Last client update was november 2011

Hello,

 

I've asked around (facebook, twitter) and nobody answered me. The Android client is a real piece of **bleep**. 

It's hellishly slow. When someone sends an album or a playlist to my inbox, I can"t access it from my phone (single tracks only). The RAM usage is just ludicrous, so as soon as I open any other app, without playing music, Spotify closes, and since it takes 4 mn to boot and be usable, it's a real pain.

 

Seriously people, I know iPhones are the main trend, but android users are numerous enough to spend a few thousand bucks on a client update, dontcha think?

 

I give you 20€ every month (two accounts, one for me, one for my wife) and I expect a certain quality of service. Every day I pester against your android client, and I seriously think about closing both of my accounts.

 

At the very least, please give me an estimated time of update.

Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Accepted answers

**** yes !! i completely agree with my friend !!! but the question is : Will Spotify do something about that request before 2013 ?

Trying Grooveshark myself! Looks great so far 🙂

The worst thing about it is spotify support's answer: "check our blog regularly"... What a scam.

 

Anyone knows if spotify employees actually read this forum?

David, if you can't explain how or why it works then I don't think you should be proposing it as a solution. It just makes it look like you are stalling for time because you actually have no idea what the real problem is.

The IT and the technology industry is built around science and logic, not blind faith.

Spotify and Vogons! Love it FLuffle!

Also, I'd like to add something to my laundry list of complaints on the last page (because it surely must seem slightly incongruos that my first post on the Spotify community forums is a criticism of a service I have already cancelled):

I want to like Spotify. I want to use Spotify. I want to pay for Spotify. The service (library, desktop app, ability to play mp3s, social integration, internal apps) is the best out there, bar-none. The Android app, however, is so bad that it negates all of it, and the silence from Spotify on the issue just drives it down further.

 

Infrequent, vague forum posts are laughably insufficient when you have a customer base of tech-savvy twentysomethings at your disposal. We want a regularly updated dev blog, we want work-in-progress UI mockups, we want to be invited to participate in alpha and beta phases so we can help you troubleshoot what's broken and perfect what isn't perfect. That may sound like asking for a lot, but the reality is that we get that all the time from app developers... many of whom don't ever so much as ask for a cent of our money to use their apps (save for dev donations which I readily make). Why can't we get that from Spotify?

 

We complain because it's frustrating to see Spotify - a service which many of us have publicly lauded and sold friends and family on - turn around and give us a big, silent middle finger.

Completely agree. Can't +1 you enough. It's the general silence and lack of a proper communication plan that just adds annoyance on top of the already poor app.

 

I asked one of the mods a few weeks ago via email whether there was a beta test group and said I would be willing to join and sign whatever NDA was necessary, but was told no such thing exists. I can't imagine the group of Andoid devs is that large at Spotify ... and therefore can't understand how they can possibly test the app before release to ensure that it's going to work and be stable on as many different phones running as many different versions (both stock and rooted ROMs) as exist - my company has enough trouble testing our own software and we dictate the hardware our customers use.

"We complain because it's frustrating to see Spotify - a service which many of us have publicly lauded and sold friends and family on - turn around and give us a big, silent middle finger." ... up the ****, gravel included - and please pardon my french.

All comments

Indeed. And it would be a way that we oculd actually be productive and helpful.

 

And anyone who knowingly installs an experimental beta really cant complain if it doesn't work perfectly. And like I said for most of us it doesnt really work at all now. So what have any of us got to lose?

 

http://community.spotify.com/t5/Spotify-Ideas/Release-a-ICS-beta-Spotify/idi-p/37113

Maybe they are not even in beta.

an official statement of a moderator both in this thread and in the 50% off thread ( link ) would be nice.

I'd say that is unlikely. THey probably have to (contractually) be circumspect i'd imagine.

I wrote an article as guestblogger on the well known german techblog mobiflip about the android/spotify situation:

 

http://www.mobiflip.de/spotify-fuer-android-eine-schwierige-beziehung/

I have stopped paying premium. And I will contact my credit card/bank and say that they have to withdraw payment to Spottily since December 2011. Because what I have been buying has not worked.  When I started as premium user everything worked fine, the last months it has not worked (crashing, buggy, online/offline issue, synchronizing problem for offline use), one function I will like in the next release is "sleep timer"....

 

 


Subscription cancelled

Your Spotify Premium subscription has been cancelled and will expire on 2012-05-01.

Like with anything else you purchase, don't pay for something that doesn't work.

quotation: "Dein Spotify Premium-Abonnement wurde gekündigt und läuft am 2012-04-11 ab.

