[All Platforms][Music] HiFi Quality - Lossless Streaming 16bit 44.1khz

I've just started a trial of Qobuz - they offer the standard 320kbps as well as lossless FLAC streaming (and high res downloads if you purchase them) the sound quality is noticeably better and on classical it's just wonderful to get all that resolution through your hi-fi or headphones! The catalogue has a way to go to get to Spotify's level, but they are getting there. The iPad app isn't' too bad (the desktop app is in need of an upgrade but I hear they are putting all their efforts into mobile apps right now).
 
So - lossless streaming - if Qobuz can do it then so can Spotify, they must have the same source - and obviously if you are asking £20 a month then those record labels and distributors take enough notice to make the high res tracks available for streaming. What this all means is soon, very soon, we will get lossless streaming and closely followed by high res downloads - but if Spotify aren't careful it will be Apple who get there first with an audiophile premium offering, and when they do it will be a much harder market place to make money in!
 
** please don't lump this suggestion with the main one on lossless downloads, that's a different idea entirely guys!
Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

I’ve no interest whatsoever in podcasts but what I am interested and what I want is lossless streaming at the minimum of CD quality.
I’m no serious audiophile and most of my listening is through my MacBook using Momentum 3 headphones (wired not wireless) and an old Cambridge Audio DAC but I can really hear the difference between Spotify and the other streamers which I’ve been trying. Think I’ve settled on Amazon HD but still got a couple of weeks to decide - difficult decision as they are all very similar in quality other than Tidal who give you CD quality for £9.99 but then want £19.99 for any higher quality and you can get that included with the others.

Since yesterday we have several news in Germany that Spotify has confirmed that it is delayed until an unknown date. Seriously? 

The difference between Spotify and me is that you can trust my promises. I'm out.

 

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Music-HiFi-Quality-Lossless-Streaming-16bit-44/idc-p/5320279/highlight/true#M238005

 

I wish you a lossy new year....

What exactly do you mean by "knowledge?" Do you mean the recommendations
and end-of-year insights?

Yes.

On Tidal and deezer these are extremely poor. When I do appreciate Hi Fi, it's not the deal for me when recommendations are not great. In case of these two Hi Fi apps I would need them for sound and Spotify for knowledge.

When that's not the case for some, I am extremely lazy to swim from app to another just to keep lists in order.

I heard on internet, that Hi Fi is delayed on Spotify, so it might not come anytime soon.

https://www.golem.de/news/musikstreaming-spotify-haelt-an-plaenen-fuer-bessere-klangqualitaet-fest-2112-162048.html

Capture+_2021-12-29-21-18-22.png

Hello Apple! Hello 24bit! 🙂

Colin Power.jpg

 

The story of the Emperor's New Clothes comes to mind when I think about Spotify this point in time. If your not familiar, "wiki" it. It doesn't seem like they're listening or recognize that they're exposed.

 

There's an article coming out almost every day mentioning that they've missed their commitment to bring Hifi to their audience. Hifi at this point is the minimum daily requirement. Some reviewers are speculating that they're holding back because their competition is offering the feature at no cost. But they  are  wrong. They are offering superior quality to what Spotify was proposing. Very astute move, Apple, Amazon.  Other services like Tidal and Deezer lowered their prices and even offered a free tier. Spotify got caught off guard.

 

Personally, I believe if Spotify offered their Hifi tier at an additional cost some of those who are exiting the service would probably come back. Personally, it's going to be hard for me to return. Unfortunately, have seen what "real clothes" look like.

 

For the last few months, I've been giving consideration to upgrading my equipment because it seems like my speakers weren't cutting it with Spotify. I have two 5.1 home theaters setups in my house (one's on my desk) and I was looking at the prospect of replacing 9 of the speakers. Not cheap. Because Spotify was talking about Hifi and delaying, out of curiosity I auditioned Qobuz, Apple Music, Amazon Unlimited, and Deezer.

 

I almost fell out of my chair. I was blown away because I realized then I didn't need new equipment. I needed to feed my systems good quality streaming. Furthermore, I can most definitely hear the improvement when I go from CD quality to high res streaming. On top of that other services are offering offer Dolby Atmos Music,  Spatial Audio, and other things that aren't even being talked about by Spotify. CD quality is now the minimum requirement. They haven't even shown that they're going to release that anytime soon. That's sad. Upsetting your customers is not a business strategy.

 

Some reviewers think Spotify may table releasing Hifi for other things. If so they may have "jumped the shark". I think the erosion of their base will accelerate.  If they do this I don't think next year is going to be a very happy year for them. In some reviewer's eyes they were barely holding on to their frontrunner status. I suspect that's going to change.

I was rooting for them because I liked them very much. But at this point, I don't have a lot of faith in them. I hope they get this right because they've done so many things right. But if they get these next moves wrong they're going to look like Frankenstein-ish amalgam of Facebook with the long term success of Pandora. My $0.02...

