The homepage is feels bloated, it needs to change.
Hi,
I'm Geoffrey, and I was a long time user of Apple Music, and musics — from my experience — get a regional lock (at least in France) and/or are simply removed from the Apple Music library quite often for some reasons.
After some times passed troubleshooting with the Apple support team and friends who use Apple Music, we found no cause for my issues.
So I switched to Spotify and started creating an account, which is when I immediatly started to get frustrated :
Firstly, when creating an account, as someone who listen to random musics from random artists, the step where you have to select three artists/music styles in order to get targeted music suggestions, followed by another page where you have to select three podcasts — all this without a skip button — just feels overwhelming, especially in a process already as boring, tedious and annoying as creating a new account.
And then the homepage, which immediatly overwhelms my eyes whenever I open it.
It feels so bloated and "shoved in my face" :
It feels more like ads in Times Square on a glass building than a highly curated selection of snacks proposed on a silver plate. And one that really annoys me is that I can't disable the recommended podcasts list, which makes me regret the Apple Music layout.
Now, some propositions to solve aforementionned issues :
- Firstly, when creating an account, new users should be able to skip all steps asking you to choose three artists/music styles/podcasts, even if it means showing the most generic music suggestions worldwide or based on his location/country.
- Users should be prompted whether or not they want podcast suggestions. Some people come to and/or use Spotify solely to listen to their musics and nothing more : from what I know, most of my friends use a separate app for podcasts or prefere reading interviews and stories rather than listening to them (I did ask when they introduced me to the service.) There are even people on this forum complaining about podcast suggestions.
Lastly, a few design suggestions for the homepage :
The homepage feels... dead. And the
The covers of the suggested content are so colourful and send so many different emotions, yet the background feels so empty, which create harsh transitions between covers, lists, and the background.
As a solution, I suggest giving more freedom over the homepage layout :
- Recently listened albums, titles, playlists, and artists should be at the top for easy access,
- Suggested content would come right after the recent category, with or without podcasts.
- Dynamic background depending on shown content colours, similar to the background changing colour depending on the music, or even let the user choose his own background with a picture or some suggested ones. And to keep titles visible, make the background a gradient which would progressivly get "contrastier?" with the title colour. This would make the app so much more welcoming when opening and browsing through it.
To get and idea, I suggest you take a look at the apple home screen, which still looks blank, but and look at how much more welcoming it feels to have just a bit more colour around titles and pictures, and the Recent category coming right after, making navigation so much easier.
Thank you very much for reading until the end, it took me a really long time to write in a language that is not my native one, you may forgive me (and correct me) if there are some spelling/grammar mistakes, I am still learning English,
Have a good day.