Creating this as a related issue to this thread that spotify have stopped giving a toss about:
DO NOT MERGE this moderators, this is a very specific issue.
Release Radar is increasingly full of scam artists who tag more popular artists as collaborators. This is particularly egregious when they tag artists who are DEAD.
This isn't just affecting big label artists, smaller niche artists, who are big within their niche are getting the same treatment. Maybe more easily as the smaller artists don't have the voice to do anything about it?
Just this week I have the following:
An artist called LYONA doing some cheesy EDM, it's their only track, tagging two respected electronic musicians Weval and Kiasmos - Kiasmos being the electronic side project of respected film composer Olafur Arnalds.
An artist called EVASION, also only made one track, apparently in collaboration with Rival Consoles and Ben Lukas Boyson. No they didn't.
Yet another artist with only one track, a cheesy EDM pop soul track with underground techno producer ASC?
Apparently nothern UK house act Bent have created a grime track with an obscure non-english speaking rapper called Mevo? No, they haven't, its another scam
The most offensive of all, some african pop act who, again, only have one song, which is a collaboration with british trans experimental pop artist SOPHIE, who sadly passed away last year.
This has gotten completely out of hand, I'm guessing these are being generated by bots now or something?
The worst bit of all this, is Spotify have REMOVED any way of reporting these tracks! If you follow the FAQ, it tells you to report the artist, but there is no option to report based on this critera, only info in their photos or bio.
Why won't spotify take action?
This problem is getting worse and worse. I see it a lot with rappers who, based on the production values of the tracks, are unknown and just starting out. They tag dozens of massive bands as collaborators, mostly in unrelated niches and with band names that seems completely out of place for their genre.
This is a very clever game on their side. Nobody knows who they are, they have nothing to lose so they do this and suddenly are showing up in the discover feeds and new release feeds for 1000s of people. Free promotion. It's a little crazy that Spotify allows this, however. If someone tags another artist, that artist needs to verify this collaboration.
Hello folks,
Thank you for reaching out to the Community.
We have a process to report an artist or a playlist directly. In this type of reports, you can use the 3 dots of the playlists or artist profile and hit the Report button.
In case you want to report a specific song from an artist for having incorrect information, we recommend you to contact our Customer Support to help you further with this.
If you think that other users would like to see a report button on albums or songs too, you can give these steps a go and submit your idea so other people can vote for it. The higher the number of votes an idea gets, the more likely it is for it to be implemented.
If anything else comes up, the Community will be here for you.
I've reported a bunch of tracks in the past, it takes weeks for any action to occur, if any. Then the same artist does it again. And other artists keep doing it.
This has been an issue people have been reporting to you for YEARS. About a year ago, one of your mods took some interest, asked us to compile a bunch of data for him, then just suddenly gave up and stopped responding.
You have demonstrated no serious interest in fixing this issue. After many years of being a paying subscriber to spotify, I have switched platforms.
This is happening every week now in my Release Radar, and as someone pointed out, it's almost always rappers.
The reporting process is awful (I have to enter my email address, paste a verification code, and then the form that presents only has one option to do with the track visuals?)
The worst bit is that once you get fooled by these scammers, they keep reappearing then in future Release Radars because Spotify thinks you're a fan of them! Spotify need to do better here!
I get the feeling that there may be a Spotify promotion / spam service that will put these unrelated artists onto random tracks.
I think there should be a verification system, so that the artist tagged in a track needs to verify it themselves before they actually show up as co-artists. I am sure that the artists themselves do not approve of their name and reputation being used by a random artist for self-promotion.
Also, Spotify's algorithms for generating the Release Radar, Discovery Weekly and other generated playlists should be more clever I think; if I have listened to a certain artist, I'm mainly interested in music from that artist, not so much different artists (in a completely different genre like hip-hop) that happen to have that artist tagged. I mean I like collaborations, but only if they are legitimate.
I think this is a big algorithm abuse issue, and I hope the artists abusing these systems by intentonally mis-tagging their tracks with different unrelated artists get reprimanded for it.
This is happening a lot in the Synthwave community recently. There's an "artist" who essentially without permission takes other artist's tracks and sings over them, then releases them as collaborations to abuse Release Radar. Spotify and other platforms should at least have a tool to remove unauthorised music from the artist profile if nothing else.
Try to get your company to fix the problem for your paying customers instead of making your customers do the work. If we can figure out what is fake then so can you. At the very least, give us a report choice that is actually related to this scenario. Right now you can only report things such as the artist's bio text or merch. We can't even help you effectively as it is now.
It can't be to hard to just have a login for artists? To post as an artist, or to post a collaboration with an artist, the artist then needs to confirm in that account.
