Local files inconsistently recognized across devices

I recently learned that WiFi syncing of Local Files is a deprecated feature, so I switched to trying to sync local files from my PC to my iPhone using the new method described here. I'm mainly focused on a playlist I have that contains only 42 local files, which I had created and populated on my laptop. I transferred the exact same files to my phone using iTunes, but for some reason, when I opened the playlist on my phone, the app only recognized 22 of the 42 tracks as now being available through my phone's Local Files. The remaining 20 were grayed out, telling me that my phone didn't recognize that the file for that track had become available through my phone's Local Files. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to which tracks weren't able to be identified: they're all throughout the playlist, across multiple artists, not in consecutive alphabetical order by title, etc.

 

I wondered if there was maybe something in the file metadata that was affecting Spotify's ability to identify some files. But I tried to add five new files just yesterday:

  1. I converted each track from YouTube, trimmed the MP3s, edited their metadata, and attached album artwork, using the exact same suite of sites and software for each file
  2. I moved the files to my Libraries\Music directory, which is where my Spotify Desktop app pulls Local Files from
  3. In Spotify, I added the five new tracks to my playlist
  4. I connected my phone to my laptop (USB-C to Lightning cable)
  5. Using iTunes, I copied those exact same 5 files into my iPhone's Music folder
  6. I opened the playlist on my iPhone
  7. Three of the five tracks were identified as now being available on my phone; the other two were not, and remain grayed out

Given that I followed precisely identical processes for each file, that tells me this can't be an issue with anything I'm doing. Each of the tracks is a similar length (11-14 minutes), and none have special characters in their titles or in any other metadata fields.

 

I can add all the unrecognized tracks to the playlist on my phone, but that annoyingly means I have a separate "PC version" and "phone version" of each of those 20 (now 22) tracks in that playlist, with each only being playable on one device.

 

Is there any way to force Spotify to reconcile files to fix this? Something like "locate track in library" option? This feels like a file-identification bug in how Local Files is built.

 

Plan: Premium (Family)

Country: USA

Device #1 (PC)

  • HP Pavilion
  • Windows 11 Home, version 25H2
  • Spotify for Windows (64 bit) 1.2.95.453.g0eeebbed
  • iTunes Version 12.13.10.3

Device #2 (mobile):

  • iPhone 11
  • iOS 26.6
  • Spotify app version 9.1.70
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Accepted answers

All comments

Hey, @cerickson,

 

Welcome to the Spotify Community!

 

Could you check if moving all local files to Files > On My iPhone > Spotify instead to see if that would work? If you can't find the 'Spotify' folder there, make sure you've enabled access to 'Media & Apple Music' for the app or try rebooting your device and it should show up.

 

This article goes in-depth on how to set up local files, I'd recommend checking it out if you haven't already.

 

Hope this helps. Let us know how it goes 👍

Child Item
Child Item