Bring back the heart button!

It's SUPER frustrating, we can't see which songs we liked in our own playlists, Bring back the heart button PLEASE, the new way doesn't work AT ALL

Child Item
Status: Live Idea
Child Item
Child Item
Child Item

Comments

Captura de pantalla 2024-07-27 a las 21.02.00.png

 

Yes, correct, we have an idea.

 

Captura de pantalla 2024-07-27 a las 21.01.37.png

 

 

Yes, that's right, we have an idea. And it seems that there are many of us with the same idea. And is there any point in expressing our opinion here? Not at all.

 

------

 

Spotify. That music streaming program where you can't see at a glance, and everywhere, the songs you've marked as favorites. What an absolute disaster.

I really fine the absence of a designated “like button” quite inconvenient. Especially when listening to the playlists I compiled, in that case in order to like the song I already have in some other playlist or move it to liked songs from there I need to go through many taps. 

I also really miss the liked heart. It was a fantastic feature to indicate which songs youve liked as apposed to just added to a playlist. Ive really tried to get along with the new tick but it really isnt very helpful/useful at all to me. I'm sure others do like it tho.  I don't know if this has been suggested already but. Maybe we could have both. The green circle with a tick for those songs in playlists. A green heart for liked songs and a green heart with a tick if in both. 🤷‍♂️ 

Might not work but its just a suggestion.

 

But please bring back some sort of liked indicator. Preferably the green heart 💚

where our heart beat!!!!! 

 

Bring back our heart beat!!!

BOOM BOOM BOOM

1.gif

One year has passed. This "community" is useless, like screaming to the void. It would be better if it didn't exist, it just creates false hope that the developers might listen/answer. They're taking everyone for fools.

Thank God I never had any serious issue with Spotify, I bet it would be a nightmare to expect some kind of support from these money grabbers.

Spotify is becoming useless for how I track my music.  Time to look at Amazon or Apple. Ridiculous to take away the heart for liked songs.  Already we know you don't pay the artist.

The main goal for me when using Spotify, is to find new music. New songs that I do not already have on my "Liked Songs". When I find one, I'll add it to my Liked Songs.

 

Now, when I have saved several public playlists, or albums I've saved so I can go through them, the green checkmark either shows or does not show based on something. Not simply whether I have it saved on Liked Songs. I may have the song on my Liked Songs or not, I cannot know any more just by looking at the list of songs. Before I could see it immediately by looking at the heart icon.

 

It used to be so much fun to to see a heart symbol and know immediately this one is part of the most valuable collection, my Liked Songs. Now as the heart symbol is replaced by multi-functional green checkmark, looking for new music is not so fun any longer.

Can someone please answer my question?

 

I think everyone have used the heart button differently. Personally, I clicked the heart whenever I liked a song or wanted to save it for later, like a bookmarking tool. For me, the heart button wasn’t just for marking 'banger' songs; it was more of an 'add to library' button. I’d revisit my liked songs list when I had time, un-heart some, and add my favorites to a separate playlist.

 

Am I the only one who used the heart button this way? Did others really use it very selectively, and save other mediocre songs by going through the extra steps of adding them to a playlist? For me, adding all the songs I liked(whether it's a banger or not) first and then sorting them later was more efficient. Being very selective and only heart-ing 'bangers' while adding other mediocre songs to a playlist (which takes several steps) felt like a hassle. Just was curious since I’m investigating this heart button for my personal case study now..

I used it as a sort of ‘add to library’, my frustration now is I would like to look through a playlist and see that everything is in my library (liked songs).

 

I used to be able to do this very easily but now the only way to know is by searching each individually which is a nightmare. 

do the users get any credit or payment from these ideas if they are implemented?

The like button was completely functional before. Why should i continue paying for a service that repeatedly makes its own platform WORSE.

Update:

 

In the meantime ive already finished the Spotify Abo ! 

And iam very happy about that.

Have switched to DEEZER !

Much much better Sound Quality ! , and

at least there is one Heart Button.

 

Good Bye Spotify (:

I understand that these changes may have been implemented with the intention of simplifying the platform or introducing new functionalities. However, I believe that maintaining both icons (heart and green tick) would provide better transparency in managing our saved songs and playlists. This functionality was not only convenient but also essential for many users who manage their music libraries carefully.

Given the negative impact these changes have had on my experience, I have started exploring alternatives on other music streaming platforms that offer similar features. For example:

  • Apple Music: This platform maintains a clear system for managing saved songs with heart icons that allow users to quickly identify their favorite songs. Additionally, integration with Apple devices and the iCloud library provides a cohesive user experience.

  • Tidal: Offers high sound quality and a user interface that allows efficient management of playlists and saved songs, with clear "Like" options and visual markers.

  • Amazon Music: Provides a simple user experience with intuitive icons for adding songs to playlists or personal libraries, allowing for easy identification of favorite songs.

  • YouTube Music: Although it works differently, it allows users to mark songs and playlists as "liked" and offers recommendations based on these interactions.

I appreciate the hard work the Spotify team puts into continuously improving the platform. However, I suggest that user feedback on these recent changes be considered, and that the possibility of re-implementing an interface that includes both the heart and green tick icons be explored for a better user experience.

It's really frustrating to have a music service where you can't see the songs you've marked as favorites everywhere, lists, albums, etc... The removal of the heart to mark and, at the same time, see my favorite songs at a glance, has significantly impoverished my user experience on Spotify.
Many of us would like to see the heart come back, or any other symbol that identifies that the user has marked a song as a favorite. A simple click, and a permanent symbol. It's not difficult Spotify.

