JJ's Bizarre Blog #89 - The Gothic Invasion of Romance

Salutations, my fellow creatures of the night! Due to circumstances around our transition between worlds, the latest Bizarre entry is coming a little earlier after the previous, but ultimately on schedule! Since we are dead in the middle of October, I need to give you something a little spooky to commemorate. And I do believe I have just the thing! We shall explore a genre, a subculture, an aesthetic born of darkness and the macabre that strives for beauty and romance in the shadows of the heart. Let us join hands this night as we dance our sorrows away! Put on your make-up and nail polish, dye your hair, get out your leather and fishnets, open your grimoires to page 666 and let us plummet into the wild and wondrous world of gothic rock!

I'm sure that one way or another you've heard of gothic music or goth in general. It's quite a prevalent subculture that has had it's place in the world for decades and seems to be having even a slight resurgence nowadays, even if it is the commercialized Temu version thereof, but I digress. At the root of it all stands gothic rock, which is a varied and diverse style that is mostly characterized by following the core tenets and sounds of rock, but striving towards a darker, more eerie sound. Lots of low tuned instruments, minor chords, dense atmosphere with layered effects and use of keyboards, melancholic, somber melodies, etc. However, an underlying upbeat rock energy is maintained, so the goal of the music is to be dark and dreary while remaining danceable. A lot of the recognizable vibe of the music stems from the lyrics, which delve into dark, introspective themes - depression, death, personal anguish, inner struggles, nihilism and the like. Romance is a strongly recurring theme, one of the most common in the genre, usually in terms of failed love, broken hearts and loss. Beyond the introspective, plenty of influence is drawn from general themes of the macabre, the mysterious, medieval poetry, ancient mysticism, horror and gothic literature. Where do you think the genre takes its name from? Gothic in this case refers to dark tales of fear and mystique, of encounters with the occult and the supernatural, ghosts and spirits symbolizing the past refusing to stay buried. Of course, if you know anything about goth, then you're familiar with the dense and rich subculture around it, in particular when it comes to fashion. Suits and dresses in medieval or Victorian style mixed with fashionable youthful clothing, lots of leather, lace and latex, and tons of accessories with recurring dark, magical symbology like crosses, pentagrams, skulls, etc. Deliberately styled hair and plenty of heavy make-up are the norm - pale foundation, dark lipstick, eyeliner, eye shadow and nail polish, for both men and women alike. And remember, EVERYTHING must be in black. If people can't tell if you're going to a Halloween party in a nightclub or coming back from a funeral, you're doing it right. I'm sure that all of you have seen this stuff and can identify the goth aesthetic immediately, even if you don't know what a goth song sounds like. Well, let's correct that latter part then, shall we?

The earliest roots of gothic rock trace back to the late 1960s as music was changing and it was a very dynamic time in many aspects. The first band labeled as gothic was in fact The Doors! I'm sure these legends need no introduction, but it was their darker, more experimental sound and introspective, poetic lyrics that were the first spark of this new movement, the signs of a new revolution coming to rock music. It would be across the pond during the 70s that the true progenitor of goth would arise, this being post-punk from the United Kingdom! A broad and varied genre defined by unrestricted experimentation, avant-garde songwriting and mixture of multiple styles. Despite the decrease in intensity, post-punk remained rebellious and anti-establishment in its own way, creating a parallel counter-cultural movement. The songs were noticeably darker and more atmospheric with lyrics in more introspective fashion. Add in some more instrumental influences from new wave, some aesthetic extravagance from glam rock and the love of horror themes from shock rock and you can see how all the elements that would make up gothic rock were slowly falling into place!

It was in the late 70s and early 80s that the UK birthed true gothic rock! Slowly, nightclubs began to form, creating fertile breeding grounds for this growing subculture! Many of the early bands came precisely from the post-punk scene, taking the guitars drenched in reverb and effects, the use of synths and electronics, the experimental sounds, the unconventional song structures and made the whole thing more rhythmic, danceable yet ever more macabre and melancholic. The lyrics and aesthetic presentation became gloomier, more depressing and drifted farther into proper gothic themes of failed romance, woes of the heart and tales of phantoms, ghosts and vampires. Vocals would usually be sung low, with a theatrical delivery, in a rhythmic, often declaratory fashion. This was the time and the place that gave us Siouxsie and the Banshees, The Sisters of Mercy, The Cure, Bauhaus and many more would go on to create both the sonic and aesthetic foundations of goth, daring fashion choices included. From the shadows, a new force came!

