Updated Spotify desktop client yesterday (about says v0.9.8.258) and the 'Library' option has dissappeared and been replaced by a rather useless and blank looking Your Music > Songs / Albums / Artists. Also I cannot star anything, a plus seems to have replaced the star. The Library was my goto screen on spotify as it contained all my local files and playlists....Spotify has rendered itself rather useless for me in 1 update, unless I go and manually create a library playlist which I would then have to manually update each time I added new music.
Please advise how to get the library back or a suitable workaround which provides the same functionality. Also, why the **** were users not notified of this big change?
I want my library back !!! - I had tons of songs on there not in a playlist - why were they not simply tramsferred tp tje new "songs" tab with the new version ??? Very inconsiderate and presumptuous thinking by Spotify - two thumbs down !
@wewantsthering Check out this bug topic which explains about what goes wrong when you drop too many tracks into My Music at once and how to work around it.
@kingkwong wrote:I feel like I've just had a service that I pay for snatched and stolen away from me. I stored a ton of songs in the general "Library" tab. Songs that weren't necessarily worthy of being starred but still worth keeping and because they weren't stored in an actual playlist, they are just gone now, into oblivion??! As a paying customer this really makes me upset that I wasn't warn about this. The software update was done without my authorization or I would have stayed on the previous version. So much time I've put into collecting/importing these songs into my library are just gone...
I didn't now you could previously store tracks straight to library. If that's right and you've now lost it all then that's by far the worst aspect of the change. I would be devastated if that happened to me.
Mdewater, is it correct that you could previously add tracks straight to library? If I'd done that and lost it all for good, the bottom would have dropped out of my world.
I'd also like to say thanks for spending time trying to field questions on this without any pay or gratitude.
Also, understand that I'm on here because 1) I've believed that streaming is the future of music listening for well over 30 years and 2) I want Spotify to succeed as I've made a huge investment of time and energy into it over the last 4 years and I still believe it's the best service of its type.
And one more thing - Spotify staff should read all the comments on this forum very, very carefully. The reason is that we might be a tiny minority of users but we care. That silent majority that Spotify seem to think are so important will be made up mostly of lukewarm users that will happily jump ship as soon as the next shiny new product comes along: and we all know what that is. So if I were Spotify I'd seriously consider treating my customers with respect.
@mdewater wrote:The majority of users in the beta test were big, hardcore, power users. Not many casual users, as many in this thread here are.
Interesting. Someone representing Spotify in these forums has said that the features in the new update have to meet the needs of the majority of users, not a minority of users. Are the majority of Spotiy's users 'big, hardcore, power users' then? I doubt it. They should have had a representative spread of users in the beta test. There is a massive number of people who are not power users but are also not casual users.
I'm not 100% sure, but I don't think it was possible to save music directly to the library. Library, if I remember correctly, pulled from three places - playlists, starred tracks, and local files. So nothing that was previously saved should be *gone*.
Regarding the beta testing, I guess the reason why most of the testers were power users is simply because those are the users that are most interested in the Your Music feature. I know I've been waiting eagerly to try it out since they first announced it in December 2012. So when they posted here that they were looking for testers, I jumped on it. Most other testers were probably of the same mindset. People who didn't care about a collection feature just didn't sign up to test it.
Unfortunately it seems that wasn't the best way to go about it. The testing should have included more casual listeners, for whom features like library and stars worked well.
Would it possible for you to be any more condescending mdewater... Good lord...
@LaRube wrote:Would it possible for you to be any more condescending mdewater... Good lord...
Don't think they were being condescending, just trying to help people understand the mindset that has led to the current state of the software. While I can't speak for anyone else, I can say that for myself it's been really interesting to see the negative reactions to Your Music in general and what's going on with the starred playlist. The beta testing was fairly limited and we clearly didn't have a wide enough range of users within that group. Now, the beta test has been expanded and the new Spotify has been rolled out to a large number of users, so it's helping the developers figure out what people really want. The way I see it, this really does come down to communication issues more than anything. As others have mentioned before, release notes, a tutorial, anything could've probably lessened the shock this release has had. But, it's too late now, and there are a lot of people doing the best they can to make things better.
@LaRube wrote:Would it possible for you to be any more condescending mdewater... Good lord...
I don't know 'mdewater' but he appears to have good intentions.
That said, he also appears to be part of the Spotify inner circle with more knowledge the beta test was run, how many people participated, how many of them were power users, etc. than the rest of us.
