[Desktop][Playlists] User Option For Raw PseudoRandom

Going through a list of tracks in random fashion is a complex problem due to the need to avoid replaying the same song twice in a row.

Ideally, we would want to completely avoid re-playing a song before all tracks of the playlist have been played once. Spotify seems to use an algorithm that is really good at doing so for small playlists, but with the drawback of always outputting a concerning subset of input when used on large playlists.

The recent changes (apparently? Wouldn't know since it's random, but it seemingly started converging differently from a couple months ago) made things slightly worst, to the point where friends that are way less of power users as I am come to me wondering how random play can be messed up so bad (where previously I would be met with disbelief when complaining about spotify's random).

Since the problem cannot be fixed for large-playlist users without impacting casual listeners, I think the simplest approach would be to add a user-enabled option to use raw pseudorandom either

1. at all time ([yes/no] setting)

2. for playlists over [X] tracks

Alternatively, Spotify could hardcode the X limit, thus removing the need for a new configuration and still fixing the issue seemlessly for most users. (e.g. start using raw pseudorandom for playlists of 666 tracks or more)

I believe this might also lower load on resources when playing large playlists, which were reported not to work properly on some platforms in the past.

Thank you and have a great day,

Child Item
Status: Active
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Updated on 2023-01-04

Hey @Geged66,

 

Thanks for bringing your feedback to the Idea Exchange.

 

We’re closing this idea since it doesn’t meet one of our Idea Exchange guidelines, namely “Checking for existing ideas”.

 

A similar idea has already been suggested here - feel free to add your vote to it!

 

If you think your idea should be considered as separate, feel free to submit it again highlighting how your idea is distinct from the existing one.

 

Cheers!

Child Item
Child Item