Plot - The Emperor's New Clothes

Two swindlers arrive at the capital city of an emperor who spends lavishly on clothing at the expense of state matters. Posing as weavers, they offer to supply him with magnificent clothes that are invisible to those who are stupid or incompetent. The emperor hires them, and they set up looms and go to work. A succession of officials, and then the emperor himself, visit them to check their progress. Each sees that the looms are empty but pretends otherwise to avoid being thought a fool. Finally, the weavers report that the emperor's suit is finished. They mime dressing him and he sets off in a procession before the whole city. The townsfolk uncomfortably go along with the pretense, not wanting to appear inept or stupid, until a child blurts out that the emperor is wearing nothing at all. The people then realize that everyone has been fooled. Although startled, the emperor continues the procession, walking more proudly than ever.

 

The "swindlers" of Spotify's tale are their marketing people. How embarrassing that they trotted out Billie Eilish and Finneas, all this slick copy, video, and empty promises. Man, the Eilish's have got to be embarrassed to be associated with this at this point. No clothes...

Great post LawLee!

 

This massive delay has also given me a chance to evaluate other streaming services. 

Had they gone ahead and made it available within a few months of the announcement I never would have realised just how good the competition is, particularly Qobuz.

 

Even if Spotify do manage to introduce Hi-Fi later than promised, the fact remains this whole thing has been handled appallingly and I'm not sure I want any part of it.

 

 

 

@spotify team, it’s now 30/Dec and this feature still has not launched this year as promised, and now significantly behind the competition. Can you give us an update with a go live date? Thanks. 

I just heard that Spotify is releasing HiFi lossless on April 1, 2022.

 

 

 

 

April Fools' Day!  😁

I've given up. I canceled my account yesterday and switched to Tidal after at least 10 years as a Spotify customer. There are a lot of things I'll miss about Spotify, but at this point it seems like they're cashing in on a stagnant product.

PaulMac,

 

Like you I'm a big fan of Quobuz. I think their aesthetic is perfect for the music afficionado. I don't know about you but I missed records. I missed the liner notes and all the things to be learned about the recording. Of the music services Qobuz presents it best. I'm sure it's the same way on the Mac but look at these next few screenshots from the PC app.

 

LawLee_0-1640892620627.png

 

The "About" is comments on the album. But if you hit the "info" button you're treated to this...

 

LawLee_1-1640892757170.png

 

I feel like I have a vinyl record with extensive sheet notes without all the scratchy noise that playing on the phonograph used to generate. Here's one of the areas where Spotify could improve. But I also like the transparency of knowing the quality of the recording in this case it tells me that it's 24 bit 44.1 khz stereo. 

 

LawLee_0-1640893419836.png

 

Then I can also select the streaming quality coming down at 4 different levels that are clearly defined instead of Spotify's statement of something being Low, Normal, High, or Very High. What does that even mean??? They say that Very High can be up to 320 kb/s. But by the way they phrase it it sounds like they've got an out to not providing that streaming quality. Did the lawyers develop this part of the program??? They ought to spell it out explicitly like practically everyone else. 

 

On top of this my receiver or my TV tells me the bit depth and frequency that Qobuz says is delivering. Just like Sonos_Steve pointed out in his posting from above, this is really cool and reassuring. I hope Spotify is taking note.

 

But I also pay for Amazon Prime Unilimited. Why? In my opinion they have the best lyrics implementation. Again this takes me back to my record days when the liners used to carry the lyrics of popular songs. The nice thing about Amazon's implementation though is you can scroll up to any of the lyrics in a song, click on them and the song plays from that point. I think Apple and Deezer do the same thing. Very cool.

 

LawLee_1-1640893758039.png

 

I can even karaoke with this. Again Spotify I hope you're taking note. The second crucial thing that I like about Amazon Unlimited is that it's more transparent in telling you its streaming quality. Look at this! It detects your system's abilities and adjusts streaming on the fly!

 

LawLee_2-1640894021453.png

 

Both phone-based apps for Amazon and Qobuz are excellent, as good and in some ways better than Spotify's. To be fair Amazon Unlimited's Android tablet app is a dumpster fire. I hope they get to work on fixing it. But still it's usable. Spotify has got them beat here. But again, Qobuz's Android tablet app is superior to Spotify's in music and information usability IMHO.

 

So for me both Amazon and Qobuz have qualities I'm willing to pay for. Maybe Apple, Tidal or Deezer come closer to having it all. But Tidal's got MQA mastering embedded in all of their songs, so you know you're getting adulterated music. Apple Music and Deezer don't seem to have the depth of information or transparency of data streaming. I pay $7.99 for Amazon Unlimited and $14.99 for Qubuz. Go do the math, I'd be willing to pay $23 a month for a service that has all of these features. If Spotify were to concentrate on their music delivery in quality and depth of information I believe they could charge more than ANY of the services because of the strengths that they already have.

 

I truly hope Spotify sees these posts and respond to the strengths of their competition. Apple and Amazon have deep pockets. And eventually they're going to get more things right. Deezer is poised to gain ground as well because they're hungry. Qobuz apparently saw 45% increase in their users last year. They just got more investment; kudos to them.