[TO THE MODERATOR ONLY]

 

I had posted a Live Idea that was incorrectly merged with this live idea today by a moderator named Novy. The above idea is a great idea that I fully support, but it's the exact opposite of my idea. The above idea relates to easily seeing which songs in a playlist (for example) have not been liked yet. My idea was to easily see which of your Liked Songs have not yet been added to a playlist. My idea was posted at the link below and I'm requesting that these separate ideas be unmerged.  Thank you!

 

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/Filter-liked-songs-by-quot-Not-in-any-playlist-quot/idi-p/6296000

 

Can Spotify explain why they removed it and why they are not returning to it? There must be a reason....

Listen. People use Spotify in their cars while driving. The less clicks you have to do, the better. So why did we change a one-click solution of liking songs to now require multiple clicks and having to focus in on the phone to see which playlist you’re adding it to? 

Change for the sake of change is stupid. They need to hire a Common Sense Consultant.  

Might as well hide the pause and skip button behind a “tap for more” menu while we’re at it. 🙄

i left spotify because of this stupid change a year ago. got back on spotify yesterday cause no other platform had this large music collection or recommendation algorithm, unfortunately they didn't revert this even after all the votes**bleep** got. Now all i can do is beg and plead. please bring the **bleep**ing heart button back. i add songs to playlist all the time but it was hearted songs on playlist that let me know it's the absolute favorites for a specific theme of songs on the playlist

Right now I´m using Spotify web and I must add that the this actually works now is totally ridiculous 😀 Working in IT industry I can say that it´s UI design gone quite wrong with this thing. Even though I´m sure Spotify has hundreds or thousands of UI designers. 

 

How can it be that you have "add to liked songs "  in the UI but after pressing it doesn´t anyway indicate have you pressed it? It´s like having machine with on/off button and you actually can not know is it on or not. 

It´s against all logic and UI design principles. Or is there some market logic behind this that we just can´t understand. 

 

I also think the Spotify recommendations for me are not as good as they should be. I have given you quite lot of information which songs:

a. Are good enough I have added to my own playlists.  Not some AI motor generated playlist. These are also albums and artists I would check later are they good for categories b or c. 

b. Are good enough that I have marked them as liked  (these songs are much better than average) 

c. Are so good that I have downloaded them (just so I can at see which are the best songs)

 

So with all this information I have given you I don´t think the playlist recommendations are that good. I would be interested to know is the recommendation functionality even able to take into account which songs I have liked ? Or is it purely recommending the songs from category a - the songs that are on my playlist? 

 

Anyway if the recommendation functionality has technical difficulties taking into account all the songs each user has liked maybe this is the reason Spotify is trying to downgrade/hide this functionality ?? There must be some reason because it´s bad UI design how it now works. 

 

The previous commentor begged Spotify to fix this. As a user at this point I would insist you to do at least something. Hello Spotify ?  Even answer something to these comments. That´s how other software communities work. Customers ask somehing and the company responds. Also as stock owner I would insist Spotify to do something to this illogical UI. 

 

 

This was amazing while in a playlist to see which song you already know and like. Now you can't see it anymore, its been months, its such a pain to navigate playlists now. I want to be able to easily queue up my best tunes ffs !

Please bring it back! For a while, I figured the "Plus" button had a similar feature, but it no longer makes sense. I have noticed in the past few weeks the "Plus" button means it's saved to a playlist. It's not the same thing! Also, wayyy back in 2015/2017, there was a curated playlist from the recently liked songs. Can we bring that back as well? K, thanks!

As already said, i ve already finished my Abo...

For me Spitify is no longer  a Pro Level Streaming

Service...reason is the amateurlike Features

(no Heart Button, no Comments possible) and the

very bad compressed and over equed Sound Quality.

This Service is only for amateurs and everybody with

a certain Musical Standard should leave this Platform.

 

 

I wanted to give this a try on the TV app so I tried adding a song to a playlist using the + (Plus) feature. It just doesn't work. Just please return the heart button; it's super intuitive while the plus feature doesn't help at all.

Hello, it drives me crazy that I can no longer immediately see if a song is in my Liked Songs list. Instead, it could be in ANY playlist (that I might delete later etc.)
PLEASE show in ANY place (ANY playlist song listing, ANY other place where a song is shown) if that song's in the like list already or not. Again, it drives me crazy.

Plan

Premium

Country

USA

 

Device

S23 Ultra

Operating System

Android Latest

 

My Question or Issue

The check mark is super confusing and inefficient. Before I used to see a heart that showed a song was in my liked songs. Now I see a check and I have to click to confirm it's in my liked songs. I use Shazam and it auto adds to the Shazam playlist, but that doesn't mean I just want it there. It's stupid and just causes extra clicks, why not just leave the heart and add the checkmark for playlists only. My liked song is not a playlist.

Almost an year has passed which is pathetic. I was still waiting but after so long I doubt they are bringing the heart button back. I was postponing moving to another platform because it will take some work moving all my music and I was still hoping they would bring the heart button pack or at least give us users some feedback.

Anyway, giving money to this company makes me feel like a fool, they don't pay artists enough so I would expect all of the money would go into hiring people that actually know what the ***** they are doing and have basic understanding of UX design. I've never seen such a stupid decision from any other company.

It really sucks that you guys at Spotify don't seem to care that We can like the album but We have to listen to all the songs and like them as well which is ridiculous. Please, at the very least,  bring back the like all songs button. That would help. If you're even listening or care.

This is really sad and very simple in the same time. I just cancelled my subscription.

Child Item
Child Item