The influence spread quickly and the 80s had no shortage of incredible gothic rock bands that brought this new style to the forefront and continued to innovate upon it. The subculture became strong and stronger, coalescing into something somewhat resembling what we associate with goth today. The UK would remain the biggest hotbed by a long shot, but regional scenes across other parts of Europe like Germany, Italy or Russia started to form as well. While they were never as loud or as brazen as the punks that they often rubbed shoulders with, the goths were proud to be who they are and from their underground lairs (nightclubs, wine cellars, mum's basements), they built their kingdom of shadow! 

It wouldn't take long for the idea to cross the Atlantic and to start evolving into its North American form. It would actually arise in kind of its own way, influenced by the British scene, but also being its own thing. Born out of the American West Coast punk rock scene in the early 80s, this new sound was just as gloomy, dark, melancholic and experimental, which is where it was given the name deathrock (which counterintuitively has nothing to do with death metal, which also arose in the US roughly around the same time). Here, more of the punk roots are retained, so the music is faster and more aggressive, the production more raw and DIY. The term deathrock would be used to label many bands across the US and elsewhere too, eventually converging almost completely with gothic rock as both were ultimately so similar. Many other movements coming thereafter would be influenced by the rise of goth to form their own spooky cults. Such as horror punk, a more straight up punk rock derivative that keeps the upbeat, fast, heavy playing of punk and much of the cut-down, minimal instrumentation, albeit with a dose of keyboards to get a proper spooky atmosphere. Much of the rebellious, political lyrics would be substituted with cheesy references to horror movies and the clothing would become all black with lots of heavy make-up and a tattered, zombie-like appearance. Thus, the goth intersection is quite evident and horror punk has done a lot to spread the goth aesthetic to more and more emerging disciples. For something even more bat crazy, I recommend you look into the psychobilly and gothabilly styles, which took the roots of rockabilly and mixed it with gothic instrumentation and lyrics for a truly zany creation!

From then on, goth kept growing and spreading, coming even more to the forefront in terms of the visual aspects and the overall sound over the 90s. Many of the founding and most influential bands from across the world were at their zenith around this time, so the goths were feasting finely! By the 2000s, the internet was helping to create new havens for the subculture to indoctrinate more youths the elements had begun to spread to other genres and influence them, so genres like alternative rock and nu metal started to visibly and audibly adopt some gothic elements for themselves, expanding and diversifying what being goth ultimately means. Later genres like emo clearly took many of the core principles from goth and ran with it to create their own thing, a revolutionary sound that ended up defining an entire generation and being an unforgettable period for many teens. Emo likewise ultimately traces its roots back to punk just like gothic rock, so it's all full circle!

If you're going to make a genre built around darkness and the macabre, sooner or later someone will want to make it heavier and it would inevitably merge with heavy metal! While some gothic rock purists scoff at metal and think it's the antithesis to the gentle, poetic and ethereal sound they build, even they must admit that Black Sabbath are awesome and that they did the whole dark, gloomy songs with lyrics about horror and macabre mysticism way before gothic rock had even spawned from post-punk! Many other pioneering bands like Iron Maiden, Rainbow, Judas Priest, Mercyful Fate and more likewise get the stamp of approval from goths for being pioneers of dark, medieval music with a driving edge. Gothic metal would truly come into existence in the early 90s, where else but in the United Kingdom! The most crucial band to spearhead it all would be one and only Paradise Lost! They started out as a much heavier death/doom metal band, becoming pioneers of that genre. But, as early as their second album Gothic in 1991, their inclinations were clear. By the next few albums after that one, these gents had fully developed their gothic metal sound - slow, thick, dirgelike riffs chugging away like a melancholic march (still at a noticeably more brisk pace than their doom metal material), enriched by tasteful lead guitar melodies dripping with sorrow, seasoned with the occasional piano or synth flourish and driven by Nick Holmes' incredible baritone voice, switching effortlessly between deep, mournful declarations, aggressive shouts and visceral death growls. With lyrics steeped in darkness and gloom and this unbelievable sound, Paradise Lost crafted a career of legend and fully realized the gothic metal idea, blending the heaviness and intensity of one with the rich emotion and epic grandeur of the other. The dark path less travelled had never seemed so appealing!

