It's SUPER frustrating, we can't see which songs we liked in our own playlists, Bring back the heart button PLEASE, the new way doesn't work AT ALL
Thanks to that wrapped, I got to know I’m in the top 2% of Spotify users.
Spotify, so that you know, removing that heart button was the least expected thing. I can’t recall any other change from any vendor in the past decade that would be that little justified and bringing so much discomfort in a single simple move.
Another frustration comes from how you interact with the community.
I recently tried to explain this to a newbie from an older gen, advocating for Spotify features. They decided that's too heavy an algorithm to remember, which is fair IMO, and continued with Apple Music.
Don´t the people at Spotify understand that seeing the hearts/you favourites is a soothing sight for someone with plenty of music in their own playlists? For example here I can directly see here that this is a good album with plenty of my favourite tracks.
Also it´s very easy to go through a playlist of thousand songs and see which albums you have already listened and which songs you have liked. There has to be some tools and ways to organize and manage your own playlists of lot of songs.
Not eveyone wants to listen only to those Spotify recommendations which are not even that good. Some want to seek their own favourites and there should be good ways to do that.
I switched to Tidal already months ago and I´ve been satisfied for many reasons (price, quality, useability). The overall playlist functionality is not as good as it was with older version of Spotify but it´s much better than in the newest Spotify versions.
Please consider returning the heart (i.e., Liked, Favorite) feature to the playlists.
You replaced it with an expressive animation of the Artist CD cover, currently at the top of each playlist. This already exists with a non-expressive animation of the Artist CD cover for each song in a playlist.
I constantly add new songs to my playlists. However, there's an existing significant amount of songs in my playlists that that I haven't listened to yet. I always do so at my leisure. The songs I've listened were separated from these with hearts (I e , Likes, Favorites)
Your updated feature groups all songs in a playlist in the same category. It was excellent prior to your update. A reversal would be extraordinary!
Thanks in advance.
I’ve been using Spotify for years and taking away the heart as a like option was genuinely the worst update to come to this app. Not only making it harder to organize my playlists but you took away the love doing it?? Not a fan, this is making me want to switch to Apple Music
If you're playing a song you haven't liked on a playlist you made, the circle will have a checkmark, which makes it difficult to know which songs are in your list, especially if it's a large playlist. The only time it doesn't is if you're playing desktop spotify on fullscreen.
Its ridiculous the amount of likes this has and they still dont care.
I have been meaning to turn off email notifications from this thread for a while and finally got round to it.
As a parting message, I too have switched to TIDAL and am happy to be in a world where I can once again love my music.
Echoing the comments made already, the sound quality is noticeably better, they pay the artists a LOT more, it still works out slightly cheaper and it has hearts. It does have some cons (being unable to reorganise playlists within folders one of them) but all pale into insignificance when you have the trusty old heart to help organise your music in a logical way.
Anyway, I won't be transferring my playlists again without good reason, so that is me done with Spotify unless TIDAL are stupid enough to remove the heart feature, but surely no business could be that stupid... I strongly recommend you all look around and find a streaming service that actually cares about its customers.
i too am jumping ship, spotify has become complacent. it was always bad, but its rapidly becoming unusable.
It's been over a full year since it was accepted as a "Good Idea", I wonder if Spotify has any updates or if they should've closed it and said "nope" years ago.
I've been meaning to stop notifications on this post because the like button came back to me I think last summer. Maybe earlier so I'm surprised that others don't have it still but I also people are posting about other things on here as well.
KilJhard, can you post here the details of your Spotify client app? Like below. Spotify for macOS (Apple Silicon)1.2.55.235.g5eaa0904
Spotify prefers you to listen to what they push rather than what you actually want. That’s why they removed the “Like” button—it gets in their way. They’re making it harder and harder to create and organize your own playlists. They just want you to listen to what they dictate. Otherwise, there’s no explanation for why the “Like” button still hasn’t returned.
I can imagine Spotify's response to this request:
Hey there! We’re always looking for ways to improve the listening experience and help users discover amazing new music. We understand that changes can take some getting used to, but our goal is to create a platform where discovery and personalization go hand in hand. We truly appreciate your feedback and will make sure to pass it along to our team. Keep the music going! 🎶✨
Actually raspael, I don't agree that they made it harder to create and organize your own playlists. Quite the opposite, playlist handling has greatly improved. But it is far from perfect and certainly not good enough for a so-called or self-proclaimed industry leader.
And with they way these improvements are implemented, I don't see the added value of a separate Liked Songs list anymore. So I prefer to keep this improved playlist handling AND have a separate visual indication for liked songs.
As raspael said, removing the like button, a feature every other competitor seems to be able to comprehend the utility of, makes it harder to create and organize our own playlists by definition. This is true regardless of whatever other features are or are not added or removed. Now... what could possibly be the reason to enshitten your own service like this? Perhaps their end goal is to have us listen to what they dictate rather than what we, LITERALLY, like.
