[All Platforms][Playlists] Switch on/off crossfade in certain playlists

Hello Community!

 

In Spotify there are some playlists with automatic crossfade. That means there's a smooth transition between songs. However, not everyone likes that, since the next song starts later (from minute 0:45, 0:26, 1:02...). That's why I thought it would be a good idea a to have the ability to switch it on and off depending on what the user prefers.

That way, there wouldn't be any problems with that.

 

This is an example of one of the playlists:

 

In my opinion, it would be a good idea. If you agree, make sure to leave your vote/comment and hopefully they'll consider this idea.

Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

That's a great idea!

Updated on 2018-09-13

Marked as new idea, which is a repost of this inactive idea.

I'd love an option to turn this off. First I thought this strange feature was a bug! Especially when the next song doesn't match the last one and I et a few seconds of two different songs playing at the same time. I find wasting the first minute or so of a song unhelpful.

THIS SO CALLED "FEATURE" NEEDS AN OFF OPTION ASAP!!!! CAN'T LISTEN TO MUSIC ON SPOTIFY ANYMORE. I MEAN LIKE wth SPOTIFY? DON'T DESTROY MUSIC...

 

Okay now you understand my feelings. Please make a button to switch this feature off. I don't have the time to switch to another music service as I already have alot of playlists on spotify. But if your going to destroy everything with wierd features. I'll have to! As I can't work without music.

 

Best Regards

An angry user

I hate this feature. It happens on the Techno Bunker playlist and I can't stand it. Please give me an option to turn it off!

I've found a workaround for this. (A temporary one, this problem still needs to be fixed)

You can create a new playlist from the buggy playlist by copying all entries with command + A, cmd + C and then making a new playlist with the copied songs: cmd + V. This new playlist won't be updated but it'll be a normal, non-buggy playlist.

Thanks, I was thinking of doing that myself . Either way there should be an option to turn this "auto crossfade" off because it's jarring and not mixed properly anyway .

Doesn't that prove that this "feature" never was a feature? And that it is just someone who **bleep**ed up? And made the mistake on the production servers? They have probably fixed the problem causing it, but never fixed the old playlists? Which is why this would work? (Just speculating)

 

Created a new playlist a little while ago and you are correct it doesn't happen on that playlist!

I think the idea was that some curated playlists (those created by Spotify themselves) crossfade to make it a more "seamless" mix. An apparently experienced user said on another thread in this forum that this is an actual feature that Spotify was testing (? or had developed). A regular playlist as created with the workaround described above doesn't have this kind of mixing because regular users can't enable this feature. The songs themselves have nothing to do with this, they can apparently be played in different ways depending on the playlist's settings. 

Aha, just tried some different playlists and as you said, those that are created by users don't have this problem. But some of those created by spotify have it. One exclusion seems to be "discover weekly".

I don't exactly know how Spotify generates the song start offsets but as discover weekly is generated by an AI and not directly curated, it makes sense that those playlists don't have this behavior. I've only seen a small amount of playlists that actually do this, most of the curated playlists I listen I don't do this. (The only one I've actually inspected is "Deep House Relax")

Techno Bunker does this as well. It's really annoying when I want to put
the songs on shuffle and they start a minute or two in.

Do you think that it might be something done manually? Like they have someone at spotify creating this playlist and when doing that they set that song X should overlap song Y with specific amount of time. So intstead of having a single long song mix like DJ:s create on youtube, they have the same functionallity of mixing. But with separate songs. (Probably makes licensing easier)

 

Or is there anything indicating that this is done automaically?

I think the crossfade is done by the usual crossfade method but the offset times might be calculated differently. The curator might actually set the offset times manually, it's done randomly or by AI/heuristic. But the fact that a certain playlist has this feature is most likely set manually. It seems this is more common for "background"-type music playlists.

Then it might be good to have a switch on the playlist, that could turn off the crossfade for this specific playlist. Could be beside the follow switch. This would make it easy to turn it on/off when you want. And possibly a switch in the settings to completly turn of the abillity to use autocrossfade. Like if you for example want to listen to the playlist in private and don't want to have crossfade on, just turn it off. But if you are playing music on speakers and want to use autocrossfade you can do that very easily. But if you absolutely hate it, you can turn it off completely.