The language used by the Spotify insiders can be arrogant and condescending at times. For the most part, they never apologize for making bad decisions. They blame poor customer experience and other bad outcomes on "lack of data" and other externalities. Sadly, this sort of behavior is the hallmark of a low morale and/or low competence team.
mdewater:
I own over 20,000 tracks and had added thousands more from Spotify.... I have had just under 20,000 when i joined Spotify... I listen to music almost constantly wherever I am... I am not a casual user... I have always enjoyed hearing the new music offered by Spotify and I loved the mix I got when I shuffled through that mix... That mix was created with no effort on my part except normal use of Spotify. Pointed to my local files, added playlists and used the Discovery feature often... Now I am told that because the beta teters were all of a like mind (who picks beta testers that think alike? Good god!), I have to spend weeks recreatibg that over 2 year history that was available as a mix... As you say my moods changes so I skip some of the tracks depending on my mood... but I love the way it works... I get the idea that SONGS can be the same thing, and if it actually were the same thing I would never have posted here... I do not care what label is on the function as long as it functions... There are many ways that SONGS does not function like the old LIBRARY function... If you had read the posts here you would have known how the discussion had developed before you responded... There is also a bug in SONGS that does not allow me to recreate the same mix... I started adding all my playists into songs and it stopped allowing me to add anymore songs... I have probably added about 1/3 to 1/4 of my playlists and cannot add anymore... How is that even remotely the same functionality? Beyond me... Course there are always bitches and moans about changes... I work in Stratetic Management and understad the process of change as well as anyone... But I spent over two years developing the way Spotify works for me and now it is gone... So I move on... If as you say we are a rare few, a tiny minority than Spotify should move on... There was a business reason for this change I am sure (probably to do with rolyalty payments...) and if that purpose is served as well as the overwhelming majority of users that is a business decision I understand... I just wanted to see if stating my views made a difference... Business is business... I get it... The few are sacrificed for the many... I do not quit understand why both cannot be served in this case... Of course there is the business decisions behind these sorts of things... And thanks Spotify for letting me post my view... That is a great thing! 🙂
Not only that can you imagine having to skip over half your tracks when you listen on shuffle? Get rid of the junk so you do have to skip... But as one says... Different strokes for different folks...
@AbsolutelyNoFB wrote:
@LaRube wrote:Would it possible for you to be any more condescending mdewater... Good lord...
I don't know 'mdewater' but he appears to have good intentions.
That said, he also appears to be part of the Spotify inner circle with more knowledge the beta test was run, how many people participated, how many of them were power users, etc. than the rest of us.
The language used by the Spotify insiders can be arrogant and condescending at times. For the most part, they never apologize for making bad decisions. They blame poor customer experience and other bad outcomes on "lack of data" and other externalities. Sadly, this sort of behavior is the hallmark of a low moral and/or low competence team.
Mdewater is not a member of the "Spotify inner circle," but simply a beta tester. It was freely available months ago for anyone to sign up for. I'm a part of it as well. That's the only reason we have the information we have. For the record, we do not work for Spotify, but are simply members of the community like you, just trying to help.
mdewater:
Have you done a survey of "power" users? I imagine I have as much or more music than you do, and listen to music almost nonstop... but cannot imagine listening to it in the way you describe. I enjoy the shuffling... I may hear something during the shuffle that makes me want to play that artist or album and then do that... but I feel that without the shuffle I tend to forget all the tracks available to me... It can be a rela revelation when shuffle pulls up a cut you had forgotten about... Oh yeah... Love that... Than go listen to the album... That is fun... Please stop trying to categorize folks so you can make your point... It is faulty logic and really does not convince anyone... It is just sn attempt to make you look like an expert so your view holds more weight... Sorry arguments based on icomplete data does not carry much weight...
mdewater:
Good to know... Thanks... As I said previously I do not have a problem with the concept of SONGS replacing LIBRARY... but of course it doesn really do that... The chsnges you mention will be welcome...
cohenfs:
Unfortunately this fucntionality does NOT exist in Spotify... These things are forseen in some future release that is not available...
Spotify has something better than surveys...they have direct access to the analytics of every user. It's not a difficult thing for them to see how a majority of people are using the software. "Power" and "casual" are broad classifications. There's obviously more to it than that, and there are more subdivisions and trends.
@LaRube I listen to music like you. I spend a lot of time shuffling and love to rediscover tracks and artists that way, but I also enjoy just browsing through my collection spotting an old album I've missed, or checking out my most recent additions.
I've said this in many places, but the current track limit is a major problem. Spotify is aware of that and are working on solutions.
@mdewater wrote:Interesting to read these comments. During the beta testing for the new design, the Library function was brought up maybe once or twice, and we pretty much came to the conclusion that it (along with stars) wouldn't be missed. From what I understand, a very small percent of users actually use the Library. Interesting to note that even a feature that is not widely used is still a lot of people's GO TO method of using Spotify.
I for one always thought the Library was completely and utterly useless. A giant pile of thousands and thousands of songs? No thanks, I could never listen to music that way.
Just more proof of how many types of users there are here.
Thanks for sharing some of what was said in the beta forum. I don't think you understand how I use the library. I use it as a reference to see if I've come across a track before. Between EPs, full album releases, remixes and such, I might come across the same track several times. I'll give something new and interesting a listen, if I like it, I'll add it to my "heavy rotation" playlist, if not, I throw it in a "nope" playlist. (I start a new "heavy rotation" playlist every month and save the tracks from last months into other playlists). If I come across a new track that sounds familiar, I can check to see if it's in my library to see if I've listened and rejected it before. If Spotify had an easy way to check to see if something was already in a playlist, I wouldn't need the library.
