[All Platforms] Option to have a true shuffle

So I’ve been noticing more and more recently that Spotify’s default shuffle feature doesn’t fully shuffle your songs. It does some sort of grouping to try to get similar songs together based off of what I’m sure is dozens of factors. Every time I shuffle a playlist (the one I noticed this with the most is ~100 songs and 6 hours of mostly full albums) it will group the songs mostly or completely together by album/artist, and given the number of times I’ve re-shuffled and checked the order there’s no way it’s just a coincidence. They also generally seem to be in the same order as well. If I hit shuffle play on a playlist it’ll generally put the same artists at the beginning every time.

 

With larger playlists of albums I am really not a fan of this shuffling method. If I have 6 hours of music on a playlist I will hardly ever have 6 hours to actually listen through the whole thing, but when I do listen to it I would like to hear all of the music on it equally, and not just the artist or two your algorithm likes to shuffle to first.

 

Anyways, I’m a reasonable man, all I’m asking for is an option to have a true shuffle (take all songs in the list, put them in a random order, and once they’re all played reshuffle them and play them again). Make it premium only if you want. I don’t think you should scrap the current shuffle algorithm because it sucks. Looking at some of the suggestions on here it seems like some people lobbied hard to have it that way. Just add an option for a true shuffle for those of us that don’t care about potentially getting the same song twice in a row.

Child Item
Status: Implemented
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Oh well, I wish you luck with this, but there's a over 4 year old "live" idea very similar to this one. Over 4 thousand votes, over 150 pages of comments and no action from Spotify:

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/All-Platforms-Option-to-have-a-true-shuffle/idi-p/4880594

 

Spotify very clearly places profits and greed over customer service.

Personally, I've given up on Spotify ever fixing this - they haven't in years - and I no longer use them. 

I can't believe this is actually still a problem:
https://community.spotify.com/t5/Implemented-Ideas/Implement-an-actual-shuffle-function/idi-p/27607
Yesterday, I had a 5-hour car trip, and out of my 1793-song playlist, I heard the same songs twice.

I felt like it was shuffling only 30-odd songs on my playlist.
It's hard to understand how you can shuffle a thousand songs and still listen to the same song before all the rest of the 999 songs have played. How hard is it to do that?

Is Spotify getting paid by big record labels to play their songs???

This is my biggest complaint with Spotify. I don't like to binge music, I like variety. When I use shuffle I want to hear my liked songs that I haven't heard in months, not the same one I heard yesterday and the day before. Can't believe this has been open for so long!  Wouldn't be difficult to implement, and can still keep the current algorithms as a shuffle option for those who prefer it.

How is this still a problem.

"So close"

 

What are you waiting for? They ignored premium subscribers for at least 4 years now. Your comment is not going to sway them.

He didn't say "please"? Oh dear that's it he's ruined it for everyone now.

Pretty please with sugar on top? 

So here's the most recent update from Greedify, with my translation below: 

 

Updated on 2024-05-01

Hello everyone, 

 

Thank you for your continued engagement and valuable feedback on this idea. 

 

I'm afraid there hasn't been any change on the status of this idea since our last update. However, we've been reading all your comments and feedback which have been incredibly insightful. 

 

We’ll keep you folks posted as soon as we have any new info to share.

===============================

 

Here's my translation on what they're really saying:

 

Hello everyone, 

 

Wow, another year has gone by and you idiots keep coming here pretending we care about your threats of leaving. We're not going to fix this problem. If you can't see that, then by all means, keep buying us new beach houses, cars, and boats. Clearly you have plenty of money to burn on a product that doesn't do what you want, so we'll gladly take it.

We will update you again in a few years that nothing has changed. Enjoy, suckers. 

===================================

 

Doesn't that sound more accurate? 

 

It's actually pretty funny thinking about a group of their employees in a board room reading these comments and cracking up over a nice catered lunch. It probably boosts office moral. If I didn't despise companies like this so much, I'd move on. But because they suck donkey nuts, I'm going to copy and paste the following here as much as I can (I'd like to say daily, but I'm a realist).

 

"Dear new or old Spotify user who wants a true shuffle: Spotify will not fix this because it's not broken. It's a deliberate business decision by them to increase their revenue. By all means, stay with them if you don't care about throwing your money away. But if you like supporting companies who actual respect their customer-base, and if you want a streaming service that actually works, move on. Most platforms offer free trials; find one that you like. Here is the list I tried when leaving Spotify (all of them were a step up):

  • Apple Music (I can't stand Apple as a company, much like Spotify, but if it works it works. I moved on because they treat their customers like a child and filter "naughty words" of song titles)
  • Amazon Music
  • Tidal (offers military veteran discount)
  • YouTube Music (this is the one I ended up staying with). 

There are plenty of apps out there that will automatically move all your playlists from Spotify to whatever service you choose. The one I used charges a one-time fee, but you can use it as much as you want after that. I think it was only like $17. I used the app "FreeYourMusic". 

 

The only way to get **bleep** companies like Spotify to listen is to take your money elsewhere. The great part about that is then you'll have an actual shuffle, and will only come here to try to help other lost listeners. 

