"Remove From Playlist Button" for Artists

Artists who get added to robot playlists gaining thousands of streams from one location are requesting a button that will allow to 'remove from their content from suspect playlists. Also to stop the user from playlisting their content the future. Also to report the playlist and the user

Child Item
Status: Live Idea
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

This would be awesome addition, often when indy artists report a playlist that looks fraudulent, it can be because they were added to that playlist by the playlist owner, without being asked, as a reason to get the artist's attention to their 'service'. Generally their services will be to pay for, which is outside of Spotify's TOS. There seems to be an assumption that if an artist appears on a fraudulent playlist, they have requested it, when in fact there are predatory companies that will do this to promote their 'services' further. Indy artists will do everything they can to ensure the stream they get are from 'proper' user playlists with real people listening. The longer an artist remains on an unwanted/fraudulent playlist (one that is linked to a pay for plays model) the higher the risk of having a track removed, no indy artist wants this, so being able to protect ourselves by removing our music from a bad playslist is key. Especially whilst Spotify does not give artists a chance to resolve problematic streams.

Yessss. This 100%

Desperately need this. 

Yes! Please!!

Desperately needed!

This is desperately needed!

 

Spotify are allowing third parties to take down musicians music.  This is unacceptable.

It’s definitely needed! 

Artists should retain the option of removing their music from predatory playlisters plain and simple. And SO simple to implement, and would restore faith and integrity to Spotify as a platform for smaller indie artists who are the most susceptible to being victims of this.

 

 

Would be great to be more in control 👍🏻

While this is an issue because of predatory practices, it seems sensible to allow artists to remove tracks from playlists (and in theory would save Spotify/distributors from having to issue takedowns, which means less admin all around).


Failure to give artists this type of mandate is to prevent them from being proactive during what is clearly a problem for both sides.

Absolutely.  My band got bot-swatted late last year and even though WE reported it to Spotify and did what they instructed, Spotify/Distrokid removed our song a couple months later and tech support was rather rude about it.

Please encourage others to help protect all artists, present and future, by casting a vote. I appreciate everyone who agrees this is an idea worthy of adopting. It will add a layer of protection to artists, who in turn are policing a problem on behalf of Spotify. That's a win-win. Thank you for making your votes and voices count 

This idea sounds like it could help you guys out with avoiding fraudulent streams. My only worry is the potential for abuse by an artist who may not like a legitimate playlist (for whatever reason) or the playlist curator (for numerous potential reasons). As an avid listener and playlister, it would be incredibly discouraging if an artist didn't allow me to list their song because of a personal reason.

Hi, twangy_stuff. You have a valid concern. I'm not an artist or promoter. I'm a playlist curator like yourself. I love all artists because they make our planet a more beautiful place. It pains me to hear first-hand accounts from artists, taken down after being added to 'bot playlists'. Technology plus greed equals our status quo. This problem isn't going away and will only get worse. I can't see how an artist can gain by removing themselves from a legitimate playlist like yours or mine and if they do they'll be hurting themselves. I would give that scenario less than a 1 percent chance of happening. On multiple occasions, I've playlisted a song (and you would have too), that is playable one day and greyed out and unplayable the next. This may have occurred because the track was taken down after fraudulent streaming. So by encouraging support for this idea, I believe there will be fewer greyed-out tracks in the future. 

Hi ASKRATA1. Thanks for the thoughtful reply. Actually, I've never had a song I playlisted grayed out because of suspected fraudulent streams. The only time I've seen songs I playlisted grayed out is because the artist removed their music of their own volition or because of a dispute between the artist and the publisher. I focus on the roots genres, and some examples I can think of are Dwight Yoakum's album Guitars, Cadillacs and Rodney Crowell's Diamonds and Dirt. Both of these were removed because of label/publisher disputes. I also focus primarily on independent/underground artists with my most popular playlists, and I've checked with the artists whose songs were grayed out. The reasons I was given were because of future re-release, lost login info, and just plain not wanting a particular piece of music out in the world. There are a lot of reasons for music being grayed out, but it is also very rare that I come across this. Fraudulent streams seem to be less of a problem in the country/americana/roots world, because of how much it's frowned upon by artists and listeners alike in the community, and it's probably a bigger deal in other genres.