Danke, dass du Spotify benutzt hast!"

It just says that the subscription is cancelled and will expire on April, 11th. My ICS-device will be here soon, so I thought it would be better to cancel beforehand. I'm waiting for the update, in the meantime, I will listen to my own collection of music only. It should be sufficient in amount and variety, so I won't regret this step too soon.

Just found some more articles on the issue:

 

About.com

Social Barrel

Online News Today

Droidmatters

 

 

I have also cancelled my premium subscription. After nearly two years of paying it is with great frustration, but the Android app just isn't working and I have no idea when a working version will be released.

 

I will continue with the desktop app for a bit until I find a competing service (with a working Android app) to migrate to.

 

It's a sad goodbye from me, Spotify, as I've been a loud promoter of the service for a long time now. I just hope, for your sake, that everybody else doesn't come with me.

 

M

I feel it necessary to chime in, even though I actually got fed up and cancelled my subscription about a month ago (after dealing with the bugs and lack of features for 6+ months assuming stupidly that fixes/improvements were coming).

 

My primary reason for paying for Spotify was to get mobile access, and for Android users... calling that app "mobile access" is downright insulting. The Spotify content is great, but an Android app that (sort of, sometimes) provides access to music is not sufficient if the UI is glitchy, unstable, feature-weak garbage.


My complaints include: frequent crashes, inconsistent UI (e.g. long-press functionality varies depending if you search a song explicitly or find it by browsing to an artist/album first or select it from an existing playlist), no library sorting options, no gapless playback on local files, service outages unrelated to mobile coverage - the list goes on. These are ongoing too - updates appear to be minor and in 6+ months have yet to fix core flaws with the app.

 

As a customer, I feel ignored, as anyone who has had the misfortune of using the Spotify mobile app should. For $10/month, that's not ok. The endless bug list and abhorrent customer service (limited to the occasional forum post of "watch the blog" or "reinstall the app"... is that a joke? It's insulting.) and, let me stress this, a total lack of formal communication from Spotify indicating that they are actively doing anything... is just pathetic. Having a "community manager" occasionally chime in on the support forums is not customer service. It's below the bare minimum, and frankly I'm embarassed that I kept floating Spotify $10/month for as long as I did.

 

May I also add that in the time since I left Spotify, I have tried several of the primary competitors. Rdio, MOG, and even Grooveshark's Android apps all, in every concievable capacity, all dance circles around the disaster that is the current Spotify Android app. I heartily recommend that those frustrated with the total lack of service do a little comparison shopping.

If Spotify won't listen to us when we speak, maybe they'll listen when we stop sending them money.


@BBSpeed26 wrote:

a total lack of formal communication from Spotify indicating that they are actively doing anything... 



We have mentioned that our team are working on improving the Android App here.

With all due respect David, that is not really formal communication. It is a message tucked away somewhere within countless pages and threads of people complaining.

 

A formal communicaiton is a blog post on the Spotify Blog saying that yes, we acknowledge that a lot is wrong with the Android app, we hereby apologise to our paying customers for having to wait so long, our mistake, please hang on a little while longer and we'll give you a very cool revamped and properly working app, and much speedier updates from now on. That's all it takes, and it is kinda baffling for all of us that Spotify doesn't do that.

All the planning charts and demolition orders have been on display at your local planning department in Alpha Centauri for fifty of your Earth years so you’ve had plenty of time to lodge any formal complaints...

+1 Fluffe hahahahaha 

I bet the assholes are going to act just like Apple and claim all this positive stuff about the new app and completely disregard all of this and not apologize.

Their legal department probably doesn't allow 'sorry', because that would mean acknowledging that there is a problem, which some people might use as a reason to start a lawsuit. Sad that things work that way.

And with all due respect to David, the sentence immediately following the one from my post that he quoted was "Having a 'community manager' occasionally chime in on the support forums does not constitute customer service."

 

To me that is about as bare a minimum as I could possibly imagine, and the attitude that, "look, you're wrong, we said something... buried in a private forum... a few weeks ago... and you should think that is sufficient" does nothing but cement my negative perception of Spotify's (lack of) customer service towards their paying Android users.

@Fluffe hahaha ! 

 

@David that's nice to read. I may have a bad eyesight, but even squinting like a sharpshooter I can't read any mention of a roadmap. Usually, when I tell my boss "I'm working on it", what I really mean is "Sorry mate, no can do just yet.." 

there're a few features and bug fixes requests on the forum. List them, get your devs in a scrum session, evaluate complexity of the issues, give them each a resolution schedule - and no, that doesn't mean adding "soon" in the ETR field - then publish the updated list.. And we'll all be the happiest little pigeons you've ever communicated with.

