It would be awesome if it was possible to give a personal rating to your songs and albums (and artists), and then sort them after it in your playlists.
Hope to see it in the future, it shouldn't even be that hard.
Thank you!
It would make curating Playlists a lot easier. I'm on my car, listening a playlist and the current song don't quite fit the playlist. Rating the song would give me the opportunity to latter review it, remove or reconsider.
I coudn't agree more. Let's make a movement and tell others that we know to vote for this idea.
Send this link to all your friends that uses Spotify and ask them to support our cause.
https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/Music-Personal-Rating-of-Music/idi-p/179102
@gallandjc wrote:
Hello. Frankly, this is a basic feature very convenient and implemented in most of competitive solutions... It is not a "Not Right Now" but a "No Brainer"...!
It's been done many times.
But feel free to try again. @__spo__ #givememy5stars or something 😄
So today I was dismayed to discover that you changed the new-ish feature that allows us to tell you if we like or don't like a song in a curated playlist, like Discover Weekly. Before you had a very nice system where I could tell you that I like a song or not... and if I liked the song, I had a choice as to whether or not it was added to my song library. Well this morning this has changed so that if I tell you I like a song, I am FORCED to place it in my library (now called "Favorite Songs"). This doesn't work at all because I've basically reached the 10,000 song limit in my library! So now I am not able to tell you I love a song (which leads to you curating better playlists for me), because if I do, it will max out my "Favorite Songs" playlist! So you just made a new feature MUCH worse than it was. All I can do now is add the songs I like to a playlist (until I fill that playlist up with 10,000 songs too), but you'll never know that I love the song, and I assume this will lead to me getting really crappy curated playlists again. 😞 Honestly Spotify, every time you do something good, you manage to counteract it with a terrible decision. It's super disappointing.
Same here I do not like that I am forced to place a song into my playlist only becaues I want to tell Spotify I like the song.
Can we get an update from spotify on this? How do we do that?
A much needed feature, can't believe it's still not here.
Setting a more granular ratings per song/album is needed.
I'd like to know if it's a song I like or a song I really like and be able to search for my five-star songs.
@atava wrote:I confirm that I'm in the process of switching to Apple Music.I'm writing all of this for those concerned and yes, also out of aresentment towards those making decisions at Spotify, who don't seem to usethe service as much or in as diverse ways as we do.Cheers from Italy,Antonio
I would do the same thing if it wasn't for being stuck with a family membership.
Thanks Antonio for your thoughtful write up. I agree with you that Spotify does not cater to those who love music and want to curate a collection. I have only stayed with it as a means to discover new music, and do most of my listening to music through other means. I've long ago given up hopes of Spotify addressing this and adding the ability to rate songs. I also use auto playlist functionality on my other music systems (but with out a rating system, auto playlists are pretty useless so never really pushed for them on Spotify)
Rating music is such basic functionality that the only reason that I can come up with that they do not address this is so that they can cut down on licensing costs and stream music that they want to feed us, as opposed to the music that we want to hear. From your post it seems like Apple Music is now just a better system. Initially, the other services catalogs could not compete with Spotify. But it seems like times are a changing....
Updated on 2018-10-02
Hey folks,
Thanks for coming to the Community, and adding your vote to this idea!
We're marking this idea as 'Not Right Now' again for the time being, as this isn't something we have any immediate plans to implement. We appreciate you sharing your thoughts.
If we have any new info to share, rest assured we'll check back in here with a new status.
Thanks.
Sure... like they've ever put any serious thought into this.Even if half the community wanted a rating functionality they would set itto "Not Right Now", either because of pressure from the music industry orbecause they just don't care.Developers nowadays either can't envision the best features for theirsoftware when they have the chance to, or they're just gutless,money-driven employees for some major corporation.I really miss the 90s.Anyway, thank you for taking the time to write a few lines.Sorry for the rant, and see you everybody.
@Melody: I'm active in this idea community since years and I never saw that any idea has actually been implemented. I seriously doubt that this community has any influence on the Spotify Product...
Can you please show me a page (URL) where all implemented ideas are listed, including the date when idea has been submitted and by when it has been implemented? thanks.
@Melody wrote:Updated on 2018-10-02Hey folks, Thanks for coming to the Community, and adding your vote to this idea! Thanks for the copy/paste reply 🙂I share bzero's skepticism, in that I doubt spotify implements few, if any, real ideas people are asking for.Spotify keeps recommending me playlists with music I have little interest in and are clearly big hits ( even my personal 'your summer rewind' playlist was 90% golden oldies that I played exactly once, at a party for my dad, which wasn't even during summer). Whether this is because so many people listen to it, that the algorithms push it onto even more people, widening the gap between small-big artists. Or if it really is record companies paying extra for this, I have no idea. Meanwhile the tracks I really like I usually forget about or can't find anymore, and the personal rating system would be one easy tool to keep some order in a library, and help spotify figure out what I like. If, you know, wanted to.
