[All Platforms][Music] HiFi Quality - Lossless Streaming 16bit 44.1khz

I've just started a trial of Qobuz - they offer the standard 320kbps as well as lossless FLAC streaming (and high res downloads if you purchase them) the sound quality is noticeably better and on classical it's just wonderful to get all that resolution through your hi-fi or headphones! The catalogue has a way to go to get to Spotify's level, but they are getting there. The iPad app isn't' too bad (the desktop app is in need of an upgrade but I hear they are putting all their efforts into mobile apps right now).
 
So - lossless streaming - if Qobuz can do it then so can Spotify, they must have the same source - and obviously if you are asking £20 a month then those record labels and distributors take enough notice to make the high res tracks available for streaming. What this all means is soon, very soon, we will get lossless streaming and closely followed by high res downloads - but if Spotify aren't careful it will be Apple who get there first with an audiophile premium offering, and when they do it will be a much harder market place to make money in!
 
** please don't lump this suggestion with the main one on lossless downloads, that's a different idea entirely guys!
Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

For me Apple Music is perfect as I only use Apple products when I listen to music. I got 6 months free Apple Music with Airpods Pro purchase, and that got me to finally ditch Spotify, after using it since 2008. 

 

I have not tried any other services. I did read a bit about Tidal and MQA, and it looks like a scam. 

 

Unless Apple really mess up, and Spotify change dramatically I will never return. And I don't see any of those things happening. 

The problem with Apple is that connectivity to most audio systems is via Airplay 2. Despite them showing high Rez, Airplay 2 changes the files to 256 AAC, and puts you right back in the same quality arena as Spotify.

Apple has developed its own lossless audio compression technology called Apple Lossless Audio Codec (ALAC). In addition to AAC, the entire Apple Music catalog is now also encoded using ALAC in resolutions ranging from 16-bit/44.1 kHz (CD Quality) up to 24-bit/192 kHz.

 

(copy & paste from Apple)

 

using airplay 2 it say’s 16-bit/44.1 kHz in the  display of my DAC

While the central message of this thread continues to be "we're not getting what we want from Spotify, so we're going elsewhere," and I do appreciate that many who are more tied-into the Apple ecosystem would find that the natural alternative (and cheers to Apple for continuing to provide innovative improvements in sound quality and surround formats), I would like to state the following:

 

I will never switch to Apple until/unless I can play it with full feature capability on my Amazon Fire TV Cube, my Roku, my SmartTV, my Raspberry Pi (with moode OS), my Android Samsung phones, etc.

 

I can play Spotify on all of the above.  I can play Qobuz on enough of the above (though sometimes in more roundabout ways than Spotify) to make it worth switching, since I value high-resolution stereo so much.

 

I think I can only play Apple Music on my Macbook laptops, and possibly my Windows Desktop PC via iTunes(??).

I value a diversity of ecosystems.  I resist investing more fully in Google and Apple and Amazon because they resist enabling their content outside of their ecosystems.  Qobuz for the win!

P.S. - I typed this response on a Mac.  🙂  And I enjoy surround sound, but my Denon/Oppo/Polk 5.1 surround system doesn't hold a candle to my stereo-only equipment; thus 2-channel stereo quality in my household blows away the surround-sound experience (even room-optimized with Audyssey DSP).

These are ranked in my order of preference. I rank Apple Music just above Spotify because of it's poor operability on anything other than Apple gear. It doesn't matter if it has HiRes or Spatial Audio if it can't work on the majority of customer's existing systems. A limiting, but predicable move on Apple's part. 

 

LawLee_0-1656292218693.png

 

 

 

Regarding the table above, I don't agree with Amazon's DAC integration (Wasapi in exclusive mode). It does not work for me while Qobuz doing it without any issues.

And there's a tons of users with the same issue. So their app is even bigger dumpster.

@mctesterson wrote:

"I think I can only play Apple Music on my Macbook laptops, and possibly my Windows Desktop PC via iTunes(??)."

You could subscribe to Apple Music on Windows and listen to it with iTunes, but not with lossless streaming, only with lossy AAC. Same is true for their web player.

By the way, Deezer offers a yearly subscription to their new Premium tier including HiFi for €5.99 per month at the moment, but only per email.

@hans-jürgen

 

Greetings! What Deezer email offer are you referring to? Deezer's problem in America is that $14.99/mo. for just CD quality is not compelling. Especially when you can get that from Tidal for ~$9.99/mo. Apple and Amazon trounces Deezer handily by providing CD to Hires quality for $9.99 and $7.99/mo. respectively.

 

Deezer needs to adjust their pricing down to the competition's level, lest they become the "Spotify" of CD quality streaming.. 

@hans-jürgen where can I get that offer?

