[Discover Weekly] Prevent Duplicates in Discover Weekly Playlists

For the past month or so, I've had so many repeats of songs on my Discover Weekly playlist.  Now, I can count on 5-10 songs that I've had before on the playlist. 

Is there a way to mix up the algorithm?  Or maybe an option to eleminate songs that have been on the playlist before?

Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Im getting same problem. Repeat of already played songs in my DW

Hi,

Today I had a song that is simply a remix of a song I already heard many times. 

What is your opinion on that ? Should remixes be considered as new songs ? 

Personnaly, I dont feel like this is a song that I discovered.

Hola

I’m OK with remixes, mainly because: 1. They can be substantially different and 2. Remixed by other artists I might enjoy getting to know.

Also seems it would be very difficult to create an algorithm to avoid this. I wouldn’t want to risk loosing ‘covers’ of songs I might already have.

Cheers!

Hi from Italy !

I'm a Premium user since four years ago, but it's many weeks that "Discover Weekly" proposes me songs that I really don't like !

What about algorithm and big data  ??

Ciao

 

 

I'm only 5 songs deep in DW and I've already been recomended two songs that are already in my library. 😕

 

It's not called REDISOVER WEEKLY. 

I get duplicates almost every week and now I got intros from albums I have listened to many times on Spotify. Why? This is a constant problem still and this post is from 8 months ago. It has not been fixed. 

This response is almost a year old and I continue to get songs from previous lists and sometimes twice on the same list, instrumentals too. Why am I "discovering" an instrumental of an album I already have listened to, mulitple times over? This is silly because the problem is not fixed. It's irritating it is being branded as something it is clearly not. Please fix it. 

I logged in just to say that it's not Sept 2018, this issue seems to date back to at least 2016, and it's STILL happening. At least 30% of this weeks list are songs I have listened to in the past, been in previous discovery, or are in my songs list already.

 

This really isn't hard, spotify. Discovery should be your special sauce, but it seems like you've abandoned it.

 I got three songs from previous weeks just this Monday. I cancelled my spotify subscription because of this. They have close to the whole Beatles catalouge. I covet that but I hate branding and throwing money at problems more than I covet any music. The service is ok. It's good but you constantly expect your patrons to do your work. Get people to do the Discover Weekly. You have the money. This is pathetic and you get away with it because people think they can't live without your service. Well, I am not in that camp. Your service sucks for what you brand it. Pandora doesn't over extend themselves and then delusionally explain away the fix that never happened. Y'all are too cheap to pay the artists and too cheap to fix your algorithms then y'all shouldn't be in business.

 A week since I posted this, I am six songs into my new discovery playlist and 3 of them were either ones I received before, or are in my favorites already.

Every week is getting worse... discover weekly is becoming: “try to listen this song again”... It don’t seem so difficult to discard what you have already heard thousens of times in a discovery list

I found some gems in this week's disover weekly playlist but there a couple of songs in discover weekly that were already in my library. It's not REdiscover weekly. 

It seemed to have been fixed but this week again, I have old songs in the Disover Weekly, some of them even already exist in my library. This feature was the only reason I've subscribed to Spotify, if it continuos like this, I will reconsider.  

Discover Weekly

Many songs I already had in my library or playlist. What discovery are you talking about?

Marked as implemented along time ago, but the situation is still the same now. Discovery weekly is hardly discovery at all. Why does it have to be just weekly? Why can't there be a refresh button like there is on the suggested track when you are creating a playlist? The tech is already there, just give me the button.

This is NOT implemented. This week, out of the 30 songs I got in my discover weekly, 15 of them were music that I've either listened to myself, or recieved in my previous weeks of spotify weekly [see image]. 

How on earth can you say that this has been implemented when over 50% of the music I recieved this week are repeats from weeks gone by. 

 

I want to be able to use spotify's discover weekly as a way to discover new music, not to have the same stuff I've listened to earlier thrown back into my "Discover queue".

Songs highligted in green are songs that I have listened to before, or got in previous discover weeklys.Songs highligted in green are songs that I have listened to before, or got in previous discover weeklys.

I'm still having this issue as well. Oddly, it seems like it got worse after I joined Spotify Premium. What can we do to stop this from happening?

Hello Spotify, 

 

I am facing the same issue as the above posters.

 

I used to love Discover Weekly because it was full of new songs and it was my main source of new music. Nowadays 30-50% of the songs in any given week are tracks that I have already heard in previous Discover Weekly playlists. And even if I do "hide" them, they just reappear again a couple of weeks later.

 

From this message chain it appears that people have been complaining about this since 2016. It doesn't feel like it should be a very difficult thing to fix - I'm surprised to see that it takes more than four years!

 

Thanks

Tom

This week I have 5 old songs in my discover weekly and 2 songs from last week's Discover Weekly. This issue isn't resolved. 

It has been weeks I have this problem. I suposse that Spotify really does not have track of songs listened cause cost issues? 

This is the main feature I use, so is very important for me 😞 I even listen some of my friends lists...

It's an old post but.. I hope some can help ? @blake

It's definitely not cost, I can tell you that - because services like last.fm will connect to your spotify account, and save your user listening history for free. For instance, exporting a total user listening history worth 18,000 different entries for songs as a CSV file takes up only 15 MB. That means less than 1kB of storage required per song - and that's assuming they're storing full names and text of song title, artist and album, instead of just a spotify song ID with date and time - which would be smarter, and is likely what they (should) do.

It's a bug, and spotify have acknowledged that it's a bug

 

If you want to "bug" them about it, you can add stuff to this post too:
https://community.spotify.com/t5/Other-Partners-Web-Player-etc/Discover-Bug-Songs-consistently-re-appear-in-discover-weekly/m-p/5219797#M79651

 

This says implemented but they must have removed this feature because I keep getting songs added that I've definitely heard before from Spotify.

 

Child Item
Child Item