Paradise Lost would be joined by their most crucial compatriots - My Dying Bride and Anathema! Together, these three bands would be known as The Peaceville Three, named after the record label they were all a part of. All three emerged around the same time and became foundational to the death/doom genre. All would evolve in radically different directions thereafter. Paradise Lost would go through many phases, perfecting and evolving their gothic sound, but would never forget their doom metal roots, eventually returning to them later. My Dying Bride would likewise retain much of their heavy foundation as they formed their own flavour of poetic, powerful gothic metal, while Anathema would transition into something completely different - a magical and whimsical progressive/folk rock sound with bountiful richness and variety, still with a note of underlying melancholy all throughout. The legacy of these three run deep and span many genres!

It wouldn't take long for the gothic metal might to spread outward, quickly making its way over to Scandinavia and to the metal (and musical) hotbed that is Sweden! There, the mighty Tiamat and the incredible Katatonia would be among the spearheads! They would follow a very similar pipeline to the British bands - starting out with a crushing death/doom metal sound before embracing the aesthetic and compositional elements of goth later on. Tiamat began with some brutal yet captivating bangers about ancient Sumerian poetry, yet began to shift into romantic, introspective and depressive topics. A few albums in, the sleeping beauty and awoken and they had fully embraced this new gothic direction and established themselves as one of the premier gothic metal bands worldwide! Some of the best goth metal tracks of all time are within their catalogue! Katatonia on the other hand were always ones to tread dark and foreboding paths. Starting with heavy and trudging lengthy doom epics, their sound softened over time, developing into an emotionally rich and deeply moving gothic rock blend carrying plenty of progressive rock sensibilities. A macabre, ethereal beauty!

From then on, other noteworthy bands like Lake of Tears, Draconian and more would contribute to the growing Swedish gothic metal scene. Soon, befitting of the cold landscape with endlessly rich musical heritage, Scandinavia and its surroundings became one of the biggest gatherings of the heavy goth contingencies!

Their neighbours in Finland were quick to pick up the mantle and forge their own legacy! The brightest star of this would be the enchanting HIM! Led by the captivating figure that is Ville Vallo with his mesmerizing voice, these lads quickly became one of the most popular and successful gothic metal acts in the world, likewise establishing themselves as standard bearers and blueprints for what the genre should be! Dark and melancholic tunes almost always rooted in withering romance and heartbreak, channeling medieval poetry and classic gothic literature. Low tuned, hard hitting riffs with no shortage of guitar and keyboard melodies on top. They very successfully took the tender and somber core of gothic rock and blended it with a meaner metal edge, creating a style they themselves dubbed "love metal". Many worldwide were successfully put under their spell!

They were far from alone though and Finland would become one of the best in the world with both the quantity and quality of gothic metal bands they produced, in many ways surpassing and supplanting Sweden! From experimentalists like The 69 Eyes with their "goth 'n'  roll" blend, to more macabre tales from the likes of Charon, For My Pain..., To/Die/For, Sentenced and more, the dark, damp, dreary land of the thousand lakes has, for obvious reasons, become the perfect place for the gloomy yet beautiful sound of gothic metal to flourish, grow and prosper!

Not to be left out, Norway would join the dark carnival themselves in spectacular fashion! Their biggest name has to be Theatre of Tragedy, one of the most influential bands the genre has ever seen! They too followed the path of starting out as death/doom metal, standing out thanks to the inclusion of beautiful soprano vocals, courtesy of the phenomenal Liv Kristine, as a contrast to the harsh death elements. Thanks to this, they became one of the earliest pioneers of the "beauty and the beast" vocal style, most commonly expressed through male death growls contrasted with melodic female singing, usually in operatic manner. This kind of approach is a common sight across a lot of metal nowadays but is a calling card especially when it comes to gothic metal. As the band's went on, they would pivot more noticeably into gothic metal territory, embracing the somber beauty and heavy emotions the genre brings and thus becoming a staple of the scene! After them, other Norwegian bands like Tristania and Sirenia would embrace a gothic sound with a symphonic touch, both following Theatre of Tragedy's lead with some fantastic female vocals!

