Hey @voidhawker,
Thanks for reaching out.
Can you please provide links to a few more examples, so we can investigate this further? Also, does this happen always when you request a particular song?
Keep us posted.
Yup it happens every time for this song. I have not found a work around.
To demonstrate it all I need to do is say
"Hey Google, play diamonds by Rhianna on Spotify"
Hey @voidhawker,
Thanks for confirming.
Can you please also send us links to some of the other tracks where you see this behavior?
Cheers,
I can't believe you moderators are asking for examples of this behaviour! Hundreds of people have been asking for years to just be able to play the standard album version of songs when interacting with Google Home or Google assistant. It is so frustrating to keep getting live or alternate versions of songs. I assume that's because you don't have to pay as many royalties, but it just means we have to go locate the phone, pick it up, turn it on, open Spotify, hit search, find the actual album song and then play it. Frustrating.
Hey @goog64,
Thanks for your comment.
I fully understand your frustration and I apologize for not providing context for my previous requests for links.
Note that this issue was investigated a few years back by our tech team (the thread has been archived so I can't link it here) and after some joint effort by Spotify and Google a fix was rolled out.
Seeing your comments, I understand that the behavior has resurfaced, but with just one example it would be difficult to start a new investigation, so if any particular tracks come to mind, please share them here so we can compile a new report for our tech team. The more examples we have, the easier it would be to get the ball rolling on this new investigation.
Thanks!
For some other examples, "play "Ghost" by Hoshimachi Suisei" will play the instrumental version and asking for "Magia Quattro" by Kalafina will play regular Magia
Latest Automatic for the People Pumped up Kicks, Red Hot Chili Peppers Give it Away
"Rusholme Ruffians" by the Smiths.
Thanks for your reply and sorry for my slow response. I estimate that for almost a quarter of the songs I request, some version other than the standard album version (that I'm hoping to hear) gets played. Some examples:
Lighthouse - The Waifs
New Orleans is Sinking - Tragically Hip
It's Too Late - Carol King
Big Indian - The Dandy Warhols
And it's almost impossible to get the speaker to play Bourée by Jethro Tull (we have tried every pronunciation of "Bourée" that we can think of.
Another example of Google Assistant playing the live version: The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down by Joan Baez
Happens to me as well.
Example: Sonique - it feels so good.
Always have to add 'radio edit' when asking Google Assistant or I get a remix
How is this still happening years later?
Exactly. It's so frustrating.
Just asked for Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen and got the muppets version, are you kidding me?
Dog Days by Florence and the Machine got a remix.
Praying by Kesha got some remix.
Space ghost coast to coast by glass animals also got a remix.
These are huge hit songs with a billion listens on the regular version, there should be no confusion as to what I want. The worst part is even specifying artist or saying original version doesn't seem to work.
Hey folks,
Thanks for all the info you've sent!
It'd be great if you can provide the Spotify links to both the song version you want played and the one that Google Assistant plays + a screen recording of what happens when you ask for a song to be played. If the file is too large to attach, you can upload it to Google Drive (make sure to allow general access to the file) or as an unlisted YouTube video. Once we gather all this additional info, we'll be able to have this reported.
Keep us posted.
Sounds like you are making this complicated because you don't REALLY want to fix it maybe?
How about this for an idea:
When someone requests a song via Google Assistant, DON'T play a live version unless someone says "live" in their request?
I am having this same problem with "I Can Do It With A Broken Heart" by Taylor Swift. I would be fine with it playing either the filtered version (https://open.spotify.com/track/29ZAW0BAp6O4C6fUncCjBk) or the explicit version (https://open.spotify.com/track/4q5YezDOIPcoLr8R81x9qy) but every time, it plays the instrumental version instead (https://open.spotify.com/track/0Z8YQJNXTCZqflWehjoJqJ). I cannot figure out a workaround for this.
Thanks for the details everyone! We'll investigate further 👍
As soon as we have any updates rest assured we'll keep you posted here, so stay tuned!
Cheers 🤘
This is rife again for me. Asked for two songs this morning and straight up both were alternative versions. Great Southern land by icehouse played a live version, everybody wants to rule the world by years for fears plays an alternate
I said, "Hey Google, play Uptown Funk." I got this: https://open.spotify.com/track/5U84vBvWfmZZuT2uqupmmB?si=i7SfFB4LQnq-nAZp0DNdYA
Absolutely absurd.