You can't even report the person doing this properly. It gives you options that all have nothing to do with fraudulent songs that are either taken from others artists, tag artists that haven't worked on the song or claim to be released on a label that they have no officially released on. I don't get how this is even a thing in the first place
It's astounding to me that this STILL has not been addressed by Spotify! Talk about being hands off as a company. Literally screwing over artists letting people work the system.
It seems to happen in waves as well - I get these 1-2 minute generic "songs" pop up, claiming to be collaborating with actual artists, headed by these unknown artists with only this one song in their collection.
Attempts to make "easy money" by taking advantage of the intention to recognize collaborators more fully. Spotify provides a method to credit un-credited featured artists, and this attempt is utilized to swindle Spotify.
The attempt towards fairness (even if small) is thwarted by a selfish sense of justice. The irony is tragic.
For sure, an option to identify suspected collaborative fraud would be helpful. Apparently an unseen loophole Spotify would be interested in managing (I assume they unwillingly pay for the fraud).
Just had this happen to me today!! So annoying. There needs to be a better system for this. Maybe the tagged artist has to approve their feature before the song is posted?
This just happened to me, but they'd I'd not say it was a collaboration they are saying the I released the track, it only carries my artist name, and I've reported it, even so, spotify is saying it will take 10 to 15 business days to fix...... unbelievable
It's driving me crazy as well. I work in the music industry and Spotify really doesn't seem to allow you to flag a song as being a fake collaboration. So ridiculous, and it leads to Release Radar increasingly losing credibility!
Yes, I was hoping to find a way to report these. It's not just rap artists.
Joni Mitchell left the Spotify platform and removed her music. Yet many many covers of songs of hers have her tagged as a collaborator. And in fact it appears someone has uploaded live recordings of some of her songs, with generic cover art, created a profile in her name and is profiting off it.
I cannot emphasize enough how overwhelmingly frustrating this is. Spotify has (in my opinion) been above average with community involvement, especially when it comes to certain bugs or features that CLEARLY represent a need for expedited troubleshooting and patching.
To me (and I am sure the vast majority of not just other subscribers, but artists) this is easily in the Top 5 of issues that we need to address. It appears that it is with ease that these nobody "artists" are able on a weekly basis, every release day, release tracks with someone you'll be awfully familiar with. An artist (band, group, etc) with MILLIONS of streams.
Everything here to me is a "First World Problem". That said,as paid users on your streaming application, this feature, or LACK of a certain feature creates this on-going issue that isn't something you wonder that you'll run into every now and then. It is every single week without fail and I'd hope there is a method that your team can implement just to simply verify these CLEARLY new accounts with single or double digit streams and followers need to be checked if they ANY artist with over a certain amount. I know on occasion a larger artist will feature on a smaller artists track. This should not play a role in this issue. What i'm referring to is ABUNDENTLY clear.
Really do hope as in the past I've seen you guys act on some issues the user community faces like this. Please address this issue at your earliest convenience.
I agree with all the posts in this thread… it’s getting out of hand.
there has to be a way for a notification to be sent to all artists listed in the upload and prompt an approval from each artist listed. it seems like an artist verification/ approval process would eliminate the uploading artist from their claim of collaboration or artist feature if all parties listed in the songs credits must approve the upload.
this way the lesser known artist uploading media with false credits wouldn’t infiltrate the users preferences or infringe upon the rights of the falsely claimed artist involved.
does this make sense?
So frustrating, I'm following thousands of artists who's new music I want to receive, yet precious slots in the release radar are taken up by these scams. Most of these tracks are so trashy that I don't even think these are genuine starting/delusional small artists but just some kind of bot farming schemes that try to collect some streaming revenue
Amen. I have this issue all the time, to the point where I've stopped listening to my Release Radar because EVERY WEEK there is a scam track mixed in there and there's no way to report them! There needs to be a reporting system added back in...It's frankly appalling that Spotify doesn't have all artists that are listed on a song approve a track before it goes live. Spotify truly has no respect for the artists who have their clout taken advantage of on a daily basis.
Yeah this has been going on for many years now. I think some are bots, some are released by scummy promotion companies. However others (and probably most) are actual individuals doing this.
Because Spotify never did anything about this, I took matters into my own hands and started finding the rappers on social media and messaging them. Most didn’t reply, but one of them said that the rapper’s name happened to be the same.
If this is actually true, then certain distributors may be at fault. Artists get a unique string ID on Spotify much like all of its users do, platforms like Distrokid require the artist ID when distributing. If the two artists legitimately both use the name, why are they going onto the same ID?
