[All Platforms] Option to have a true shuffle

So I’ve been noticing more and more recently that Spotify’s default shuffle feature doesn’t fully shuffle your songs. It does some sort of grouping to try to get similar songs together based off of what I’m sure is dozens of factors. Every time I shuffle a playlist (the one I noticed this with the most is ~100 songs and 6 hours of mostly full albums) it will group the songs mostly or completely together by album/artist, and given the number of times I’ve re-shuffled and checked the order there’s no way it’s just a coincidence. They also generally seem to be in the same order as well. If I hit shuffle play on a playlist it’ll generally put the same artists at the beginning every time.

 

With larger playlists of albums I am really not a fan of this shuffling method. If I have 6 hours of music on a playlist I will hardly ever have 6 hours to actually listen through the whole thing, but when I do listen to it I would like to hear all of the music on it equally, and not just the artist or two your algorithm likes to shuffle to first.

 

Anyways, I’m a reasonable man, all I’m asking for is an option to have a true shuffle (take all songs in the list, put them in a random order, and once they’re all played reshuffle them and play them again). Make it premium only if you want. I don’t think you should scrap the current shuffle algorithm because it sucks. Looking at some of the suggestions on here it seems like some people lobbied hard to have it that way. Just add an option for a true shuffle for those of us that don’t care about potentially getting the same song twice in a row.

Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

this is so frustrating when you see that you get apps that can apparently do a tru shuffle, meaning that there is huge demand for this. Im getting so frustrated listening to the same somgs that ive even signed up with Apple Music to see if they do a better shuffle. Even got out the old ipod the other day as this does have a true shuffle!

"[I've] even signed up with Apple Music to see if they do a better shuffle"

 

I don't know about Apple Music. I moved to Amazon Music and with regard to "true shuffle" I would have bad news and good news. Amazon Music's shuffle is probably not a huge amount better than Spotify's, but it wouldn't be "Shuffle" you're looking for. In Amazon Music there is an option "randomise playlist" and that is the option you'd need as that randomises the entire play list after which you'd just go and play it without applying any shuffle from start to finish.

 

I'm not sure whether something similar may be in place for Apple Music?

Someone mentioned Spotify losing paying customers, but that's not all they lose. I'm one of those "free" customers, so they earn a little from advertising from me. I doubt ad dollars are as much subscription dollars, but those ad dollars are going away as some of us "free" folks also switch away. 

 

I've been trying out Pandora for a few months, and now haven't gone back to Spotify for at least the last month. Pandora doesn't have lists, but since Spotify doesn't have the kind of list I want (randomized), there's no loss for me. Pandora is more of a "radio station" music player, but I like their selection better than Spotify's radio version. I pick a single artist I like and their "radio station" plays that artist's music about half the time. The other half is a pretty good selection of similar music. It's not the same as a list where I pick each song, but it's pretty close enough. I may hear a song I wouldn't have selected for a list, but only because I've got Pandora set to "Deep cuts" or sometimes "Discovery", each of which finds songs I haven't heard before. I often have to go to the app to see who's playing because it's pretty awesome.

That comment about Amazon Music's "shuffle" vs "randomize" is interesting. Once upon a time, "shuffle" meant "randomize", at least where music lists were concerned. The term came from shuffling playing cards, which is meant to randomize them. So it appears the music companies have decided to re-define "shuffle" to maximize profits. But hold on, maybe they didn't...

 

Take a look at Merriam-Webster's definition of "Shuffle":

https://tinyurl.com/254q4x8r

 

One of the definitions is, "Intransitive verb #2:  to act or speak in a shifty or evasive manner"

Hmmmmmm....... Maybe the music players just decided to use Option #2 instead of Transitive verb #3a.

 

 

Yeah LOL....

 

Ok even if Spotify's "shuffle" was made with the best of intentions and nothing nefarious is going on, the problem is that the algorithm cannot work as people would expect. The reason is that their "shuffle" is based on a play queue of 80 songs. When you play songs in "shuffle" mode it actually creates a queue of 80 songs by "randomly" picking 80 songs from your play list. So far so good, but then it does this. It starts playing song number 1 from your queue. When that song is played, it removes it from the queue, song number 2 becomes song number 1, song number 3 becomes song number 2, etc..... song number 80 becomes song number 79, and it "randomly" picks a song from your play list and puts it in position 80. And then it goes and plays song number 1, and it just keeps repeating that process.

 

And that is fundamentally flawed. As I illustrated in my code samples which I put in GITHUB and you can find elsewhere in this long and pointless thread, it won't be very long at all before you will start hearing songs again that you have already heard. If you have a play list with 1,000 songs in it, and by the time the "shuffled" play list plays the 100th song and you start hearing songs you've already heard, of course you're going to conclude that the shuffle is broken. Of course the shuffle IS broken if that happens as there are 900 songs you haven't heard yet in your playlist.