I've use Deezer plenty over the years, now don't have any active subscription and they haven't sent me any offer via email regarding this particular yearly subscription discount deal. I read about it on the reddit-sub but also on the Deezer-forums.

El0h1m

 

You are right about Amazon. Their exclusive mode is unreliable. Their apps are terrible. Hopefully they continue to refine them. I did revise my table to reflect your comment. BTW

The current promo deal by Deezer is probably only sent to free accounts and/or ones that did not have a promo deal in the past already.  And it can only be offered in countries where the new Premium tier is already available. See e.g. this thread on their community:

https://en.deezercommunity.com/subscription-and-payments-5/deezer-email-offer-73176
It's likely that it will end this month, as they started sending these emails at the beginning of June. It may also have to do with their plans to be available at the stock market soon, see related press releases.

 

Apart from that they continue to roll out their new Premium tier including HiFi streaming for 10.99€ per month in more countries. As far as I know Brazil (one of their biggest markets) will get it in July which only has the old separate Premium and HiFi tiers yet like the U.S.

Et al,

 

It turns out I did get the promotional mail about Deezer Premium at $5.99. it says nothing about Deezer HiFi being offered at any reduced rate other than the normal $14.99.

 

The Deezer Premium plan is lossy encoded. I see no description of the bit rate as to whether it is 256kbps or 320kbps. I'm not interested in Spotify quality. However, Deezer HiFi is limited to 16bit 1411kbps CD quality.

 

And why would I spend $14.99/mo. on Deezer HiFi for only CD quality when and when Qobuz offers me true HiRes at up to 24bit 192kbps for only $12.99/mo.🤷‍

Deezer is 320K MP3 on Premium.

I think Spotify needs Hifi fast, even at more price, as Spotify's benefit is whole package.

Many would be willing to pay up to 14,99 a month for Lossless.

I won't pay them 14.99 for lossless. Why? I have a Hi-Res music for £10.83 (one payment of £129.99) from Qobuz. And I am happy with them.

Podcastify need to act SMART to beat the market now as I am no longer interested in just lossless CD Quality because I know how true HiRes taste.

I contacted Deezer and the customer service and asked them why I hadn't received any kind of email regarding the new discount. They told me that the discount yearly subscription 5.99€/month is only for those accounts that are eligible. Well, I've had few accounts and paid for Deezer for many years ago. Im not sure, but it seems to be weird that if you ever had been their customer then they just wouldn't try to lure you back into their service. Sometime ago they merged Premium and Hifi, then raised the price for 1€, so now it should definitely be hifi quality on the Premium.

 

Spotify is fine for me, Im currently eligible for the student price but now that they don't necessarily feel the need to better their service or provide better quality audio I might have to think what to do next. Feels awkward that Spotify otherwise is so good but one of the main things is seriously lacking (compared to what other services provide).

Hello gents, any update on Hi Res quality plan we are all waiting for ? 

Absolutely none. Switch to Tidal now!

Absolutely not a lossy Tidal's MQA.

Avoid and go Qobuz.

Ecoustics Podcast Interview with Dr. Mark Waldrep: Is Hi-Res Audio More Hype Than Reality? - ecousti...

 

“MQA is dead, irrelevant, and should go away now that Apple/Amazon have lossless.” - Dr. Mark Waldrep

The problem is most people connect Apple lossless through Airplay 2…which
transmits it as 256k AAC…thus no better than Spotify.

Can't wait! 

i3eyond , it's not going to happen any time soon.

You better run and pick an alternative like Qobuz or Deezer (if you are happy with CD quality only).

Espero puedan horientarne en este proyecto social

Just came back here to check how 2005 looks like.

If you see my earlier post a PhD audio expert made the case that hi-res audio is overhyped. I’ll post it here again

 

Ecoustics Podcast Interview with Dr. Mark Waldrep: Is Hi-Res Audio More Hype Than Reality? - ecousti...

 

He makes some good points. And my anecdotal experience supports that premise. Just because something is processed 24bit, 192kps does not mean that it’s going to be superior sounding. FLAC is just a container. And if there isn’t much data in the container it can still spit out 24bit, 192kps processed output with not much information in it.

 

Many people are using Bluetooth headphones because Apple in their infinite wisdom eliminated the headphone jack. Apple has been leading the industry away from high performance audio for a long time. I owned Apple phones and iPods. I also owned high performance MP3 players by SanDisk, iRiver, Creative Labs, and Archos. The worst fidelity MP3 players were Apple. And the original apple buds were poor fidelity wired headphones. Since they weren’t sealed many people listen to audio at levels high enough to drown out background noise and damage their hearing.