The rest of Europe were quick to catch and wherever breathtaking gothic architecture stood, sublime gothic metal appeared! In Germany, the Neue Deutsche Todeskunst was a localized movement during the 80s that helped establish German language gothic rock and cemented the strength of the scene! The implementation of traditional poetry, philosophical quandaries and overly theatrical presentation became staples of German goth. Stemming thereof, several bands like Atrocity, Crematory and Pyogenesis came from different metal genres and among all their wild experimentation, all coalesced into gothic metal. The similarly sounding but ultimately distinctive Lacrimosa from Switzerland and Lacrimas Profundere from Germany (both coming from the Latin words for "weeping", very fitting names) fully embraced the oldschool gothic approach and became one of the new forerunners of goth across Europe! The former channels German-language poetry and a more classical music touch to create somber operatic odes, while the latter carries that ever present doom metal heritage that gives them the proper potent melancholy!

Moving south, we reach Italy, some of the most prominent masters of gothic architecture and it turns out the music followed suit as well! Their biggest name is by far the unstoppable Lacuna Coil, who are not only one of the biggest and most successful gothic metal bands ever, but one of the biggest bands in today's metal as a whole and one of the biggest Italian metal exports! With simple, punchy riffage bearing a hint of metalcore and melodeath and led by the amazing duet of Andrea Ferro and Christina Scabbia, Lacuna Coil are one of the prime examples of "beauty and the beast" executed to perfection! Their songs are incredibly catchy and memorable, yet carry that palpable darkness and never shy away from delving into despair. A perfect example of how goth manages to be fun and somber at the same time! Lacuna Coil are far from the only Italian contribution of course - in fact, it seems they really love vampires over there and while they are a very common theme across goth, they are especially common here. Bands like Theatres des Vampires and Lord Vampyr being some of the premier Italian gothic metal acts and bringing forth some of the bloodiest and most captivating vampiric tales through their music!

Voyaging off west to the very terminus of Europe in Portugal, we meet one of the greatest bands to ever bless the gothic metal genre - the one and only Moonspell! You'd think this beautiful, sunny Iberian country wouldn't be conducive to such dark music, but you'd be dead wrong! In fact, a recurring theme across Portuguese folk and traditional music is the feeling of "saudade", meaning a longing for something or someone forever lost, a melancholy over that which will never be again. Moonspell embody this emotion perfectly! Starting off as a folk-tinged black metal outfit but quickly adapting the path of goths, to me these guys are the perfect embodiment of what gothic metal should be! Comparatively simplistic instrumentation, but a rich, dense atmosphere. Enveloping guitar accompanied by keyboards galore, especially church organ and orchestral flourishes. Songs are dark, enveloping, enchanting, ready to take you on an otherworldly journey. Heavy and dense, yet melodic, going from slow and dirgelike to epic and invigorating! Fernando Ribeiro's deep bass-baritone voice is incredibly rich and beautiful, one of the most velvety smooth and gallant voices you've ever heard, yet he can switch to beastly growls when the song calls for it. His presence is a glorious centerpiece for the entire symphony of darkness around him! The lyrics he delivers are perfected poems about the macabre, full of medieval mystery, turbulent emotions, dark fantasy, occult secrets, stories of vampires and werewolves, romantic declarations and more! Moonspell are the pride of Portugal and no other band even comes close! They have truly mastered the gothic metal art and have rightfully earned their place as one of the most successful bands in all of modern metal!