Just contacted customer support and I got a worthless default reply. I
guess their support staff has no idea what I'm asking. If this isn't fixed
soon I'll be cancelling my premium.

Please add an on off feature to the auto fade. I use spotify because I like the pre made playlists but I don't like to be told how to control the way I listen. 

I hate this feature! Also thought it was a bug. Wish it had an on/off button! I stopped listening to the playlist (deep house relax) because of it. Definitely not relaxing to have it switch so abruptly to the middle (typically about 2 minutes in) of the song.

This "feature" ruins playlists. Ok lets say I want some wonky "dj set" crafted by an unknown spotify executive..it does not act SMOOTH at all if you shuffle! I discover this issue every time only through ears due to it just cutting music off and then a new track starting in the middle of a beat, no buildup, no context. Pure cancer, remove this bs or turn it off!

Why is this even a thing? It's so intrusive to my listening experience

I have several playlist that I listen to where I have noticed that auto crossfade has been implemented. PLEASE INSERT THIS OPTION!! While there are times where this would be extremely useful, the majority of the time I'm finding myself breaking focus and going into Spotify to start the song from the very beginning; very annoying. My humble opinion: either give the option to choose or don't use auto crossfade. Thanks for all your hard work!!

Why bother providing a "crossfade songs" setting to users if it's completely disregarded?   That's just bad UX and should accurately be relabelled to "crossfade songs (except when we decide otherwise)".  

 

If there's no intention to respect this user preference, labelling playlists with a "forced crossfade" tag will help properly set user expectations for the listening experience. 

 

Also, I had thought that crossfade should only kick in as one song naturally ends and the other begins for the sake of a (smooth) transition.  If I manually skip to the next song, please start me at the start - not a minute in.  

@manafire Spotify seems to make a distinction between the normal crossfade you can toggle with a setting and this special playlist "mixed crossfade" (as I'm going to call it).

  • Normal crossfade turns off when turned off with the setting. Its length can be changed using another setting ranging from 0 to 12 seconds. (as far as I remember).
  • Mixed crossfade cannot be disabled. It appears on certain playlists and starts songs at a predefined point that seems to range from the start of the song up to about 1:30 minutes in.
Exactly. The problem is the mixing is badly done and jarring. If it was
professionally done then it wouldn't be so bad but it's not. Either way
they should have "mixed" playlist and non mixed ones. I like to have my
dance music playlist on shuffle and HATE that the songs will just start at
random points.

I think it's pretty dumb of Spotify to override user's preferance. This is really annoying. Especially since there's no indication in the UI that this is a playlist specific setting that users can't control. And extra dumb because I've explicitly turned crossfading off in my settings. If there's gonna be a setting for playlists, you should add it there so there are 3 modes to that settings:

 

- off (actually off everywhere)

- on (some playlists)

- on (everywhere)

 

 

What a stupid feature indeed. It is ridiculous to say the least. Crossfade option is already there for the user to choose whether they want it or not REGARDLESS OF THE PLAYLIST THEY ARE LISTENING TO. If it is set to OFF why the *** it is being ignored? That's it. It's sad to see Spotify doesn't give a ****. There's no need to add another stupid button to confuse people even more, just make the existing one to work as expected in any playlist.

@marcos744 please keep it calm and civil. Getting upset isn't going to fix this issue faster.

 

I have actually gotten this issue to Spotify as a technical support issue and they said they'd look into it and get back to me once they've done it. They have not responded since my tech support call. I'll post here when something happens.

They just runined another playlist with this feature. "I love 90s hip hop"
has this "automix" feature enabled now. It will literally skip the intro of
songs and get straight to the verses alot of times and I hate that. I love
intros to old school hip hop. This is a stupid feature that needs to be
removed.

Jup, Brain Food and Lo-Fi Beats are now ruined as well. Thought it was a bug but turns out to be a "feature".

 

I don't get it why this would be set in the playlist when there is a setting for that in the settings page.

Crossfade should also be max 5 seconds, not 30ish seconds offset in the next song... Others songs starts very strong this way and not a nice listening experience.

Please remove it al together or add a option to disable this asap.

If not it's bye bye Spotify

PLEAAASE,  Spotify. I understand that some users might like this. Personally, it sounds terrible and all I want is the option to turn it off.

Child Item
Child Item