Smart shuffle is a fun way to discover new songs, but it comes at a cost. Want to reshuffle your queue? Bam, wait a few seconds longer. Want to unshuffle your playlist? Bam, no longer works, and goes to a completely random place in the playlist.
To me this is an unwanted complication, and I'd much rather be able to choose in the settings menu whether I want to enable the Smart Shuffle feature, or disable it.
Agreed! I'm okay with the concept but we should be able to permanently disable it. Having to toggle through it on the shuffle button is a constant inconvenience, especially when the feature takes a long time to turn on and changes the playlist order. Sometimes it even skips off the song I'm listening to when I click it. Very frustrating and an unnecessary nuisance.
Please allow users to choose what features they use. Impossible to turn smart shuffle off on large playlists it just spins. Completely useless and a reason to quit Spotify. Please don't become a customer hostile company.
I have NEVER pressed shuffle and actually wanted smart shuffle.
I wonder what the actual % of users who press shuffle and want smart shuffle is? I'm guessing 0-1%? Please remove this terrible feature.
Remove it already. 700 votes here and 700 comments on the announcement post. How long before you realise it was a bad idea and undo it? 1000? 10,000?
this feature sucks but it has a purpose i guess. But for now its unintuitive, its clunky, and its a pain in the **bleep** whenever i wanna do a simple reshuffle that should take less than a second but now it takes 15 seconds. And on top of all that it just makes the app insanely buggy. Please add the option to disable it completely. And fix your product that im paying 15 dollars a month for.
It seriously is more like a bug than a feature. Please let us permanently disable it in the settings spotify!
Smart Shuffle is a feature nobody asked for. Every time one would like to shuffle their playlist is first confronted by Smart Shuffle, which adds songs to one playlist (extra mobile data). In addition, Smart Shuffle does not allow listeners to optimally enjoy their offline experiences. Therefore, we should have the option to disable it at least.
I've tried the logging in and out workaround but it is only temporary, after a couple hours the doom buffer wheel is back and **bleep**ing up my playlist that I didn't ask for. While I'm at it. Can you make it so my playlists stop automatically organizing to "Recent" when booting up the app? I also didn't ask for that I want my playlist organized to "alphabetical" and STAY in "alphabetical". Please for the love of christ spotify you are pissing off your community! Get**bleep** together this has been a problem for moooonthes.
Is this a joke? I see so many people about to cancel because of this. Along with myself. If there is no solution to this problem they have created for us , in offline mode , causing people to wait. . . Just take it off. It’s a terrible addition
Yes please add this option at the very least. The feature should be thrown into the depths of **bleep**, but the choice to turn it off is a good start.
Plan
Free/Premium
Country
USA, Grenada, any honestly
Device
iPhone 11
Operating System
iOS 16.6
My Question or Issue
I’m an international student and rely 100% on WiFi for my cell phone. Even while in the US (with cell service), I never liked smart shuffle and hated the lag when switching modes. Without WiFi/cell service though, it is not possible to switch modes due to smart shuffle. It needs service to process the switch, and there’s no way for me to bypass it. So if I leave the house on one mode and want to listen to music, I have to wait until I’m reconnected to WiFi so Spotify can process smart shuffle, all for me to skip right past it. PLEASE add a feature to disable. I know a ton of users hate the lag/recommendations/location of smart shuffle in the first place, but I’m trying to get Spotify to understand how this impacts people
who live abroad/don’t have cell service. It has completely ruined Spotify for me, which was a major part of my commute.
Months later and still nothing from Spotify. I cancelled my subscription today because of this issue and how frustrating it makes using Spotify offline.
It wouldn't be so bad if I didn't have to keep hitting it over and over to turn off. It's very frustrating in the car because of you stop smart shuffle it will only play the first song, then you have to pull over our get a passenger to start the playlist again.
I've been an active Spotify user for years dealing with multiple iterations of useless updates which have bogged down the software, making the UX clunkier and inconsistent between multiple versions of the app (for example the lack of smart shuffle on desktop but the inclusion of the ridiculous now playing bar). Your paying customers have asked for the removal of smart shuffle that's tied to the shuffle button on mobile and that's the bare minimum that should be implemented to return the mobile app back to its former functionality.
My conspiracy theory is that smart shuffle has been introduced so Spotify has more control over the music that premium users listen to. That way, they can work with labels and artists to promote their content across millions of playlists, without relying on organic growth.
At the extortionate rate Spotify charges, turning the consumer into the product so blatantly is leaving a demonstrably bad taste in your users mouths. Remove smart shuffle completely or give users an option to permanently disable a feature that is useless and boggs down an already buggy app!
This smart shuffle is beyond stupid and I want it gone or potentially leaving spotify. I love to shuffle my library but since it would start selecting the smart shuffle afterwords I have nothing but issues now. When smart shuffle gets turned off it will literally take me to the same spot in my library no matter how deep into it am. I will disable it and the next song is right in the middle of the an album. It's so frustrating the logging out and logging in helps that issue but is only temporary. Closing the app and reopening it cause smart shuffle to be back. Please let us disable it
it’s not a matter of OS, smart shuffle always takes a few seconds to generate its recommendations…. and i think a lot of people just want the shuffle button to toggle between shuffle and nonshuffle. myself included. would appreciate an option to disable smart shuffle completely
Me too! I gate this stupid function
Please give us a button to disable**bleep**!!!