Now that we’ve reached the coast of the Atlantic Ocean, we might as well cross it, right? As we arrive once again on the American coast, it's no shocker that goth has taken up a significant stronghold here, given everything the deathrock movement has done for gothic rock as a whole. Not to mention that shock rock, horror punk, emo and more were always focused here. When it comes to gothic metal, there's plenty to choose, but there is one band that stands above and beyond all others - Type O Negative! Despite their incredibly dark and sinister lyrics, delving into the most depraved and depressing topics imaginable in a completely unfiltered manner, they've become one of the most commercially successful goth bands in history! Many of the other bands already discussed admit to using Type O as their template! Their music is some of the richest, most engaging and most brilliantly composed not just in goth, but in all of metal! A fine blend of gothic and doom metal with lingering aspects of thrash among other things, Type O have some of the greatest guitar riffs in all of goth - simple, instantly recognizable thanks to that crunchy tone and completely unforgettable! The keyboard work is subtle, but pure genius and adds so much depth and melodic richness to the experience! But of course, the centerpiece is the breathtaking Peter Steele, the mastermind behind this wild bunch! His booming bass voice is an unmistakable blend that nothing else compares to, yet he brings such an unbelievably varied and diverse delivery, going from low singing, to Gregorian chants, to high notes, to deafening screams, making it all look effortless! Thanks to his depressing, sometimes sarcastic lyrics, fascination with the occult and horror movies and of course his towering presence, vampiric presentation and raven-black hair, Peter is a true goth icon and has done immeasurable work to furthering the genre and spreading the subculture worldwide. You're welcome to check out the full blog I made about his entire body of work, both to learn just how deep that legacy goes and the full, rich, tragic story of the man's career!

By this point, goth had gone global and the subculture had gained its now established recognition. Its distinct sound and appearance were inspirational to many, so lots of bands that aren't gothic metal per se were incorporating elements of it into their own identity. Most famous of these would have to be the one and only Nightwish! These Finnish maestros are one of the biggest metal bands in the world and while the most recognizable part of their sound is the dense and layered symphonic implement, they draw quite noticeably from gothic metal in terms of guitar work, lyricism, melancholic vibe, even a little bit of the fashion. British phenomenon Cradle of Filth are quite huge themselves and they found their signature sound by mixing their symphonic black metal roots with the foundations of gothic metal, creating a dark and enveloping feel, exceptionally atmospheric, creepy and horrific, but with tunes that are quite fun and pumping, allowing them to reach a significant audience. Dani Filth's side project Devilment (very underrated!) presents a similar idea, but instead of black metal, you get lots of rhythmic Pantera-style groove metal riffage to go along with the gothic vibe and shadowy theatrical lyrics! On the other side of Europe, you can find the exceptional Rotting Christ from Greece! While they are fundamentally a black metal band at heart, they dabbled quit extensively with gothic metal in the middle of their tenure and while they've since swung back firmly into black metal territory, the goth influence is still present, allowing them to forge a very unique sound that is exclusively their own!

Like we mentioned before, nu metal has been intersecting with goth for a very long time and by the late 90s, many artists had managed to become icons of both! Prime among them is Marilyn Manson, Dark King of nonconformity, his heavy industrial sound, controversial lyrics and bold presentation made him an immediate hit and a core part of the rising nu metal movement. However, he clearly incorporated a lot of gothic fashion into his iconic look, playing a pivotal role in popularizing it to many worldwide. By the mid-to-late 2000s, he had embraced goth in terms of sound as well, along with dark romantic tunes, introspective musings, tales of ghosts and vampires, occultism, etc., properly immersing himself in the full spectrum of goth in all facets! Right alongside him, Evanescence are a prime example of the gothic/nu metal fusion! Dark, catchy tunes, vocal mixes, a rich atmosphere, they had it all and like Manson, Amy Lee is a modern goth icon that helped spread the macabre appearance to teenage girls all over the globe! Thanks to people like them, while many in the nu metal era chose JNCO genes, spiky hair, flame patterns and skateboards, others chose the black eyeliner, nail polish, leather pants and gloom. The two competing aesthetics are forever intertwined.

Of course you've noticed by now the repeated mentions of doom metal. Doom and goth arose in different eras and in completely different ways, the former being the heavier Black Sabbath interpretation of hard rock and blues, the latter the darker evolution of post-punk. But regardless, the two have always been similar and given how close they are in their mission statements, vibe, emotion and overall sound, the overlap has almost always been there and both have mutually inspired each other in more ways than one can measure. Many of the most iconic and influential gothic metal bands have either dabbled in doom metal or outright come from it. They often get freely categorized as both, gothic/doom metal, simply because the distinction is pretty hazy and the main difference is maybe the heaviness and just how slow the slow songs really are. Both love down tuned guitars, trudging beats and bountiful keyboards. In general, rule of thumb is that doom metal is the slower, more depressing and harder hitting of the two, while gothic metal retains the original idea of goth rock of being dark and gloomy, yet still catchy and danceable, staying noticeably more upbeat that your usual doom foray. By this point though, it's very hard to separate the two and you just can't have one genre without the other.