 

In pursuit of battery life Apple’s headphone amplifiers were weak. It actually it caused the headphone industry to develop earbuds that would sound reasonably well on Apple devices, skewing the earbuds fidelity industry. That’s why the whole portable DAC industry got started. Buying a phone for hundreds of dollars and then having to spend another 100 or more dollars for a DAC. Thanks Apple! The whole phone industry followed lockstep in eliminating headphone jacks from phones, which are the principal way people listen to music today.

 

But when Bluetooth came around Apple drove the industry that way. Bluetooth is inherently lossy. Your music which was encoded in MP3 or AAC is reencoded to be transmitted from your phone in either SBC, AAC, LDAC, Samsung Scalable Codec or others. Most of these are limited in terms of their data rate below bit rate received on your phone.

 

So Apple wants the lead the way in hi-res music now? How ironic. Keep in mind most of their streaming devices top out at 24bit, 48kHz.

 

Still Bluetooth is the limiting factor. And it’s true that upstream in your phone you’d like the best possible transmission quality, you then have to squeeze it through the Bluetooth pipe, or I should say straw. So I agree that 320kbs to CD quality is more than good enough for people who are consuming audio using Bluetooth.

 

Since my Yamaha Aventage Receiver has a Bluetooth input I decided to try to transmit music from my Galaxy phone to my receiver using Bluetooth. It sounded horrible. I have what are arguably accurate and well reviewed Bluetooth headphones. I've done critical listening on Galaxy buds, AKG and Sony top of the line Bluetooth headphones. Meh! I'll stick with wired when I'm not working in the yard or exercising.

 

Because my receiver is trying to process that signal to synthesize 5.1 channels of information using DTS it had nothing to work with. Spotify Connect directly to my receiver substantially sounded better.

 

But what sounded best by far was high data rate the lossless files of any type. Spotify connect today here's a convenience factor like Bluetooth. But either because of their data rate or the inherent limitations of Spotify Connect that convenience comes at a cost. A cost I'm not willing to pay.

 

I'm interested in quality. Home theater systems that can do DSP processesing on a stereo or Dolby Atmos stream are like a microscope. It's going to uncover the inherent problems in the source material. So yes, all things being equal. you can hear every step between 320kps Ogg-Vorbis to 16bit, 44.1kHz though 24bit 192kHz.

 

I've cancelled my Spotify subscription and used Soundizz to transfer all my playlists and albums to Tidal (I'm aware of the MQA issue, I'm happy with CD quality).

 

Anyway, Spotify dragged me along for too long, I was promised HiFi so long ago that I feel some what skrewed over here. As such I will not be returning to Spotify until HiFi is implemented, and will also now be advising people to leave the platform as well.

 

The lack of transparency here is disappointing, as a long time supporter of Spotify, it's a real shame that they couldn't keep us updated with what's happening with the feature.

Well I've read the next version of Bluetooth "Bluetooth LE" is about to start rolling out in the near future and this supports lossless audio over Bluetooth.  If Spotify haven't got HiFi released when these new earbuds start appearing on the market that will be the point they start losing a lot more subscribers.

Most definitely. Even though Apple Music is the only service that can match
Spotify's catalogue, and they do offer everything at a very reasonable cost,
they still discriminate against Windows and Android TV, which essentially
excludes hundreds of possible devices. which I happen to use. I'm never
going to get an AM sub as long as this continues.

Here we see global misunderstanding between Spotify management and users requirements. 

The simple to see today - mobile listeners are coming home to continue listen on some devices. Simple way to continue listen is  use wireless active acoustic systems. 

Sharing music with google or apple devices currently is very simple. 

Also not a secret, but in case user are from more related to music quality like hi-fi etc. the user put at home some stereo system with internal media system. 

The center of this media was usually some device (like a media streamer) but today we could see transfer users to use custom devices Like Raspberry Pi and similar to play music. 

The reason is finance crisis and price of currently available solutions for sale. 

 

From here we should pay attention to next point - what is a next steps for Spotify? Support OEM's with new functionality to disable possible custom way todo similar solution t home. This point should be good because number of sales of OEM devices has been related to Spotify gross margin. 

Second way is to provide more functionality to users, and lost margin from OEM's. As we could see here only features with additional payment could be provided from Spotify, but I think amount of features to provide for additional payments is not enough. 

 

So guy's we can ask for Hi-Fi, for some Spotify connect available for all family in subscription, and more and more usable function for us but not, because is not a part of real plan how to do business in Spotify. 

 

The one way as written above - go to others for required functionality to make Spotify money lost. This only single way to do. 

@demo_sphere

Remember that all Tidal's tracks labeled as a 'Master' have no longer true CD Quality available.

All Tidal's 'Master' tracks stream in FOLDED MQA when streaming 'Lossless'. Which is even worse than fully unfolded MQA.

 

Only tracks without 'Master' are really Lossless.


Qobuz is the only service with true HI-Res and CD quality.
If want to CD Quality only then Deezer as well.

Child Item
Child Item