Unexpected playback control syncing when multiple macOS users logged in

Plan

Premium

Country

UK

Device

M1 MacBook Pro 2020

Operating System

macOS Monterey 12.1

Spotify Version

Spotify for macOS (Apple Silicon) 1.1.74.631.g0b24d9ad

 

Steps to Reproduce

Bob = Spotify Account 1

Jill = Spotify Account 2

  1. Bob logs into his own macOS account and opens Spotify logged into his own account
  2. Bob locks macOS account without quitting Spotify and continues to listen to Spotify on another device logged into his own account
  3. Jill logs into her own macOS account on the device Bob has just left and opens Spotify logged into her own account
  4. Jill starts listening to music using her Apple Airpods
  5. Jill removes Airpods, not only does Jill's music correctly stop playing, Bob's music on another device unexpectedly stops too
  6. Jill inserts Airpods again, not only does Jill's music correctly start playing, Bob's music on another device unexpectedly starts too
  7. Jill uses the spacebar to play/pause, this does not affect Bob's music

Doubt it makes a difference, but just for extra info:

  • Both accounts are on the same premium family plan
  • Issue is experienced at least when all devices are on the same network

 

 

Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Accepted answers

All comments

Hey @jtsalva15,

 

Thanks for reaching out to us in the Community!

 

Could you confirm there weren't any playback issues for both parties prior to connecting the Airpods? In other words, can you play music without interruption if Jill isn't using her Airpods? Feel free to also let us know which troubleshooting steps you've tried so far so we avoid repeating them.

 

If you haven't already, try switching to mobile data to see if the issue persists.

 

Keep us in the loop.

 

Cheers!

Hi @Elena

 

There are no playback issues prior to connecting the Airpods. I have already tried the obvious troubleshooting steps. For example, restarting devices.

 

Thanks for your help!

Hi @jtsalva15,

 

Thank you for your reply and confirmation.

 

Can you try to re-pair the pods with the device to see if the issue persists?

 

We'll keep an eye out for your reply.

 

Take care!

Hi @George,

 

Yes we've tried re-pairing multiple times, the issue persists.

 

I'm confident the issue is not related to the specific Airpods we're using. But at least any Apple head/ear phones that automatically play/pause depending on whether you're wearing them or not.

 

Thanks

Hey @jtsalva15,

 

Thanks for your reply. 

 

Just to make sure, is this also happening if Bob logs out of the Spotify app on the PC before locking the macOS account?

 

Additionally, we'd like to know if you've already tried with a different pair of headphones to check if the same happens. 

 

We'll be waiting for your reply. 

Hi @Eni

 

No, this does not happen when Bob logs out or quits the Spotify app.

 

Yes, also tried with the Airpods Max. I believe this issue occurs for any Apple head/ear phones that automatically play/pause depending on whether you're wearing them or not.

 

Thanks

Hey @jtsalva15,


Thanks for the reply.

 

This is most likely related to the Airpods, in which case there is no setting within the Spotify app. which can manually adjust the signals they send.

 

What you can try doing is to forget that the headphones on all devices and then re-pair them only on one of the devices to try this. 

  • On your iPhone, go to Settings > Bluetooth and tap the More Info button next to your AirPods.
  • Tap Forget This Device, and tap again to confirm.

If the issue persists, try connecting some devices to a different network, like a mobile hotspot.

 

Keep us posted on this.

Hey @Alex

 

Thanks for taking the time to look at this.

 

To be clear, the headphones are never connected to multiple devices so I do not think that's the solution. Jill has her own headphones connected only to the device she is using. Whether Bob is or is not using headphones doesn't affect this issue either.

 

Thanks

I believe the root issue here is a bug in the Spotify app, either it is:

- not sandboxed properly between macOS user accounts

- or is wrongly listening to headphone insertion/removal events when running in the background of a locked account and another macOS user is logged in and listening on their own Spotify account

Hi @jtsalva15,

 

Thank you for your reply and sharing those insights. 

 

After examining all the information you've shared, we can conclude that this isn't a bug. Instead, the issue lies in the fact that Bob isn't quitting Spotify before locking the PC user. 

 

In this case, it's advisable that Bob quits the app if he is not expecting to return to the device in a while, especially when sharing said device.

 

Nonetheless, we appreciate this feedback you share with us. We'll make sure to pass it on to the right teams, but please be aware that there might not be much we can do, depending on how the app is currently built or how MacOS handles the pairing with music control and playback devices.

 

Let us know if you have any questions.

Child Item
Child Item