Thanks for the copy/paste reply 🙂I share bzero's skepticism, in that I doubt spotify implements few, if any, real ideas people are asking for.
Spotify keeps recommending me playlists with music I have little interest in and are clearly big hits ( even my personal 'your summer rewind' playlist was 90% golden oldies that I played exactly once, at a party for my dad, which wasn't even during summer).
Whether this is because so many people listen to it, that the algorithms push it onto even more people, widening the gap between small-big artists. Or if it really is record companies paying extra for this, I have no idea.
Meanwhile the tracks I really like I usually forget about or can't find anymore, and the personal rating system would be one easy tool to keep some order in a library, and help spotify figure out what I like. If, you know, wanted to.
I think this was the same comment we received one or two years ago.I would love to say thank you for taking your time to get back to us but. Looking when we posted it and how many people have ask for it. Why not just say this will not happen so you at least do not have to respond anymore. Moreover it might be even closer to the truth.
How can this be so difficult? Didn't you go to the stock exchange? Didn't you get some millions to invest in making your service more user-friendly? Rate music (or whatever) with stars has already been invented. It's a simple database. Ask your Silicon Valley colleagues how to do it.
Spotify, your lack of interest in reasonable requests for things that are basic standard features in other media players is shockingly arrogant. The minute there is an alternative service that is more interested in providing what their customers what, you've lost a probable lifetime subscriber to your service.
I am also waiting to add this functionality. It would be very convenient for users and for Spotify, improving options "👍👎".
Using the Spotify API i added this feature to my application. There are 5 special rating playlists (very long). When a song is rated it gets added to one of these playlists. When editing playlists you can see what rating each song is rated. Any song that is rated is added to my library.
This is one of two major features I miss from my old music player (MediaMonkey), being able to "like" a song and give it 3 stars but its not one of the best songs which would have 5 stars. Makes it a lot easier to find your absolute favourite songs without needing to constantly update a manually created playlist.
I would kill for this feature. Basically the only organizational tool we have is playlists. Giving tracks 0-5 stars would be sooooooo useful.
What is the satus as of May2019?
This feature is essential for heavy duty listeners, which rate their songs
I won't leave my favourite player with 5 star rating untill Spotify implements this.
pathetic. they just told me they consider any suggestions with over 100 votes... but there no point in me resubmitting this if has been here since 2012 and you still cant take a day to **bleep**ing code a personal rating system... the **bleep** is wrong with you. thats like... the number 1 thing in organizing music... shame.
Sounds great! This would REALLY help make Spotify even more user-friendly and personalized if implemented.
Another missing feature for organizing your saved music.
This is one of the main reasons I'm still not using Spotify as my main music player app.
(still using MusicBee and Rocket Player for now)
I just use Spotify to discover new music. It's a real pity that we can't have the best of both worlds though!
this feature would be wonderful to have. I made a post about this as well but was notified that it is a duplicate. My thought would be to add a pop up layer to the like button and allow you to choose a star rating.
Yeeeeeessssss Pleeeeeaase Spotify!!! Do it! I'll go premium if you do this one thing, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.
After 8 years, the feature is not even considered! How many votes do you need to add this?
I've been on here a long time. I can tell you that the lack of this feature has had clear results in my case: I've listened to Spotify far, far less often than I otherwise would. My home player (AIMP) has a library a fraction the size of yours, but the ratings make it far easier to figure out if a given song is (1) one I've listened to before, and (2) one I liked a lot, or thought was just okay. When I see that 4 or 5 star rating, I get excited and engaged -- that's what you're giving up by not having the feature: user excitement and engagement.
With Spotify, a "heart" just tells me the song is "not bad, but not necessarily really good, either". No "heart" means "either this was just okay, or it was bad -- or you've never even listened to it." What a mess that is! Far easier to go with a player that tracks this information. (Meaning ALL of the good players out there, and almost all of the bad ones, too.) If listening to AIMP, and my modest library, means giving up the gigantic Spotify library, then in practice, I've consistently chosen to do that for a period of years. I don't say this in anger -- I'm just reporting one user's experience with your program.
I listen to Spotify and enjoy it. But my home player, IN PRACTICE, has been my choice about 7 times out of 8 for the past 4-5 years, and the inability to rate songs is a major reason for this.