Show Placeholder for Unavailable Albums

I often use Spotify artist pages as a source of reference or information. I like being able to see an artist's entire discography over their career. But when there are a bunch of holes in terms of what music is available on Spotify and what isn't it makes for some confusion.

Some examples would be The Black Keys' Turn Blue or Coldplay's Ghost Stories. Neither album is available in full on Spotify - only the singles.

I would prefer for the artist page to include the album, and simply leave the unavailable tracks greyed out. That way Spotify artist pages can truly act as a reference for an artist's discography, and we can stop jumping back and forth between Spotify and Wikipedia.

 

EDIT: pnc has pointed out that this idea has already been implemented on the desktop version for a few select albums. Since it's already a possibility, I'd like it to become more widely used (as there are still a ton of albums that it isn't being done for). I'd also like to see it shown on mobile versions as well.

Child Item
Status: Active
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

@mdewater ,

 

I think we already got this feature. I can view the whold song list of The Black Keys' Turn Blue or Coldplay's Ghost Stories and can play one or two. You can try uncheck the box Hide unplayable tracks in the setting to see if anything change.

 

Capture.JPG

@pnc 

 

Good call! Shows how much I use the desktop version I guess! Thanks for pointing this out. It looks like a few select albums do indeed have exactly what I'm talking about on the desktop version. There's no sign of it on iOS though. Are they on Android?

 

That said, it looks like it's only select big-ticket albums that have released fairly recently that have placeholders. There are lots and lots of albums that don't show even on the desktop version. Some examples:

 

The Black Keys - El Camino

U2 - Wide Awake in Europe (and countless other live albums and singles)

Michael Giacchino - Super 8 (and tons of other soundtrack albums)

I'd also extend this idea to include the big artist holdouts. The Beatles, Garth Brooks, ACDC, etc.

 

I just found this article talking about it (focuses on Coldplay, but also mentions others) here: http://musically.com/2014/05/20/coldplay-ghost-stories-spotify/

 

I guess since it is something that is already used in some cases, I'd simply like it to become a more widely used feature, and also be able to see it on mobile. Does that still count as an idea? Haha

Thank you for your idea. 

When it comes to showing albums that are not available on Spotify, there is already a similar idea here:

http://community.spotify.com/t5/Spotify-Ideas/Complete-discographies-on-artist-s-page/idi-p/99747

 

As you can see by the comment this will unfortunately not be implemented. Notice the 'Case Closed' status. 

If one or a few tracks from an album is available in Spotify, the rest of the album will show, but as you've discovered, with the rest of the tracks greyed out. 

 

 

Child Item
Child Item