts are similar to that of a book. Some time to be absorbed into something in a calm and reflective manner and also to drift off to sleep as they help mask my tinnitus. Adverts completely change the tone, pace and volume of things which I find very intrusive and disturbing. We are bombarded with advertising everywhere in our daily lives. Let us have our quality time without interference. Like Donnie says, we are paying for that.

The worst part of this whole b.s.  is that spotify commented themselves and said "they must be using OUR new ad integration software"  if it is your software that allows / promotes this then disable it for people who pay you to not **bleep**ing do it. And don't be so disrespectful and have the audacity to talk it up like it's a proud thing in response to a complaint about that product being an issue

Hey Lgnthmpsm, that sounds like something pretty significant. Do you have a copy or link to that response from Spotify? Apologies if it’s in the history threads related to this but I couldn’t find it.

 

So I’m thinking this “New Ideas” section of a user forum just isn’t the place we are going to  get our voices heard. It’s not even the obvious place for other disgruntled users to seek. The complaint has been going since 2017 and keeps getting reset. Maybe we could use our efforts in better ways and in a joint effort way. 

I appreciate we are all probably in different countries but I’m wondering if this is something that Ofcom should be made aware of here in the UK. Perhaps there are similar complaints bodies for the communications industry in your own countries too?

 

We shouldn’t have to waste our time to try and put right what Spotify have let go wrong. I’m up for doing my bit but soon I’ll be speaking my mind by cancelling my subscription if no response is made by Spotify. Anyone remember how to work Napster again? 😉

Anyone still in doubt whether podcasts are big business for Spotify and not just a generous “convenience”, as suggested by someone previously, should look at this article by Spotify for advertisers about podcasts:

 

https://ads.spotify.com/en-US/news-and-insights/streaming-ad-insertion-podcast-advertising/

That was a link for advertisers in the US. On the Spotify Advertising homepage in the UK podcasts are the biggest mention and selling point I’m seeing. Here is one of their big articles selling the medium to advertisers:

 

https://ads.spotify.com/en-GB/news-and-insights/podcasts-and-the-attention-sweet-spot/

 

So with Spotify’s own words to advertisers in mind, “Podcast fans listen up and take action”, let’s prove them right!

 

I am sure the podcasters love that ads are being forced down listeners ears through their integration **bleep**. The only way to not get these **bleep** ads, is to not listen to any podcasts. So sorry podcasters. I specifically pay for premium for no ads, now I get to hear ads from PowerBall!! and multiple times in a row!!!! AWESOME!!!! 

I'm confused. Wouldn't this require Spotify to fund every podcast so that premium users can listen without ads? Seems unfeasible, unless they hike the price on premium to cover the costs. Most of these podcasts are uploaded to multiple platforms and the funding they get from sponsorships are likely way more than what Spotify could pay. As a premium user, you're paying Spotify to remove THEIR ads from THEIR platform. If you don't want to listen to the ads, just skip forward like 30 seconds (there's buttons for that), it's not like a normal unskippable Spotify ad. If Spotify forced creators to remove ads from their platform in exchange for less money, you bet your ass they're gonna get out of Spotify.

 

In response to one of the other comments on this post, that this "opens the floodgates" for musicians to place ads after/before their music. What? We as a society have decided that podcasts are the audio equivalent of television, and as such, advertisements for free entertainment is understandable. Something has to fund the production of these shows and the wages for all involved (especially when these people make it their day jobs). If you want an ad-free, paid service for podcasts akin to Netflix or Spotify Music, try a different platform like Luminary. They have a premium podcast service that has ad-free shows (of course there's no free listening, though, even with ads).

Whether the ad is from Spotify or anywhere else is irrelevant.

I’m paying Spotify for access to their platform in an ad-free way. Spotify aren’t holding up their end of the deal. I’m still getting ads.

Using a Television ad-revenue analogy in a world where subscription based, ad free streaming services dominate is a weird one.

Spotify paid Joe Rogan $100m for exclusivity to his Podcasts. Funded by... yup, Spotify subscriptions.

I want the ad-free service I’m paying for.

To be clear Spotify are involved in the ad integration on their platform. They are advertising this service to advertisers. They are claiming it to best thing since sliced bread to them. I’m totally up for advertising in exchange for listening but not when I’m paying a subscription to remove ads. And yes, I will be looking elsewhere for an ad free podcast service if Spotify don’t clean up their act in this regard. As a consumer that is what I desire and see value in paying for. Just as I’ve always supported the BBC license fee here in the UK. I’m sure society will force this in time, I just wish Spotify would recognise this before they become the next victim of complacency.

This. 100% this. When I started listening to Daily Wellness there weren't many ads that I noticed. Now it interrupts every time I'm ready to settle into the next calming or meditative section. Largely don't listen for nearly as long as I used to.

 

While we're at it, CHANGE UP THE MUSIC already. I've listened to the same batch of songs for months. Really, really annoying.

Lastly, take out the "Up next: A few songs" and "Take a break" tracks. No one needs these and, again, they are distracting and take away from the overall mood and intention of the playlist.

 

Thanks for hopefully listening.

I actually started listening to podcasts on Spotify because a few of the podcasters I like mentioned they get more revenue when listeners tune in via Spotify. So I feel torn–I really want to support the podcasters I listen to, but also, as a Premium subscriber, don't want to listen to ads. As Montesi called out, the experience of skipping over ads is also very tedious...I would love to not have to do the 15 sec forward, 15 seconds back dance...

 

If it's a question of revenue for Podcasters (which is maybe an optimistic thought), I would also be more than happy to pay an additional fee every month for a higher tier Premium membership guaranteeing no podcast ads. I understand when Spotify developed their Premium membership there weren't podcasts, and so this new use case might require a shift to the membership structure. I just want to throw my two cents in and encourage Spotify to address this issue!

Child Item
Child Item