 

And this happens if everything else about the algorithm is 100% "honest". If the provider starts prioritising pet artists or popular songs, it gets infinitely worse. It's the algorithm that is wrong at its core, and no amount of tweaking can fix it.

 

 

 

I would just like to give you a suggestion to make the app better. I have currently 1,800+ liked songs and would like to listen to them in a random order but when I listen to it on shuffle play it always wants to play the same music all the time. You need to create some kind of play count tracking that shuffle always plays the lowest number play count. So far the best way for me to listen to them randomly is to sort them by album and listen to them not on shuffle but even that has its problems. Every time I stopped listening and then start again it plays the previous song but then starts randomly shuffling unless I go through the list and find the spot where I'm at and manually start it over at that spot.

2 years later and there is still no actual random shuffle... Where can i see the latest news about whether this idea is actually still being considered or not?

Listen everyone, 100% True shuffle mode is not gonna happen the way we want
it to be, rather I can see a path that has lead to the "DJ" mode which BTW
is worth giving a try, it is the closest thing I can find on spotify that
plays my liked songs with bit of Flair (a man talking about my liked
playlist) and if your not "vibing" as he says, hit that DJ button to change
the mood/genre/song/vibe.
Just my thoughts regarding why I believe Spotify is pursuing the truest
shuffle mode they can find in the DJ mode while creating newer
technologies to accommodate our request to have our "Liked" songs played in
their entirety.
I could be wrong, however, enbrace what is there like DJ mode, Shuffle and
make it work or just try another vendor. I know it is a cause for concern
and yeah I am not happy that it does not work the way iTunes or Pandora'
shuffle mode does, but Spotify is different and that is why I use them in
the 1st place!
After 3 years with Spotify mode and now in the future when my wife gets
back from Europe this summer we will start using Spotify Duo, another
feature I find valuable and worth the small fee to upgrade to this plan.

thanks for listening and reading this post

JT Rock'n Rossi

When listening to a Playlist, I'm hearing songs being repeated almost immediately sometimes. Meanwhile others don't get played at all. There are over 2600 songs on one Playlist so how is it possible that I hear many songs played almost back to back when Spotify is in shuffle mode?

Irritating that pricing is going to increase & yet a true shuffle has not been resolved. Like many other users, my playlists are 1000s of songs/hundreds of hours, but I get the same handful of songs playing over & over.  This issue increasingly bothers me & I am seriously considering starting over with another service who actually listens to consumers. I can’t believe Spotify has been ignoring this issue from customers for 3 years! SPOTIFY, listen to your paying customers!

…and being a high school teacher who has a specific classroom playlist… I will be MORE than happy to promote a better music service to my students if you cannot fix yours!

Been way longer than that. They’re fools who don’t have the will or talent
to craft a true shuffle.


GOOD NEWS EVERYONE!

Today for the first time clicking on shuffle gave me an option between "shuffle" and "smart shuffle".

 

Thank you Spotify people! 💖

 

PS: If this is a gimmick, I will be back very angry 😛

sorry but it's not what you think.
we will be here waiting for you to come back crying.
and we will support you.
don't be afraid, you are not alone.
Gimmick

Exactly. It's a gimmick and a useless one to boot. The solution is not to make the shuffle "smart" whatever they think that should mean. The solution is to make it as dumb as possible. Simply reorder ALL the songs in some random order and then allow the user to play them in that new random order from top to bottom. That's it. That is all that's required.

The last thing we want is a "smart" (DUMB) shuffle, what we want is a truly random shuffle. One that doesn't repeat until all of the songs in the playlist have been played. As many have said before, it's an hour or two's work to do that, I wrote that code 30 years ago.

Le Français est la langue de vos clients Français.

Tel que le spécifie la réglementation Européenne retranscrit en droit Français et Suédois, c'est à vous de vous y adapter.

Et comme Spotify ne fait pas son travail je partage la trouvaille du jour :

https://www.chosic.com/spotify-playlist-analyzer
Grâce à ce service j'ai pu résoudre le dysfonctionnement :

  1. Analysez votre playlist
  2. Cherchez le paragraphe "Playlist Table"
  3. Cliquez sur "Shuffle"
  4. Sauvegardez sur Spotify

Merci à l'éditeur de ce site et honte à Spotify qui refuse de fournir une fonction fondamentale qui existe et fonctionne parfaitement sur toutes les autres plateformes de streaming (Youtube Music, Deezer, Amazon Mucis, SoundClound).

