[Desktop][Playlists] Save scroll position during drag and drop

There is an existing Fixed issue, "[Desktop] Scroll position not saved when navigating through pages", that is related to but is not the same as this.


Problem: You are on desktop. You have a very long playlist, and you want to add a song in the middle. (Simply dropping the song on the playlist, or using the "Add to..." menu item would add the song at the end, which means I would have spend on the order of a minute slowly dragging it up to where I was.)


Before the redesign, you could scroll down to the middle, go to the album or whatever you want to add a track from, and drag, hovering over the name of your target playlist. Your playlist would then be re-opened at the point you had scrolled to.


There is not a way to do this anymore. You can navigate back and get to the same point in the playlist you were viewing previously. You can drag and drop songs into a playlist. But you cannot do both at the same time! The possible ways of navigating back are:


- Click on a button

- Press a key combination (Ctrl+Alt+left arrow for me)


But those aren't available because a drag and drop operation is in process -- the mouse is in use, and the only key you can press is Escape.


Currently, the only workaround is to Ctrl+C with the desired songs selected, navigate back to the playlist, and Ctrl+V. This has no feedback at all if you are doing it correctly, and for me, completely freezes the client for a very long time when pressing Ctrl+V, on the order of 5 seconds. Music playback does not stop, at least, but the UI doesn't draw at all. It seems to get slower with multiple tracks.


This could be fixed if instead of only remembering scroll position for the history stack, it was remembered for all playlists opened in the current session. I only have a few hundred playlists, and cannot imagine opening more than a few thousand before restarting the client. There can't be a technical limitation preventing the client from storing a few thousand numbers (consider that music is two channels of 44.1 or 48 thousand numbers per second...).


I've had no luck in the original thread that was marked Fixed, so I would appreciate at least some acknowledgement that I'm not making this up, and that the official position is that you must use the undocumented Ctrl+C hack.


Plan: Premium

Country: US

Operating System: Linux

Version: 1.1.68.632.g2b11de83

Child Item
Status: Active
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Updated on 2021-11-07

Hello and thanks for submitting your idea to the Idea Exchange!

 

We've gone ahead and marked this as a new suggestion. Spotify Staff will look into this idea once it reaches the necessary amount of votes.

 

We've slightly changed the title to make it easier to find and understand.

 

More info on how your feedback reaches Spotify via the Idea Exchange can be found here.

 

Cheers!

I have huge playlists. I want to be able to drag and drop new albums in the middle of such playlists.

This was possible before the last versions of Spotify:

- I navigated to the correct position inside the playlist

- I browsed Spotify to find the album to add

- I drag the album on the playlist

- the songs of the playlist were shown from the point I left them (for example, songs 510-530 of 2000)

- I could drop the album in the correct position, immediately.

 

Now there is a problem: when I drag the album on the playlist... the visualization of the songs inside the playlist is restarted from the beginning of the playlist, and the scrolling is really slow, so I waste 20/30 seconds for every album I want to add in the middle of it.

 

This is awkward, who changed this functionality? Can you restore it?

Updated on 2022-02-06

Hey @maeveynot 

Your Idea has been submitted a while ago, and unfortunately hasn't gathered enough votes (50 votes within 3 months) to keep it active in the Exchange. Be sure to know that this does not mean that your Idea has been declined by Spotify.

Don't worry, your Idea will still be able to gain more votes, and may get a Live Idea status if it receives enough of them.

For more info on how the Ideas Board works, click here. 🙂

Child Item
Child Item