[Mobile] Get rid of 'Create' button on mobile navigation bar

marcoslaporte8_1-1729535408614.png

I recently got the last update, and found that a fourth button was added to the bottom navbar. What's the point of this? It's in the way of entering 'Your Library' section, as this was the default spot for that button.

Besides that, does it really need to have a shortcut? How often do people create new playlists or blends? There's already a button for that in 'Your Library', so...

I think removing this button will improve UI.

Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Yes! Atleast give us the option to enable/disable it.

Muscle memory has been messed up because of this addition. Please remove it and put "Your Library" back there.

Please yes. The library button is also moved on IOS in the menu bar, in favor of an "add playlist" button that I now click constantly. I am not sure I understand the decision to place such a rarely used button (for most) in a prime location on the screen... on the other hand, I use the "library" button pretty much every single time I open the app.

Please remove this, Library is something I open on a daily basis. There is really no need to place something like add playlist is such a prominent place. 

I sure hope they revert this, Spotify keeps giving me reasons to stop my membership. Broken shuffle, 'smart' shuffle, and now this..

why would you clutter the space with this useless button when its right there in the top right when you click my library??? spotify keeps degrading their ui with every year smh

The most useless button ever. I tap on it so much that it’s annoying. It seems an innovative idea for the ones who make a lot of different playlist on a daily basis but they should reconsider it. 

This is just terrible UX. There's no reason to have the option to create a playlist on the same level as access to library, home and search. No one creates playlists so often that it should be there. Have you been looking at analytics of bots creating a ton of playlists every day and then coming to the conclusion that this button must be what the users want?

 

Plan

Premium

 

Country

Germany

 

Device

iPhone 11

 

Operating System

iOS 18

 

My Question or Issue

Can you please remove this new rightmost tab button to create a playlist?

My thinking is: How often do you want to visit your library vs how often creata new playlist. For me it is something lik 99:1. I'd wager you must have an internal challenge who can break muscle memory of the most users because really this is a ridiculous change.

remove it or put 1 place to the left

put the 'library' back in the corner

I mistakenly open the create button already 1 million times, VERY VERY annoying!

nobody asked for this monstrosity 

get real and remove it or - at least - give the option to the user to remove it!!!!

 

It’s the worst idea ever to put it there. Stop ruining UI and UX we’ve learned so far…

Hey @thedafelix,

 

Thanks for posting this thread in the Community!

 

We really appreciate you sending this screenshot, as well as explaining in detail your opinion on how the app looks like for you at the moment. Keep in mind that from time to time you may see something that your friends don't on Spotify (and vice versa) and that would explain the plus-button.

 

We're always testing improvements and new features as we always strive to improve and offer better functions. Thank you once again for expressing your feedback. 

 

Should you need help with anything else or if you've got any questions, we're here 🙂

Thanks @Ivelina!

 

Sorry for being so harsh in my original post, I was just frustrated in this moment.

I understand that you do A/B testing but it's also not great being a "test subject".

This was a bad idea in 2022: https://community.spotify.com/t5/Your-Library/How-to-remove-plus-button/td-p/5352581 and it still a bad idea in 2024. A lot of people have muscle memory to quickly navigate to their library/playlists which now leads to frustrated clicks on a button that we do not need.

Remove it or at least move it to the centre. My library should be in the corner, muscle memory is tough to beat.

This is just so bad. At the very least allow us to configure the bottom buttons instead of just forcing us. I loved having library at the rightmost, it made the most sense 

 

I go to my library waaaay more often than I create a playlist. This decision was just nonsensical.

Please temove the create icon. We are so used to have library there.

I wonder if Spotify devs actually consult users before making these changes?

 

Please undo this change. Literally everyone I speak to says the same thing, this is not a good move. At least give us the option to remove it, if you are so set on keeping it. It's really annoying. 

The newest Spotify update has added a create tab to the bottom navigation on iPhone and has moved the location of where the library button lives.  This got me thinking, what if you could customize the navigation? To be able to swap out the create button with other frequently used options, like maybe you don’t create playlists often, but you want a quick link to something else? Or to be able to add/remove an option. Like home search and library always stays the same but you could have the option of adding one or two more items to the navigation. That’s one feature I wish we had control over in other apps like YouTube, I wish we could remove the YouTube shorts tab as it’s majorly addicting. 

You can create a playlist from LITERALLY any song or page in the app, why on earth did they think they needed a button for this???  Do people who work on this app use it?????

 

I agree, not only is it a terrible UI choice, it's also completely useless just like shuffle on this app.  Even if I did create a playlist with that button, will I be able to add songs to it?  No.  Why is it occupying one of the most vital parts of the UI then?  Just let me see my library please

 

Remove the add button to the bottom right, it's just stupid, nobody is creating playlist every day, everyone wants to access their library, it's the worst idea since looping a song automatically by default, don't know what the UI team is thinking, i will do myself a present and start using tidal next year.

This is so annoying why does Spotify always screw with people’s muscle memory for no good reason? I will almost never use this create button. At least make it customizable or is that too difficult for them to figure out?

The new "Create" button in the bottom right of the navbar is very frustrating. From a UI ergonomics perspective, and for right-handed users, the most commonly used action is definitely expected to be placed there. The button can be pressed without looking, unlike the library, which has now moved to an off-center location of the navbar. At this new position, the library button is very difficult to hit. In various situations (walking, running, driving), this is incredibly annoying and one of the worst regressions in Spotify for years.

 

 

We are robots when it comes to pressing buttons. The Library button has been moved to the left but my thumb still goes to the right and I now accidentally click the Create button, its very frustrating. Please move it back to the right, just literally swap it with the Create button. I always think main buttons should be on the edges anyway.

Child Item
Child Item