topic Re: AppleScript completely broken in Desktop (Mac)

AppleScript completely broken

ToastyKen — Tue, 28 Mar 2023 23:19:21 GMT

Device

MacBook Pro 16-inch 2021

Operating System

macOS Ventura 13.2.1 (22D68)

My Question or Issue

AppleScript seems completely broken. I can't even load the dictionary in AppleScript Editor, and this basic script doesn't work:

tell application "Spotify"

play

end tell

I get:
error "The variable play is not defined." number -2753 from "play"

Re: AppleScript completely broken

Prague — Tue, 28 Mar 2023 23:38:18 GMT

Paw-some to see you ToastyKen!

I'm sorry to hear that you're having trouble with AppleScript.

Regarding the issue you mentioned, the error message you're receiving suggests that the "play" command is not recognized by the Spotify application, and therefore cannot be executed by AppleScript.

One possible solution is to check the Spotify dictionary to see if the "play" command is available. To do this:

Open AppleScript Editor.
Click on "File" in the menu bar, and select "Open Dictionary".
In the "Open Dictionary" window, select "Spotify" from the list of applications, and click "Open".
This should open the Spotify dictionary in AppleScript Editor. Look for the "play" command in the dictionary to confirm whether it is supported.

If the "play" command is not available in the dictionary, you may need to use a different command or approach to achieve the desired functionality.

Also if the "play" command is available, you can try modifying your script to explicitly reference the application's dictionary by using the "using terms from" block. For example:

using terms from application "Spotify" play end using terms from

This should ensure that the "play" command is recognized by the Spotify application when the script is executed.

I hope this helps! Just a pup-date on your situation will do, thanks!

-Prague the Dog

Re: AppleScript completely broken

ToastyKen — Wed, 29 Mar 2023 18:34:47 GMT

So open dictionary didn't work. I could choose Open Dictionary, select Spotify, then click Choose, and literally nothing would happen (other than the window closing). The dictionary for Spotify would NOT pop up.

Your alternate script didn't work either.

But then I dug in and found the underlying AppleScript definition file in Spotify, and strangely the simple act of directly opening it in Script Editor fixed it?!? I did the following:

Right-click on Spotify.app and choose "Show Package Contents".
Drill down to Contents/Resources/
Choose "Open" in Script Editor
Drag Spotify.sdef into the open dialog, and click Open

That opened the dictionary, and then everything worked after that. It seems like my computer somehow is failing to load the Spotify script definitions, but once I force it, it works?

To do it quicker, you could also do this from Terminal:

open -a /System/Applications/Utilities/Script\ Editor.app /Applications/Spotify.app/Contents/Resources/Spotify.sdef

So I have a workaround now, but I still have no idea what the root cause is, or even whether it's Spotify's fault or macOS's fault, or something else.