Add basic day one features to podcasts

Podcast treatment in the Spotify app is currently really really bad. There seems to be some internal conflict within the app, like there's a pair of gremlins fighting over whether podcasts are their own thing, or if they're just "long songs". In some aspects, the app treats podcasts as special. Podcasts are presented as "shows" with episodes rather than albums with songs. Autoplay doesn't mix podcasts in with music listening (or vice versa). There's some first class treatment of podcasts, like suggestions on the homepage when new episodes come out. This is all fine and good.

However. There are some other ways where the design seems to have completely ignored the stark difference in expected experience when listening to a podcast, compared to listening to music. Recently, the app has begun to do something unfathomably strange with podcasts; when reaching the end of the latest episode of a podcast, it will randomly start playing some other, tenuously related (at best) podcast automatically. Autoplaying music after a playlist ends is perfectly fine, it's honestly a great way to discover new music that's similar. But for podcasts? I can't imagine a single person on the entire planet ever wants to finish listening to the latest episode of their favorite comedy podcast, and then with no warning, no prompt "we suggest this/would you like to listen to this", just instantaneously start playing some wild-ass heavy bias political podcast they've never even heard of. 

At the absolute very least, autoplay should be disablable. And just to preempt, yeah sure it's technically possible to do so in settings, there's only one global autoplay setting. I already mentioned, autoplay for music is great. I find tons of new music with it. But with music, at worst if I don't like the song all that much it's only there for a few minutes. If it's just kinda whatever, you just let it play, because you're driving and in a couple minutes another song will play. You might skip, or if you really hate it you can just hit dislike and it's gone forever (or at least, you could, until very recently. This was a bad move. Everyone disliked that. Put it back). Listening to podcasts is entirely different. Autoplaying some random podcast after the one I chose to listen to is like if I was reading a book on my kindle and instead of ending at the end of the book, the last sentence is immediately followed by the start of another completely unrelated book that I didn't even add to my library. It's nonsense. It's bad UX for the only option to be to go to the settings page every time I switch between music and podcast listening, just to toggle the autoplay setting. There needs to be separate autoplay settings for podcasts vs. music, at least, though I'd honestly say just nix it for podcasts entirely. Suggesting related podcasts in something like a "more like this" section would be fine, I don't think anyone is opposed to finding new stuff they might like, but when it just suddenly starts playing without any sort of consent, I don't care how much I might like it, it's unpleasant to have the abrupt mood change into something I didn't even ask for.

And to be honest, if not for this next issue, the previous one might not even be that bad (still poor user experience, but lower impact), but:
Podcasts being treated sorta like music (autoplay) but also sorta like it's own thing combines in a really patently terrible experience due to the way "liking" or following podcasts is different than liking music or albums. The fact that you can even like individual episodes of a podcast is already a little weird, but more specifically.. it doesn't really seem to matter. You can't "dislike" a podcast, but apparently liking/following it isn't really important either. Regardless of whether you have or have not followed the podcast, regardless of whether you have or have not liked an episode of the podcast, regardless of whether you have or have not LISTENED TO ANY EPISODE FOR EVEN TWO SECONDS, AND ONLY BECAUSE IT STARTED AUTOPLAYING, spotify plops it on your homepage under a big allcaps "YOUR SHOWS" label, FOREVER. No way to tell it that no, this isn't one of my shows (following and unfollowing affects your library, which for some indefensible reason isn't the same thing as "my shows"), no way to say no, actually I hate this podcast, nothing. Removing the ability to dislike or otherwise remove a song from suggestions is bad enough, but ASSuming that I'm automatically in love with any podcast that's ever downloaded a single packet of data through my account, and want to be notified of every new episode from now until the end of time? Not even music does this in spotify. There's no "mY moST FAVorT moOSaCs" section with songs I've never listened to on the homepage. No "epIsODes FoR yOu" from artists I've never followed.
Who approved this, and how many hallucinogens had they taken just before the meeting. No one is going to take spotify seriously as a podcast platform if there's zero way to control your own podcast/episodes feed.

This needs fixing, as soon as physically possible. As a fellow software engineer I know, a single dev could fix all of this within a few hours at most. Trust me, there is not a single person out there that will listen to a podcast that's forced upon them, for any reason. No matter what hair-brained, cocaine-fueled quick-money-scheme was envisioned to rationalize this design, this will do nothing but push podcast listeners to other platforms. To be very clear, it's gonna be real hard to make any money without any paying users.

Child Item
Status: Closed - Does Not Meet Requirements
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Updated on 2024-05-12

Hey @EthanReal,

We’re closing this idea since it doesn’t meet one of our Idea Exchange guidelines, namely point 3: “One change request per Idea.” and point 5:“Making sure your idea is clear”.

When one post includes several feature requests, it becomes hard to keep track of and update them. Therefore, please submit any suggestions you may have one at a time and describe the feature in a short but clear and concise manner. We appreciate the personal touch, but all the additional information that may or may not be relevant only makes it more difficult to determine what the request actually is.

Feel free to submit a new idea - just make sure to familiarize yourself with the above guidelines.

Thanks for understanding.

Child Item
Child Item