topic Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong in Spotify for Developers

Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

andersxa — Thu, 02 May 2024 03:20:13 GMT

The Update Playlist Items endpoint all of a sudden started returning the wrong values when reordering items. As per the documentation it is supposed to return the checkpoint ID as a string:

AAACi5JU+kMmH1WlpKKp8PeBdfLNw0BJ

Now it instead returns a base64-encoded string:

MTAyNDIzLDdiZWI1Yzg0YmQ2ZGI1ZWE5YWE4ZmEwOTg4ODYwY2VmZmI2ZTAxOTM=

Which when decoded becomes:

102423,7beb5c84bd6db5ea9aa8fa0988860ceffb6e0193

I.e an integer separated with what looks like a GUID.

How do I derive the checkpoint ID from this now? It used to simply return the checkpoint ID as a string. If I pass the returned value directly as the input parameter snapshot_id=MTAyNDIzLDdiZWI1Yzg0YmQ2ZGI1ZWE5YWE4ZmEwOTg4ODYwY2VmZmI2ZTAxOTM= I get a 400: Missing or bad version tag error.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

andersxa — Thu, 02 May 2024 22:26:26 GMT

Today, May 3rd, the string returned now correctly looks like a snapshot ID. However, the endpoint itself has stopped working and it simply returns the same snapshot ID as the input, so no changes to the actual playlist. Seems like this endpoint is under active development.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

gwenolechenouard — Fri, 03 May 2024 08:24:25 GMT

Same here !

Since yesterday, I can't reorder my playlists using this endpoint.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

ATLAST — Fri, 03 May 2024 10:03:21 GMT

Same here. Replace tracks doesn't work, but adding tracks does. Looks like they made changes to the endpoint overnight on a production server, without any advance warning or they're having some kind of bug.

In any case, sending a PUT request to https://api.spotify.com/v1/playlists/{playlist_id}/tracks results in a 405 error at the moment, whereas this has always worked and should still work according to documentation.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

evaldorcardoso — Fri, 03 May 2024 11:13:01 GMT

Same problem here, returns the same snapshot ID with no changes to the actual playlist.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

ATLAST — Fri, 03 May 2024 12:08:20 GMT

Yeah, same here. It will change when you add to the playlist (POST), but not when you re-order / change the playlist (PUT). Looks like someone disabled the PUT request for this endpoint even though this is still the official way according to the documentation so it looks to be a bug. It also wouldn't make any sense as only having the option to add tracks to a playlist would greatly reduce the functionality of the API.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

LambertSpot — Fri, 03 May 2024 14:25:15 GMT

Thanks for reporting this. We recently did do an update on this endpoint, we will look into this and get back as soon as we have more information.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

shuffles — Fri, 03 May 2024 18:44:33 GMT

It looks all related to the above posts, but when I try to move a track to the end of a playlist, e.g. there are 4 tracks in the playlist, and I'm using {"range_start": 1, "insert_before": 4}, I get a "Given positions are out of bounds" error message.

My code has been working flawlessly for many months until yesterday.

If I try {"range_start": 1, "insert_before": 3} it appears to work but the playlist is not modified.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

gwenolechenouard — Fri, 03 May 2024 19:34:47 GMT

#0 is the first track, so you need to write {"range_start": 0, "insert_before": 3} to move the first track to the 4th position.

When you tried {"range_start": 1, "insert_before": 3}, the track #2 is supposed to be moved to the 4th position. But for all of us since yesterday, we get a snapshot_id but the playlist is not modified.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

shuffles — Fri, 03 May 2024 20:16:46 GMT

Thanks. The documentation says "To reorder the first item to the last position in a playlist with 10 items, set range_start to 0, and insert_before to 10". Maybe that has changed recently? I'm pretty sure that's how it used to work at least. It would make sense to me, because in my mind if you insert before the last track, the existing last track would still be last track. What makes sense and what actually happens may be two different things of course.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

gwenolechenouard — Fri, 03 May 2024 20:25:58 GMT

Sorry, I was probably wrong with the "insert_before". I'm confused now. You seems more used than me with this endpoint 😉

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

LeSqueed — Sun, 05 May 2024 06:35:39 GMT

Seems like the issue is still ongoing. Multiple days so far. Would've expected the live API to have some method of reverting changes that actively break things rather quickly. Any update on this?

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

ehtisham — Sun, 05 May 2024 22:09:51 GMT

Can't believe it's May 6th and this issue is still not resolved in Production,

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Spotify-for-Developers/Issue-with-Reordering-Tracks-in-Playlist-via-API-Action-Not/m-p/6051175#M13771

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

LambertSpot — Mon, 06 May 2024 08:25:10 GMT

We found a bug in the new code. Instead of using the insert_before parameter, we were re-using the range_start parameter. That would explain why attempts to re-order would not actually move anything, since it was being moved to the same position it was already in. Is it now working as expected for you?

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

ATLAST — Mon, 06 May 2024 09:16:44 GMT

Hi Lambert,

Thanks for the reply and for looking into this. We're currently still getting a 405 error unfortunately when trying to replace the tracks in the playlist. This is with PUT and a bunch of URIs. Everything worked perfect until 3-4 days ago.

We use PUT on the /playlists/[id]/tracks endpoint to first replace the songs in our playlists with up to 100 new ones. And then we use the POST request if we need to add more songs beyond the first 100. The POST request still works fine, but the PUT throws a 405 error that wasn't there before a couple days ago. Hope that helps. 🙂

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

shuffles — Mon, 06 May 2024 09:33:00 GMT

Thanks Lambert. It still does not seem possible to move a track to the end of a playlist. Testing with a playlist with 9 tracks, I can move a track to the last-but-one position (insert_before: 8), but when I try to move it to the end (insert_before: 9) I still get the 'out of bounds' error.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

gwenolechenouard — Mon, 06 May 2024 16:24:24 GMT

I still can't reorder my playlists using this endpoint. A snapshot_id is given back but the playlist order is the same.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

gwenolechenouard — Mon, 06 May 2024 18:26:17 GMT

It works now 👍

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

ATLAST — Mon, 06 May 2024 20:36:55 GMT

Interesting. Still a 405 error over here with the PUT request unfortunately.

Re: Update Playlist Items endpoint returning wrong string value or documentation is wrong

JoaaoVerona — Mon, 06 May 2024 21:33:37 GMT

@LambertSpot, first of all, thank you for handling/communicating these issues.

Even though playlist updating is kinda working right now, there are still some issues:

The returned snapshot_id is exactly the same as the one specified on the request body; this data is particularly important for API consumers that must call this API many times in sequence, since we need the last valid snapshot ID to be specified on the request body of the next API calls. This same issue also happens on other playlist-related APIs (like the DELETE variation of this one, for removing playlist items).
Moving a track to the end of a playlist, as @shuffles mentioned, is indeed not working (for me, the API is returning 502 Bad Gateway with an empty message).