This thread was started quite a long time ago, and the issue is still there. The thread is marked as solved but it isn't. What was suggested was a kludgy work around rather than a solution. For this work around to work, you also have to know in advance what song you will want to listen to. I tried asking for "Come Monday" by Jimmy Buffet, and a weird version with the Henry Mancini Orchestra played. Even getting more specific about my request did not work. While driving, I cannot open the app, to bring up the proper song. I agree, The top result should play. Live versions of requested songs that I don't want to hear often come up, and asking for the album version does not work. (IE: "Mountain Dance" by Dave Grusin). Artists often Riff; change the melody; words; or there is just to much crowd noise in live versions. All of this (In my opinion) seriously detracts from the song and my enjoyment. Those that like the live, altered, duet versions of solo songs, or songs redone by another artist should specify that version. The Album (or popular) version of the song usually comes up first in most of my Spotify searches, and aught to be the song that plays when I request it from Spotify through Android Auto. Is there an actual fix for this issue possible? The suggested "Work Around" isn't a fix, and this thread should have never been marked as solved.
Addendum: (There doesn't seem to be an edit button on my original post.) Perhaps "Mountain Dance" by Dave Grusin was a bad example. I just did a search through the App, and every instance of the original of that song is "Greyed Out" and unplayable. Why this is, I don't know. This was just an example though. There are plenty of other songs that will play in the original format through the app, that will not come up when requested through Android Auto, and a live or alternate version is played. I just wanted to drop this revision in, because I didn't want to leave a bad example posted.
I managed to listen to "Come Monday" by Jimmy Buffet by asking for the album "Living and Dyeing in 3/4 time, and bumping the track until the proper song came up. This work around could be problematical if you don't know the name of the album the original was on; and I shouldn't have to go through that to listen to an original version of a song.
Hey everyone,
We're unable to provide an ETA for a fix at the moment, but rest assured our teams are actively working on improving this behavior. We’re always looking for opportunities to enhance the user experience for everyone and your feedback on this is greatly appreciated, thanks for sharing it here.
The Community is just a post away if there's anything else we can assist with in the meantime.
Take care 💚
Hi,
Quite often when I use voice controls (whilst driving using Android Auto) to request a specific song, Spotify will select a live or alternate version. It doesn't matter what you say (for example "play the original version of xxxx") it'll still just play the version it wants you to hear.
Weirdly, there also seems to be an issue where certain fake versions of songs are being played. When I ask for Chandelier by Sia it plays a fake version with someone tunelessly screeching along to a quiet version of the original. It seems almost impossible to listen to the correct version.
Has anyone else come across this and found a solution please?
"Play Rap God by Eminem on Spotify" got me a remix.
"Play Shallows by Lady Gaga" got me an acoustic cover.
"Play Childish Gambino" got me "Waiting For My Moment by Donald Glover", instead of literally anything by Childish Gambino.
Any update on this issue? This started for us over a month ago, and is now occurring on every Google device we have (hub max, home, 2 minis) every time we ask for a song.
Every. Single. Song.
This is garbage I pay for a service that can't play a simple requested song if this is not resolved in the next 7day I'm cancelling my subscription I use googe home all the time and this has only started happening for me fix your S@#$.
"Play Miley Cyrus Mother's Daughter" and it plays a shitty remix, how the F^$# am I going to sing that in the shower...
Please please STOP PLAYING LIVE VERSIONS OF SONGS when I ask for a song via my Google Home Speaker. It's happening more than half the time now.
Or at least please GIVE US BACK THE DISLIKE BUTTON so we can stop them from playing in future.
Thanks for looking into it mate
)
Here's a little list of songs I've noticed
Living next door to Alice - smoke
Miss Jackson - Outkast
Cowgirl in the sand - Neil Young
Echoes - Pink Floyd
Have a cigar - Pink Floyd
Wish you were here - Pink Floyd
Take me to church - Hozier
Ex-Factor - Ms. Lauryn Hill
Born to run - Bruce Springsteen
Glory Days - Bruce Springsteen
Stand by me - Ben E. King
Paranoid - Black Sabbath
Drops of Jupiter - Train
So fresh, so clean - Outkast (plays radio mix)
Hey Ya! - Outkast (plays slow version)
Muffin man - Frank Zappa (It should play the Bongo Fury Version)
Hey folks,
Jumping in here to let you know that this is still being worked on. In the meantime, feel free to reach out to Google Support or post on their forum to report this.
Cheers,