Its even easier, just add another button called Random and leave the current shuffle as is.... come on I listen to my liked songs playlist which has nearly 1000 songs whilst I work, and I would like to listen to all my liked songs equally!

Are you kidding me? I have over 2600 songs on one playlist. It would take
days to reorder them all and make them random! This is a problem that
Spotify needs to adress! #- Please type your reply above this line -##

2023 and still no update? Or am i missing something? Because "shuffle" as annoyingly repetitive as it was when this idea was created 3 years ago...

So driving down the M5 in the UK, playlist with 2h 36m worth of songs, and within 1h 15m a song had been repeated!

Someone needs to get a grip at Spotify.

I pay for this service, and they are not delivering a satisfactory customer experience.

 

Clearly Spotify has no interest in providing us with a true shuffle for some reason. What a simple and obvious feature every music service should have. They, like all tech companies these days want to force whatever content they want on the user and do everything they can to keep us from listening how we choose. 

Bonjour , même problème j'en peu plus j'arrête définitivement et cette manque de considération de la part de Spotify c'est un honte, je vais essayé apple music, j'ai déjà un compte youtube payant entre les 2 je trouverai mon bonheur je pense. Pourtant ça faisait longtemps que nous étions sur Spotify ma famille et moi. Boycott Spotify 

Spotify, après maints échanges et demandes injustifiées de leur part, a reconnu que leur lecture aléatoire ne l'était pas et qu'ils décidaient à la place du client ce qu'il doit écouter.

Extrait : "Nous comprenons que la fonction de lecture aléatoire ne reproduit pas toutes les chansons d'une playlist. Cependant, on s'attend à ce que dans les grandes playlists (plus de 150 chansons), la lecture aléatoire donne la priorité aux chansons que Spotify perçoit comme vous les appréciez le plus, il est donc possible que vous entendiez certaines chansons plus que d'autres. Pas de soucis; vous pouvez simplement désactiver le mode aléatoire pour lire toute la playlist dans l'ordre."
C'est un total irrespect du client, de l'être humain.
Depuis la date de mon post, j'ai demandé :

  1. une date à laquelle la fonction lecture aléatoire sera opérationnelle : aucune réponse depuis.
  2. une proposition de compensation pour service non fonctionnel : la réponse a été une menace de suspension de l'offre en place (oui, vous lisez bien...)

Certains se croient à l'abri, mais les textes de loi sont là et chacun doit s'y soumettre.
Sachant que le juge ultime est le client 😉

Plan

Premium

Device

iPhone 12

 

 

My Question or Issue

Smart shuffle and shuffle issues has ruined my experience with Spotify. I didn't use SS at first, but when I tried it, I really enjoyed it until this started happening. It plays the same songs over and over, and I can't disable it. I will turn shuffle completely off, yet it still adds the same songs with the little sparkles saying it is from SS. After that started happening, my shuffle also broke. Instead of shuffling my playlists, no matter what song I click on first or how many times I click off of shuffle and back on, it plays the same sequence. Every day. It is getting very annoying, and I don't know what to do. The app is up to date. 

This is still a problem!! 

It's been over 10 years and they still haven't fixed it. 

Create a random shuffle option. It really can't be that hard.

This has ruined the app for me as I hardly hear 90 percent of my songs.

I haven't been using "shuffle" anymore, with few exceptions. I tried "enhanced playlists", which are sometimes inspiring but mostly worse than before and unrelated to the original, quite simple, feature request.

Come on Spotify, don't become the next Twitter.

You know we're still here and haven't left yet, but the time will come.

Plan

Premium

Country

US

Device

(iPhone 8, Macbook Pro late 2016)

Operating System

(iOS 10, Android Oreo, Windows 10,etc.)

 

My Question or Issue

In a playlist that is all songs from one artist, around 20 - 25 of them, it only plays around 10 from one album. I don't get why, if I wanted to play those songs, I would obviously just play the album itself! 

Is this still something being looked into?  I have same issue of constantly hearing the same songs from my playlist.  I like to just play from my *liked songs* playlist but somehow even with over 1000 songs o heart the same stuff over and over again. Especially in a single day or two or will seem to play from the same group of songs so I will regularly hear the same artist and songs over and over again despite hundreds of songs I almost never hear.

Given that in less than a month it will be the 2 year anniversary of
someone from Spotify pretending to care, it's not going to happen. They
want you to hear what they want you to hear (AKA what makes them the most
money) not what you want to hear. You have two options, either use a
seperate program that puts your playlist in random order so you can listen
to it with shuffle off or give your hard earned money to a company that
cares about its paying customers
[image: Spotify.jpg]
Child Item
Child Item