 

I'm not trying to "shill" for anyone or "troll" Spotify. Anyway best wishes Spotify. But your strengths are not as glaring as some of your weaknesses IMHO.

Well this didn't age well or at all.....

Integrity and follow-thru builds trust with customers. Two days left for Spotify to make good on it's online announcement to bring Lossless features to customers by “year end” 2021.

The BS meter is close to pegged about now. : ‘ (


Broken promises are a bad thing to do… leaving Spotify again. Back to Apple with an Apple One family account. More features for the same price.  Even storage and games. Already having Timely provided lyrics and lossless audio streaming to my av-set.   2022 means bye bye Spotify for me and likely many. When breaking  a promise, you break a bond.

As a reminder of the statement from Spotify on 2nd March 2021 some 400 pages ago :

 

Hey folks, 

 

We're happy to say that we'll be setting this idea to ''Under Consideration'' since implementing it is in our current timeline.

 

Starting later this year, Premium subscribers in select markets will be able to upgrade their sound quality to Spotify HiFi and listen to their favorite songs the way artists intended. 

 

Take a look at our newsroom article here for more info.

 

Cheers!

 

Five hours and 30 minutes to make this happen.  No further official statements since March.  Those of us loyal Spotify subscribers who waited for HiFi feel entirely disrespected and disregarded.  Have been with Qobus now for 1 month and the sound quality and services are fantastic.  My Spotify premium officially runs out early January.   Last chance saloon for Spotify to reclaim my subscription.

 

If there are others in the same frustrated situation I would recommend trialling alternative streaming services who seem way more responsive to customer needs and for the same money as Spotify premium.  Bizarre pre-occupation with Podcasts and war-mongering dilute its musical integrity.

 

The investment is described as an 'ethical' investment,  into a company which better serves humanity.  Apparently artists have spoken out.  Maybe that money chould have gone towards Spotify's prime objectives as a music streamer.  The investment undoubtedly came from Spotify subscriptions.

 

It makes no sense to me that there is absolutely no further news regarding their planning re hifi;  it just screams of arrogance and not caring about their customers.  All of their competitors now seem technically more advanced that Spotify;  those of us who want lossless music are being ignored.  They absolutely deserve lost costum if this is their attitude.

Status Update - Leaving Spotify Premium, Possible Return

Updated on 2021-12-31

 

Hey Spotify, 

 

I'm sorry to say I left your paid service this month after your failing to deliver Hifi, and failing to be transparent about it.

 

I'm happy to say though, I'll be setting the idea of returning as a paying customer ''Under Consideration'' since implementing this may be in my future timeline. That's providing, of course, you deliver Hifi. No guarantees though. Like you, I am ambivalent and non-committal. 

 

Starting this year, Premium subscribers in all markets are turning to your competitors to upgrade their sound quality beyond Spotify HiFi to listen to their favorite songs the way artists intended.

 

Take a look at your newsroom article here for more info on how you missed your commitment.

 

Cheers!

I’ve got a three month window of tolerance now - feel like I’ve been lied to, conned and kept in a situation where I could have jumped ship 6 months ago but didn’t due to naive faith in big green customer service….

My Question or Issue

It's 2022. So HiFi has launched, at least if Spotify's own For The Record blog is to be believed. However, my quality is still maxing out at "very high".

Please clarify.

Hi, can you send me the link where this news is. I cant find anyting in this spotify Jungle about that........ I do not beleive there is such a thing at Spotify and dont beleive it´s coming either.... another question is, do they need it. What´s sure is that, for 10,99€ and with so much focus on anything else they have no room for mistakes anymore, meaning 1 cent more up in the price and I´m gone.

Missing a deadline is one thing, but not communicating this your user base speaks volumes about the company you are. I am a 10 year+ paying customer and I will now look into other options.

 

Edit: Me and my family have now quit our subscriptions. I like so much about Spotify, and will consider coming back when lower compression options are available and the playback GUI is more transparent.

Other services takes exclusive control over my DAC and displays bit depth and sample rate for all tracks.

Who is ready to jump ship ?  

 

I am.

Would have gladly paid more for Hi-Fi.

Ynohifi et al,

Already gone.

<https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Music-HiFi-Quality-Lossless-Streaming-16bit-44/idc-p/5321932#M238196>

I'm now a paid subscriber to Amazon Music unlimited and Qobuz. But if you add that up I'm paying $23 a month. So clearly if Spotify had Hifi I might have paid more too. Too bad...

IMHO opinion, the lack of transparency is worse than the lack of the feature.  Offering a HiFi "tier" is pointless now since all the competitors have CD quality at the $10 price point. Now, it would need to be an MQA tier or lossless at the base price.


Right now, the only thing keeping me on Spotify is Spotify connect, and it's a little sad that it's convenience rather than music quality given where all the competitors are at. I'll spend the next week or so exploring the options to see which is the most convenient and which has the best selection of music.

 

If your playlists are keeping you with Spotify, start researching playlist migration apps. 

Child Item
Child Item