As far as power users and casual users go, I remember when iTunes Match came out and some power users were howling that it was limited to 25,000 songs. While I don't have nearly that many tracks, I sympathized with them. They were obviously passionate about music and were hurt by the limit. My husband doesn't use Spotify, and he listens to his entire music library on shuffle all the time. He will listen to Mahler's Kindertotenlieder and then the Dead Kennedys. (I'm not making this up). It's not what I would do, but he likes it.
You should open your mind that not everybody enjoys music the same way you do. You don't know me. Don't judge me.
@mdewater wrote:
Haha I'm not judging anyone!! I've been the one advocating others not to judge ME! There's all kinds of different users, and it's interesting to hear how different users use these different features. Yours is especially unique, with a "no good" playlist.
Glad you still have a sense of humor. As for my style, I used to have a limited budget for music. I used iTunes wishlist to come up with a list and then cut it down to fit my budget. I was still spending twice what I spend now for Spotify.
Ain't that the truth.... I have not bought any music for a heck of a long time... Have not bought a "CD" for about 5 years... Loaded all of my 1700 cd's to the computer and sold them (yes I know that digital music in general is lower quality... I will live... the convenience outweighs the loss of quality...). I love that aspect on online streaming... Spotify has been veru innovtive and has changed the streaming business; mainly with the approach they took to paying artists for their work; revolutionized the industry. The monthly fee is cheap for all the enjoyment I get...
I hope that the Spotofy business model can be modified to allow them to survive... According to the business publications they are still operating in the red... Course they are just guessing... I want Spotify to Live Long and Prosper... 😉
mdewater:
You missed the point completely... I was not talking about the labels, I was talking about how YOU have generalizing about the users here... Your generalizations do not help the discussion... I do not care how Spotify categorizes people... You assumed that all "power users"use the system like you do... Just not true... That was the point I was trying to make...
Thanks for the dialogue however... Ain't it great when the internet works like it 'sposed to work? Open free discussions! Wow! 😉
Really Peter - "not a tab most people used" - that's a bit presumptuous - I used it all the time because I did not want to make playlists out of every song I saved and if I wanted to listen to a song or group of songs I could just click on the list randomly - now all the miscallaneous songs I saved over the last two years are just gone poof because of someone's arbitrary decision - why were they not moved into the new songs tab as a default ? I am really sorry I upgraded to the "new" version .
I want my library back !!! - I had tons of songs on there not in a playlist - why were they not simply tramsferred tp tje new "songs" tab with the new version ??? Very inconsiderate and presumptuous thinking by Spotify - two thumbs down !
I don't understand why Spotify didn't just copy all people's tracks from their Starred section to the new library. Seemed like a very idiotic oversight. Who exactly designed this program? When I copy all my tracks from Starred to "Songs," they only look they're there until I restart Spotify. They dissapear after I restart the program. Seriously? Really shotty programming here people.
Or simply make it a new funtion... Clear your history? Something that could be done as wanted or needed...
There has to be more at work here than just the beta testers oppinions... There has to be some fundamental business or technical reason for the change that has to do with the future of the business... So a good business decisions often has consequences both good and bad... This may one that answers the underlying business issue but will not serve a small minority of customers... This is the sort of business decision that some times has to be made...
Guess it is time for me to re-evaluate Spotify as it stands and decide if it is better than what else is available... It is what it is and I will move on one way or the other... I am but a small voice in the wilderness... 😉 ... and although it is fun to have these discussions they will not change what is extant today...
For instance, this is a prime driver for me to test the radio feature which I almost never used... See if it is smarter than Pandora... I know there are over 20 times the available tracks... just have to test the algorithms for customizing the station...
Just imagine if I had signed up with Spotify today... I would wonder what all the brouhaha is about! I would probably be happy with the offering as it is... Ciao,,,
These discussions can influence things, eg when Spotify reversed their decision to make signing in and sharing by Facebook mandatory. I certainly wouldn't waste my time having pleasant discussions on here if I didn't think it could make a difference.
In my experience, the Spotify Radio function is incredibly good - light years ahead of crappy Pandora.
Thanks for sharing some of what was said in the beta forum. I don't think you understand how I use the library. I use it as a reference to see if I've come across a track before. Between EPs, full album releases, remixes and such, I might come across the same track several times. I'll give something new and interesting a listen, if I like it, I'll add it to my "heavy rotation" playlist, if not, I throw it in a "nope" playlist. (I start a new "heavy rotation" playlist every month and save the tracks from last months into other playlists). If I come across a new track that sounds familiar, I can check to see if it's in my library to see if I've listened and rejected it before. If Spotify had an easy way to check to see if something was already in a playlist, I wouldn't need the library.
As far as power users and casual users go, I remember when iTunes Match came out and some power users were howling that it was limited to 25,000 songs. While I don't have nearly that many tracks, I sympathized with them. They were obviously passionate about music and were hurt by the limit. My husband doesn't use Spotify, and he listens to his entire music library on shuffle all the time. He will listen to Mahler's Kindertotenlieder and then the Dead Kennedys. (I'm not making this up). It's not what I would do, but he likes it.
You should open your mind that not everybody enjoys music the same way you do. You don't know me. Don't judge me.