Spotify and Vogons! Love it FLuffle!

Also, I'd like to add something to my laundry list of complaints on the last page (because it surely must seem slightly incongruos that my first post on the Spotify community forums is a criticism of a service I have already cancelled):

I want to like Spotify. I want to use Spotify. I want to pay for Spotify. The service (library, desktop app, ability to play mp3s, social integration, internal apps) is the best out there, bar-none. The Android app, however, is so bad that it negates all of it, and the silence from Spotify on the issue just drives it down further.

 

Infrequent, vague forum posts are laughably insufficient when you have a customer base of tech-savvy twentysomethings at your disposal. We want a regularly updated dev blog, we want work-in-progress UI mockups, we want to be invited to participate in alpha and beta phases so we can help you troubleshoot what's broken and perfect what isn't perfect. That may sound like asking for a lot, but the reality is that we get that all the time from app developers... many of whom don't ever so much as ask for a cent of our money to use their apps (save for dev donations which I readily make). Why can't we get that from Spotify?

 

We complain because it's frustrating to see Spotify - a service which many of us have publicly lauded and sold friends and family on - turn around and give us a big, silent middle finger.

Completely agree. Can't +1 you enough. It's the general silence and lack of a proper communication plan that just adds annoyance on top of the already poor app.

 

I asked one of the mods a few weeks ago via email whether there was a beta test group and said I would be willing to join and sign whatever NDA was necessary, but was told no such thing exists. I can't imagine the group of Andoid devs is that large at Spotify ... and therefore can't understand how they can possibly test the app before release to ensure that it's going to work and be stable on as many different phones running as many different versions (both stock and rooted ROMs) as exist - my company has enough trouble testing our own software and we dictate the hardware our customers use.

"We complain because it's frustrating to see Spotify - a service which many of us have publicly lauded and sold friends and family on - turn around and give us a big, silent middle finger." ... up the ****, gravel included - and please pardon my french.

So I stopped my subscription 3 weeks ago and I have also convinced 4 of my friends to do the same.

As me they were not at all impressed by the android app, but as me they did not know that there are excellent alternatives to use.

Wimp, deezer etc.. 

 

So this unrest about the android app is spreading. What are you going to do about it Spotify?!?!


@David wrote:


We have mentioned that our team are working on improving the Android App here.



This is ridiculous. Are you seriously thinking a comment in a forum deep down the internet is enough for all the problems we have with the android app?

I mean, we are paying 10 bugs a month to use this app and this is all we get from you as solution for the problems. "There will be an update of the app...in the future...maybe"...and parallel you're releasing one new feature after another for the windows/iphone/web-client.

Do you have some android developers or is this a "hobby" for spotify?

When you read the post from erik hartwig (http://www.spotify.com/de/jobs/people/erik/) on the spotify homepage, it sounds like a "hobby":

"We had two master thesis students that had built a prototype, but it was far from production ready. Me and a friend here at Spotify happened to have iPhones, so we ended up on that project"

When you have professional android developers it should be a thing of days to fix the most important bugs in the current version (I know whereof I speak, I myself am an android developer). Why don't you fix the most important bugs in the current version and parallel (or after that), release a major update with polished style and new features?

I mean, if you only have "normal" software developers, it should be easy to give them the android documentation, which is really good, and they should be in the position to fix the most urgend and biggest bugs in the current client.

I don't get it...

I have today cancelled my premium membership.   Spotify will not work on my new phone.

Sorry - get an Android app that works and I might come back - that is if one of your competitiors does not tempt me in the meantime.

swordsman2007 - I see you've posted the same thing a number of times on the board. While your comments itself are fine, duplicate posts will be removed in accordance with the community guidelines. 

If he doesn't repeat himself how does he know you hear him?

 

Seems like you all are ignoring Android users.  Considering its the largest portion of the Tablet and mobile phone market in the US, its a huge share of income that will be lost due to folks cancelling accounts.

 

Luckily I have WP7 as well and use that (the app there is fantastic) but I would prefer to use my Asus Transformer instead, as its what I use to stream Pandora, iHeartRadio and so forth. 

Wait, are you telling me Windows Phone's app is better than Android's? ****? 2% market share?

 

and I have to agree with schmak0&, David. We'll comply with the forum rules once your team complies with our demands for a stable service we pay good money for.

Heh, the WP7 app is actually REALLY **bleep** good. one of the best apps I have used on the phone.  Still no pandora, but it does support HTML5.

Child Item
Child Item