Hello! I have a reoccurring issue with my collaborative playlists. I often make my playlists collaborative so that my friends can add songs instead of having to tell me what they think I should add. This works well and I love having input from my friends, but strangers keep adding songs that neither myself nor my friends want in there. If I make the playlist secret, it stops being collaborative. If I make it collaborative, it becomes public so anyone can add. I've had this issue with several playlists and find that it ruins my listening experience. I think it would be amazing if you could make playlists collaborative without opening them for anyone to add. It would allow listeners to enjoy a playlist made with whoever they want while also adjusting it to themes or styles as they want, which is similar to the blended playlists but not the same since those are random and changed often. Thanks for your time and the chance to provide feedback!
OK, after digging through a bunch of other posts on this (lots of people are frustrated about this!), I found one was closed because it was a duplicate to another one. This appears to be the master post on the topic, and fortunately Spotify is working on a solution:
I have a playlist with a group of friends and yesterday someone in our class came on and deleted all 11h of music and my friends and I were gutted. We spent 3h on a call rebuilding the playlist. Today, another person decided to add 420 songs which we then had to delete. I’ve now been forced to turn off collaboration in fear that someone with deliberately sabotage our playlist again 😞 exclusive collaboration is a much needed feature please!!!!!
Updated on 2022-02-14
Hey @laynesigmon,
Thanks for bringing your feedback to the Idea Exchange.
We’re closing this idea since it doesn’t meet one of our Idea Exchange guidelines, namely “Checking for existing ideas”.
A similar idea has already been suggested here- feel free to add your vote to it!
If you think your idea should be considered as separate, feel free to submit it again highlighting how your idea is distinct from the existing one.
Cheers!
This is driving me crazy too! Me and a friend carefully curate our collaborative playlist (now at over 380 tracks) only to have others start adding songs to them. What really confuses me is that the feature we are requesting was apparently there before. Here's a response to a thread back in 2018 telling us to simply make sure the playlist is set as "Secret":
https://community.spotify.com/t5/Accounts/Shared-private-playlist/m-p/4400959/highlight/true#M1485276
Nothing there about "secret" now. The only thing I can see is the ability to choose to either "Add to profile" or "Remove from profile" which is only available before the playlist is collaborative. Once it's collaborative, that option is grayed out. The online help for collaborative playlists has no help at all on this. I keep hoping we are just missing something here, as this seems a rather obvious need.