 

I also have to completely disagree that it would be uncommon for an artist to ban their music from certain playlists. Image is a huge factor for most artists. There are many reasons for artists only wanting their music on certain playlists. I actually was watching a video a few minutes ago about the "Discovered On" section on artists' pages. I just happened to notice a comment from an artist that is a perfect example of how chaotic and unfair it could become, if artists have the power to remove their music from user playlists. Here is the link:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rGE2-9LsV4

This person is aggravated because their music is on a playlist they don't like that is showing up on their "Discovered On" section.

 

I also don't think this would be remedied by doing away with the "Discovered On" section for the artist page. As you probably know, an artist can see every playlist their music has been added to, even if those playlists don't show up in the "Discovered On" section. It is a valid concern that some artists would abuse this power. I want to eliminate fraudulent streams and playlists as much as anyone else, but I also don't want my playlists touched by anyone's hand but my own. I would stop using Spotify altogether, if this was allowed. I paid for the service, and I should be able to curate my playlists however I want.

 

Hi, twangy_stuff. Thanks for sharing the video link. It is insightful and I appreciate you for sharing. In the comments section of that video. The comment from user @24sl4l42, "hwo do i get off of these playlists the discovered on playlist i was added to was not something i wanted on my artist page" cuts deep into what I'm trying to achieve with this idea. I need time to research this artist's gripe. He is stating that he wants to be removed from those playlists. His solution depends on how to edit the 'Discovered on' section. Or can he choose not to display the 'Discovered on' section in his profile? I can't do this do myself because I am not an artist. I want everyone to be happy here. So any artist reading this post please go to your artist page on Spotify and let me know if you have any control over what appears in your 'Discovered on' section. Or can you choose not to display it? It pains me that this scenario, which is still hypothetical, could prevent a solution to real harm occurring today. I want to respond to user @24sl4l42 directly with the solution he seeks. So any artist.seeing this please confirm what if any control you have over the 'Discovered on' section of your artist profile 

This is a necessity. 

I have attempted on several occasions to convince Spotify employees to remove my songs from botted playlists. 

The only response I’ve ever gotten from Spotify is that it’s against their “policy” to remove songs from a user’s playlist without their permission… Which I find hilarious, because they can identify the streams as bot streams, but won’t delete the playlists. lol 

The only problem with this approach is that even when you do actively report a bot playlist to Spotify, they will STILL take down your music. I noticed I was added (without my consent) to a bot playlist and reported it as soon as I noticed it. I was even told that my music would not be negatively affected because I reported the playlist. They STILL TOOK DOWN MY MUSIC! Spotify DO A BETTER JOB.

@wavecollector, Agree! That's why I would love to be able to just simply remove it if I spot it. At the moment we're entirely powerless in this scenario and have no way to defend ourselves.

Agree this would be a great idea. The botted playlist we are on keeps reappearing under a different link. I'm guessing Spotify takes it down and the curator puts it back up.  I've reported this playlist now 5 times to Spotify and gave them the link to his profile.  When i looked the curator up on the internet I found complaints about his botted playlists going back 3 years. One would wonder why he is not suspended. Meanwhile we have about 10,000 fake streams on our song all from Finland with an average streams per listener of 14. I'd like to think we're a superstar in Finland but I know better. Spotify needs to do more.

YES! This is a MUCH needed feature, I'm sick of writing Spotify everytime one of my songs gets added to one of those "playlists" A report button or something would be very useful.

This should’ve been implemented years ago. Now is the time

Commenting simply to express support for this feature. My song was removed by my distributor today due to Spotify identifying fraudulent streams which, wouldn't ya know it, came from some random playlist run by scammers. Words cannot describe how discouraging it is: first, that this happened through no fault of my own, and second, getting an interminable runaround from both Spotify support and Distrokid. After putting hundreds of ours of work into something and so carefully and thoughtfully promoting it by exclusively legitimate means, getting the rug pulled out from under me by any random stranger with a few pennies to spend on bots is just sickening. Having no recourse is the insult on top of the injury. PLEASE SPOTIFY, TAKE NOTE AND ADD THIS FEATURE. It will save you the administrative headache and save small artists from a helpless, discouraging situation.

Happened to me as well but luckily DistroKid will allow you to resubmit your song. If you use the same ISRC code as the original release your streams will be restored. However you may wind up on the same booted playlist. If so report it to Spotify. In my case Spotify took down the playlist but the spammer kept putting it back. I had to report him multiple times before the playlist finally disappeared permanently -maybe they banned him.
Child Item
Child Item