I’m not entirely sure what Spotify requires from distributors prior to distribution, but if artist ID is required then there is intentional misuse on the user side: either the artist is pasting the ID that doesn’t belong to them or the distributor is parsing the artist name and pulling the ID for the user. In the latter, I’d have to guess those distributors take royalties and we have a serious case of fraud— or really crappy development.
So already for over 2 years this issue has been nagging users, including me. Almost every week there's a track by some unknown artist whose name always goes first in the list of artists, but obviously it had not been made with the well-known artist it claims to be a collaboration with.
Example of this week is the 'artist' zackLL who claims to have made a track with the famous Hardstyle artist Bass Modulators: https://open.spotify.com/track/6IwVs8GS5flYFXJV50GnfB?si=bca6231ad21f471c
It's not even the genre Hardstyle that the only 1 minute track is, which is the only genre that Bass Modulators produces.
So I have this playlist called `Release Radar history` which gets automatically filled with what's in the Release Radar by an applet on IFTTT and when I checked this `zackLL` I saw that another track of this so-called artist is saved in that playlist... Oddly enough the collaboration has been removed but not the play count, which stands at a whopping 73k. So it hasn't been the first time this 'artist' has done this and it can just continue scamming Spotify for streaming revenue by tricking legitimate users into listening to their track of a fake collaboration.
On my Android phone I can just block this 'artist' so it won't be played again, but somehow that doesn't work on the desktop app and the underlying issue is not solved.
I'm so massive frustrated and fed up with these practices and Spotify doesn't seem to care to fix these very important issues, no they seem to rather break good working features (like removing the heart icon) or adding features we don't need (like (pushing) podcasts or adding the AI DJ).
I've been a loyal paying customer for many years but I find myself on the verge of ditching Spotify altogether.
Can you please restore faith and convince this customer to stay? I just want to listen to my favourite music without any annoying issues.
Update: some 'artist' named Lokass abuses the name of D-Block & S-te-Fan with a track called Eidolon Tears: https://open.spotify.com/track/57tJJ6bxNn7bkq0jOluwXK
I think I should keep updating this message with all the weekly examples I find in my Release Radar and it would be nice of others join in the effort so we actually show what's wrong with Spotify nowadays.
Just remove this SPAM!
This, most likely AI, 'artist' ZackLL releases tracks and tags well-known Hardstyle artists and somehow it's allowed to keep doing that. Why not block this name altogether?
Current victims are Phuture Noize, Sound Rush, D-Sturb:
https://open.spotify.com/track/6XGFBWHLMt4efg1pZd22iD?si=8b31a24f8ddc42f0
This is happening a lot. Since I am a fan of some big artists I like to check whom is putting their names in others artists music, and from my reasearch I found all of the next releases are using in this case the name of Akira Yamaoka unlegitimaly just to increase their stats (and profit/money):
https://open.spotify.com/album/3AzkrhSnlBq1gtMoxCt7nZ
He has other collaborations but from what I could find they are legit, only the ones I posted above are using the name of Akira Yamaoka artist to their favor.
There are more instances I found on other artists. For example, this artist is an extreme case, he is constantly releasing music using the name of bigger artists, since he has released a lot of tracks I will just put his artist page:
He already has 60k montly listeners, but that's because he is using the artist names of Akira Yamaoka, Capcom Sound Team, Kikiyama, Yabujin, Falcom Sound Team, Yoko Shimomura, and more!
Something similar is doing this artist:
I can only imagine how many fake artists are out there doing this...
Wanted to chime in to the choir with my own anecdote. All these posts are right on the money. Years and no fix is unbelievable, but I guess if you view it from Spotify's perspective these scams drive engagement to the platform so maybe that's why they are so against doing anything about it. Shows what they're really here for (spoiler to no one: money!)
I've been following this small artist for years, and have seen her grow from a miniscule unknown singer to being mildly popular. She clearly works very hard and even though I don't know her it has been a joy to witness. To see a scam artist "collaborate" with her and to secure her #1 popular spot on her profile (!!!) is heartbreaking. I won't put her name here because I don't want to give this scammer any more attention (clicks are clicks after all).
And yeah, Spotify's reporting really is lacklustre and unfit for purpose, and their support are clearly very helpless in these situations. "Music for everyone" includes scammers and con artists too I guess.
Came to comment here because this is still happening. Three years after this post and nothing has changed. Spotify don't care because it somehow makes them money. The real artists don't care because they've already got money. The fake artists are the only ones left caring and they're the ones that want to keep it this way. F*** the listeners, I guess.
This is happening to me too. Friends are messaging me excited that I'm releasing music, but I've never heard of these randos tagging me as a collaborator.