Lastly, going even beyond rock and metal, unlike many movements goth actually has a third contingent - the electronic realm! All the way back in the post-punk days, mixing in electronic elements and experimentation was not uncommon and many artists ended up pivoting that way. The darkwave movement is a gothic division that mixes in new wave elements with the tenets of goth to create a dark and atmospheric sound along with all the usual mystical lyrics. The result is a varied and diverse sound that can range from programmed folky/symphonic sounds like the so called neoclassical darkwave of bands like Dead Can Dance, or a more club oriented darker form of synthpop. It has spawned its own sub-movements such as cold wave and ethereal wave, which seek to further explore the desolate, atmospheric and eerie vibe that darkwave can create. There's significant intersection with industrial music too, as it also employs depressing lyrics and visuals to contrast a danceable rhythmic sound and both also like dark, outlandish fashion, so the intermixing that began in the 80s has created a whole separate subculture around electronic goth! It's no stretch to say that the darker electronic genres of dark ambient, darksynth or dream pop can trace their roots back to here!

Lastly, it would be remiss of me not to mention cybergoth! This is quite a unique phenomenon that rose from the 90s, less a specific music genre and more of an aesthetic and a pure subculture for clubs and social gatherings. Many people took the core ideas of gothic fashion and added in lots of cyberpunk, rivethead and steampunk elements - neon colours like green, yellow and pink, fluorescent/glow-in-the-dark components, goggles, plastic "dreadlocks" (called cyberlox), fluffy fur leg warmers, techy gadgety accessories and very famously using decorated gas masks as a regular fashion accessory.  Not gonna lie, I think it's one of the coolest aesthetics out there and when you really commit to the bit! In terms of actual music, the main goth link is with darkwave and its spinoffs, though cybergoth actually leans more towards industrial, EBM, futurepop, rave, aggrotech, electronic hardcore, etc. Basically, danceable electronic bangers that are still dark, edgy and kinda transgressive in presentation, carrying a vibe and sound befitting of a cyberpunk nightclub. This is counter-culture after all, but cybergoths do still famously love to dance!

So there you have it, the definitive deep dive in the world of gothic music! I'm gonna be honest, for the longest time, I didn't get goth and wasn't really into it. I liked the aesthetic but the music didn't resonate a lot. There seemed to be a gaping disconnect between all the separate things labeled "gothic" - architecture, literature, music, fashion, etc. But I always had the interest, as Paradise Lost have been a beloved band of mine for many decades! So when I discovered bands like Moonspell, Type O Negative and Tiamat, gave them the proper shot and found how they exactly matched the "gothic" vibe I was looking for, I finally understood. I saw the connection and I felt the heart of the music properly. So I hope that with this blog, you now do too. Yes, the music is dark, creepy and often depressing, but there's heart and soul to it, it deals with some of the most precious and deeply human things ever - love, fear, sadness, anxiety. And it does it in a poetic and theatrical manner that feels epic, it's an enveloping kind of experience that really immerses you in everything happening. It likewise carries a kind of ancient feel, like reliving a magical tale from centuries past, something we believed to be long lost, yet still it lives on today! The past refusing to stay buried! Also if you just love horror, creepy stories and anything occult and mysterious, you'll love it here! Perfect for Halloween season (or making any season Halloween season)! And as you can see, goth comes in so many shapes and sizes that I'm sure you'll find something that's the right fit for you. If ever until now you found gothic fashion to be cool and interesting, if ever you've wanted to try it, go for it! Now that you have the understanding of the music and the whole culture around it, you can do so without just being a larper and really live what it means to be a goth! Stay safe out there, my dark disciples! Tread carefully, but don't be afraid to venture forth! Take care of yourselves and I'll see you all again soon! 

Check out all Blogs in The Index!

Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Child Item
Child Item