"Greedify" sounds perfect 😂

 

At this stage I think most of the "regulars" here are only still following this thread because, frankly, it's funny. We long since stopped paying for this rotten excuse for a service. Other than us who are merely here for sh1ts and giggles, the only new comments here are from "newbies" who seem to think that they're the first to ask for this to be fixed.

SPOTIFY STOP REPEATING THE SAME SONGS YOU **bleep**! THE SONG IS NOT EVEN OVER I CAN ALREADY SEE ITS ON QUEUE AGAIN!!!!!!!!! THE FU-!?!?????

Can we please get a true shuffle?? Make toggling it off an option kind of like the "Smart Shuffle" option. 

Tip: before you add a comment here consider that this thread is 4 years old and 153 pages long. Why do you think that is?

Please, I agree that this feature should be added! I am really thinking about cancelling my membership for this exact reason. I do not want to hear the same song several times a day, I have thousands of songs in my playlist and I never get to hear most of them unless I search for it manually. I will notice every now and then, I will hear a song I haven’t heard in a very long time. It is so inconsistent, and doesn’t give a chance for smaller artists to get as many streams. This is really a dealbreaker for me! 

What would it take for you to stop "thinking" and start reaching inevitable conclusions?

Wow, rozeboosje. I DID notice the thread was four years old....I ALSO NOTICED that it was updated in May of this year. I was simply trying to bring more attention to the issue. Which is why everybody else commented, correct? So, what exactly did I do wrong here to warrant such a snide remark? You're right, I am a newbie to Spotify Community. However, I've been using the app for seven years. If you've moved on from Spotify, why continue to troll the comments on this post? Imagine not having anything better to do in life than argue with strangers on the internet over something you supposedly don't care about anymore. 

Oh I DO care. I want Spotify to crash and burn. My comment wasn't directed at you, per se.

Perhaps people might think it's "histrionic" to express the wish for Spotify to "die" as a business but it makes perfect sense.

 

Spotify was the first legal streaming service on the market and they still dominate it. But as is often the case, the original innovator becomes the later obstacle in the way of progress for end users. Imagine if IBM were still the only choice for personal computers. It doesn't bear thinking about.

 

I'm not entirely sure what larger problem this ridiculous failure to address such a trivial technological problem is indicative of, but I can only assume that Spotify somehow managed to contractually or legally paint itself into a corner, and I don't think Spotify can fix this.

 

So Spotify needs to die, so that other providers who aren't encumbered by such contractual or legal handcuffs can take over and give listeners the experience they deserve.

 

As long as Spotify keeps hanging on to its enormous and undeserved market share it disincentivises other providers to invest into real technological improvements.

 

Yes, the sooner Spotify goes bankrupt, the better.

 

Not quite

 

Toujours le même problème. C’est un réel foutage de gueule.

 

Maybe.

 

Do you like music?

 

I'm REALLY sick of hearing the same songs over and over in shuffle mode. Please fix it so it plays EVERY song in the playlist before replaying. No algorithm, please.

 

I don't care much for what happens to smart shuffle just fix the normal shuffle, I'm heavily considering switching streaming services over this and I'm sure many others are.

 

Please hurry we are suffering

I never get songs from the beginning of my playlist when I shuffle it. It only gives me songs from the last few thousand. It’d be cool if in the little menu where the organize by album and by duration there was another one that would shuffle the songs completely randomly. Then when you don’t want then shuffled anymore you just turn the option off.

What do you think is going to happen to a request to "please hurry" in a four year old thread with 154 pages of complaints?

Me reading increasingly angry and frustrated comments from people who expect functionality children can write to be included in the primary product of a $60bln company:

Frustrated person reading comments GIF

 

As it has been said many times before on this thread: If Spotify hasn't fixed it in over 4 years, they won't fix it no matter how many people beg them to do it. What they call shuffle must be heavily rigged to get them as much money as possible, otherwise they would have fixed it by now. It is not a difficult thing to grab a list of music and mix it up.

 

If shuffle is important to you, there are other providers that do it properly.

The only way for Spotify to fix this, is if they start losing money instead of making it, and that will never happen because people are loyal to a company that doesn't care about its customers. All Spotify care about is making money.

Greedify as someone called them.

 

I didn't think about leaving. I left. Happily hearing long playlists on shuffle and without repeats.

shotdeadfred welcome to our forum where dreams come to die. If you want a true random shuffle you can either use a third party program that will reorder your playlist for you or give your hard earned money to a company that gives a s**t about its customers which is what most of us did. You will own a house on Pluto before Spotify implements a true shuffle

There's a very easy way to get what you are looking for, it's called Amazon
Music

Well, I've been following this for a few years now. So, I guess the best thing is to start talking more about the competitors. I'm specifically looking for a music streaming service where I can choose a bunch of artists and it randomly play songs from this artist list. Is anyone familiar with a service that does that? It's similar to what everyone is talking about (a true shuffle) but instead of creating a song list, I want to create an artists list and have it play random songs from all those artists.

Child Item
Child Item