I'm subscribed to this thread because I'm curious if Spotify is capable of actual improvement, but I've long since moved on to Deezer. I didn't know what I was missing with Deezer Hifi; even my non-audiophile ears can detect the increase in quality. Even if they did see the light one day and decided to catch up to their competition feature-wise, no use going back now.
Spotify, it's time to put this back. It is a serious flaw that is a great obstacle when organising your music.
I think the major problem is that they changed the button to more of a playlist button instead of a heart/like button so it makes it so much harder to tell if it's in your liked songs or not. I'm constantly confused if a song is in my liked songs because it might have a check mark (where the heart/like button would be) and that doesn't mean it's in your liked it just means it's on a playlist you might have. I've found that when I add random playlist or my linked Shazam and other similar apps the songs will show up with a check mark but it's only because they're added to a playlist of mine and not a liked song. UGH. It's annoying.
This a screenshot of me trying to figure out if this song is in my liked playlist from my desktop. No idea by looking at the song. I can see it has a check mark where the heart/like button would be. I have to click on it to see that the check mark is noting that it's in a random playlist and not my liked. You can see I have to find my liked playlist in my library to be able to see this, so obnoxious.
If that isn't frustrating enough. Instead of just clicking what would have been the heart/like button to unlike a song now we have to click remove from liked playlist. On my desktop PC app if you don't right click on the button it not only makes you do this but you have to confirm after you unselect to remove from liked playlist.
What do you mean with "You can see I have to find my liked playlist in my library to be able to see this"? If you click the checkmark you can immediately see (In the "Add to playlist" popup) whether the track is in the Liked Songs list or not (because it will appear on top of the list). Same behavior in the mobile app. Just trying to be helpful, because I do agree with anyone (expect Spotify) that playlist handling and liking songs are 2 separate things so these deserve/require separate controls or indications. Separation of concerns! Who can convince Spotify that their UX sucks?
With the exceptions of removing the Like (heart) symbol, and not displaying album release dates in playlists, I think the desktop app has come a long way, in a good way. (I only listen to music on mobile, and do all my playlist creation/changes on desktop.)
I don't ever use Spotify offline, so I'm now using the Download Symbol as a Like Symbol substitute. With download quality set to Low, and the ability to clear all downloads in settings, it works out well enough (for me) for temporarily marking tracks, for various reasons, to assist with playlist building.
Removing the heart button is the stupidest and most dysfunctional thing Spotify has ever done. It's crazy that it's not possible to see which songs I've liked in a playlist or album. Fix this now!
2025/02/09.
I insist. This section is a big lie. Useless. According to its own rules, Spotify should have closed the case or implemented the idea. A vague response from 2023 is the only thing that is available. Don't waste your time here, it's worthless.
I am not sure if they entirely cut the team that actively monitors and reacts to these suggestions, if they just laugh at how much we struggle and achieve nothing or if they have been told to ignore us because we don't want the heart and are just too stupid to realize it.
Maybe it's the same people that pushed the sonos app? Or at least they seem to be related on a mental level.
I used to use spotify all the time and this change and the lack of response from the team infuriated me so much that after a couple of weeks I moved to another platform and I've been happy ever since. Don't use services that purposefully disrespect their own clients!
While the newer plus/checkmark system streamlines playlist management/organization (adding and removing songs from playlists), I miss the heart/like symbol being displayed next to my favorite tracks. Although songs can still be viewed in the "Liked Songs" playlist, it was incredibly useful to see hearts within my playlists, instantly distinguishing my top favorites from the rest.
When discovering new music, listeners often add multiple songs to their playlists but naturally gravitate toward certain tracks more than others. For example, when a new album drops, they may enjoy several songs but connect more deeply with specific ones. The heart symbol helped highlight those standouts, making it easy to see which songs resonated the most.
Beyond new discoveries, listeners always have familiar tracks in heavy rotation. While they may add new songs to their playlists, those tracks might not get as much playtime immediately. Over time, it’s easy to forget which of the newer songs stood out the most. The heart symbol provided a simple, effective way to keep track—without needing to re-listen to each new track, check the "Liked Songs" playlist, or click the plus/checkmark to see if a song was liked.
Bringing back the heart icon alongside the new system would offer the best of both worlds: seamless playlist management and an immediate, clear visual cue for personal favorites. And even if it wasn't specifically the heart/like symbol being brought back, possibly creating a new way of instantly distinguishing liked tracks from not-liked tracks within playlists--instead of having to take those extra steps.
The new system really works well from a functionality standpoint, but I feel like bringing this feature back--in addition to the newer system--could really improve users' experiences.
Dumping the ability to mark tracks with a heart (or whatever, it could be any friendly symbol, I don't care) was the dumbest thing Spotify has done yet. And it's a shame because the user interface has gone through some really nice improvements overall, in my opinion. I don't like being forced to use the download symbol as a heart-substitute ... it's quite clumsy.
The new sizeable columns and ability to choose which columns to display has me hopeful we'll finally start seeing some new column choices like album-release-date, key, tempo, etc.
It’s extremely frustrating not knowing what songs are in my liked songs at first glance.