Yea come one make this already
As I stated in the Introducing Smart Shuffle! thread, I (including [mostly] everyone else here and in the other thread) very much dislike this change, or rather, the implementation. Please add an option to disable this feature so we don't have to consider alternatives. It can really ruin someone's listening experience.
LET ME OUT!
I dont want this nonsense! Let me at least opt out brun.
It takes an eternity and 2 clicks instead of one to disable smart shuffle
End it already please ...
This needs to be an option. I don’t ever want random songs in my playlist and reshuffling (due to poor shuffle in the first place) is incredibly slow with this new “feature.”
It ruins the ability to listen to Spotify playlists when you don’t have service. I downloaded all of my songs in my playlist for a long flights where I wasn’t sure Wi-Fi would be free. I was completely unable to listen bc Wi-Fi wasn’t free and Smart Shuffle is the default. When I went to listen to the playlist the message stated couldn’t listen because SS was active, to turn SS off - but it wouldn’t let me open the playlist to even turn SS off. This is the worst feature ever, I immediately turn it off when I open my playlist-and may be the feature that causes me to cancel our premium family Spotify account. Currently researching other options which sucks since our family has been paying members since 2016.
Smart Shuffle is a garbage feature and you should have made it opt in (or at least a separate button from shuffle) from the beginning. It's ridiculous that this ever made it past QC. If this doesn't get fixed I'm canceling my subscription and encouraging everyone I know to do the same. The UI/UX "upgrades" over the past few years along with the awful focus on podcasts indicate to me that Spotify is going the way of enshittification and frankly I'm tired of paying to be a product.
smart shuffle takes too long and waste my time. sometimes when i press it too fast my spotify freezes and i cant pause my songs, basically completely breaking the app. i have to remove and open back up the app. please spotify, js remove smart shuffle and add back enhance instead.
Exactly, now I have to turn on my data to switch modes. An ON and OFF button needs to be implemented.
I have been a spotify fan for more then 8 years, but this weird ‘feature’ makes me want to go back to my mp3 player 😕
Please!!! I just want to listen to my playlists in order. That's why I pay for premium. Please let us disable the shuffle toggle! I hate it when it switches to shuffle when updates happen or when I accidentally bump the button. It is the WORST!! Please please please add this option I'm begging you
I can't get shuffle at all anymore on iOS on mobile. It is smart shuffle (which is the stupidest feature ever - the reason I make playlists is to hear the music I want to hear!) or nothing. I am so frustrated.
I have turned it off and it continues to play smart shuffle songs.
So, I am going to try uninstalling/ signing out and signing back in and everything but I just want to complain, too.
So about two weeks ago, Smart Shuffle became my personal enemy.
All I want is to listen to my TSwift playlist in peace, but literally- it does not matter how often I click the "smart shuffle" off- it comes back on. CONSTANTLY. Like, I'll turn it off- play a song, and during the song the smart shuffle will come back on. Instead of happily listening to Enchanted, I'm listening to some rando band I didn't want. I'm not emotionally ready to listen to other artists and Smart Shuffle keeps judging my choices and it is NOT cool.
I have to turn off the smart shuffle every time, during and after every song at this point.
I want it gone.
I deleted the widget and started using the app itself- didn't stop the issue.
This is AI taking over if I've ever seen it. It is haunting my dreams and giving me severe anger issues. At this point, imma go out and buy straight-up CDs I'm so done with this **bleep**.
Oh! I tried turning to offline mode and it STILL didn't work! AI literally said F** you to my data boundaries in order to push its stupid a** suggestions on an unwilling ear.
I have been a premium subscriber and avid lover of all things Spotify and these last two weeks have me questioning all my life choices. Please, for the love of God, just let us turn the stupid thing off- I think you have enough complaints to warrant an attempt at the very least.
This is not a solution. I shuffle the 10k plus liked songs I have on the app and hear the same 10-20 songs every day, it honestly drives me nuts to have the algorithm try and suggest what it thinks I want to hear. I WANT TO HEAR IT ALLL!!!!! Remove the Smart Shuffle feature, or at least develop it to be optional because it's asinine for musician types like myself. I also don't want to play my playlists/liked songs in any of the other sorting methodologies, because then I'll end up getting tons of songs played by the same artist, which is also something I don't want when I'm trying to get some flipping variety in my life... As I dive into it deeper I have noticed that this "enhancement" to your product will cause my devices to play the same songs in the same order every time I play a playlist/liked songs, and often will repeat songs within 10-15min of each other even if I have selected "Regular Shuffle", so to me it looks like the development of this smart shuffle has caused issues with the normal shuffle functionality and needs to be fixed if you want to retain your customer base. Another aspect of your poor development... I am on the 8.8.60.501 iOS version,