Spotify "resolved" the issue of true shuffle. now the thread with 6000 likes of support is gone and/or private, and the shuffle is still broken.
here's some comments that got deleted post shuffle "fix"
"I have posted here a few times and expressed my opinions about the overabundance/UNREASONABLE amount of repeats. I have been on the bandwagon and dispaired of anything being done about it because, as stated before, it HAS to be about money."
"Pure random shuffle is not an acceptable solution, IMO, and this new "fewer repeats" doesn't seem to be either. Maybe Spotify isn't implementing a true shuffle because it would result in them having to pay more royalties to more artists?"
"Anger is appropriate given in their last statement they act like they've not only listened to the community, but shuffle has actually always been pure randomness. Ridiculous..."
"Well, first day with the new random option and on a 16 hours playlist, I've heard the same song 3 times in the same hour and the artist played 5 times in the same hour. So obviously, nothing has changed. I guest we will have to wait another 5 years before they gave us another update on this one 😔"
"Agree with recent posters. The algorithms for pseudorandom/random including state/cross-session/history management were not rocket science 10 years ago when this was asked for, and definitely isn't now. And now they've introduced a marketing speak, "YOU ASKED, WE LISTENED!", non-requested feature that still injects 'Spotify contract black box logic' for some non-user reason. Yawn."
"On a playlist of 9,228 songs, I experience almost no change or difference
from what has been happening for years. I still see the same clump of songs
one after another, even after I skip them."
10 minutes ago there were 99 pages of comments on the main thread. all of my previous comments have been deleted
Team,
really you need to overhaul the shuffle mode. Even with "less repetitions", I also encounter the issues as described above. The solution should be some kind of list all played songs in shuffle mode are saved in. And only if all available songs have been played and thus were put into that list, should it start again.
BR
Definitely not a unique idea, see lots of posts already asking for this, and most of them say "Implemented" when they are clearly not.
Make shuffle be RANDOM. I have 3k songs in one playlist, and I feel like I only ever hear 60 over and over.
And yes, the cache has been cleared, fixes nothing except the DJ for maybe an hour, then its back to playing nonsense and music I would NEVER listen to, but since it plays it once, it assumes I now likes that music and slips it into everything.
Whoever implemented all the algorithms and automation should be canned.
Spotify has Implemented shuffle modes like standard and fewer repeats, but honestly, since I’ve had this feature the same songs in a playlist of over 163 hours is still repeating the same damn songs. There are songs in my list that I know I have not heard and I just want an actual randomized shuffle option so that I can go through my playlist because I’m starting to get sick of some of the songs cause I hear them so often almost every day the same ones play doesn’t matter which shuffle option I have on.
Updated on 2025-12-02
from Spotify:
Hey everyone,
Thanks for coming to the Spotify Idea Exchange and sharing your feedback.
We're setting this idea to Implemented with the introduction of the Fewer Repeats shuffling option which takes your recent listening history into account and can be found in Settings - Playback - Shuffle mode. Check out this For the Record post for more info.
Once again, thanks for helping us make Spotify better, by participating here on the Community!