topic Re: Radio repeating songs way too often in Desktop (Mac)

Radio repeating songs way too often

cohnbc — Tue, 03 Jun 2014 00:16:22 GMT

I've seen many similar posts on here about related issues but I still feel compelled to throw this out there.

I love Spotify and use the Radio feature all the time, but it's incredibly frustrating that my custom stations play the same songs over and over again. It's almost like I'm listening to a set playlist and not hearing new music at all. Sometimes I'll hear the same song 3 times in a few hours. Not often so whatever. But consistently, I'm just hitting skip because I've hear the same songs every time I put that station on.

If I want to keep hearing the sames songs, I will take advantage of the other features Spotify offers, like adding music or checking the thumbs up list.

Maybe I feel the Radio feature should be geared more towards music discovery, rarely replaying songs at all, even if you liked them. It seems like 90% of what I hear is repeated music and 10% is new, and I feel it should be the opposite. I'm looking for an Actor/Model system.. and not the other way around. Sorry, I'm getting carried away.

Anyway, my thoughts. Thanks.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

Peter__ — Tue, 03 Jun 2014 12:21:44 GMT

Radio repeating tracks is also an open bug:
http://community.spotify.com/t5/Bugs/Android-Desktop-Radio-repeats-tracks/td-p/241950

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

gimme_music — Fri, 04 Jul 2014 14:31:37 GMT

It's not that bug Peter. Music keeps flowing, but eventually all you get is the same set of songs.

I ended up adding all the tracks from the "Rock" radio station to my playlist called "Rock" so I can keep them offline since no new track pops up ever. I wasn't expect "Rock" radio station to be a set of 42 tracks, but that's what Spotify pushes to me. And yes I do like and dislike tracks along the way, that's all I got now.

I too was hoping a sort of music discovery radio. I tried deezer, rdio and left because of the lack of music discovery. Now I'm stuck on the same issue on spotify, but I'm still rooting for it.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

tobyandcarol — Fri, 04 Jul 2014 16:25:39 GMT

I think this may be a bit different - this does not happen "after a while", it happens every time I play the station. In short, it's not a station anymore, it's a playlist that plays exactly the same songs every time, from the start.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

sammnz — Wed, 13 Aug 2014 03:19:05 GMT

Yep agreed. I have to constantly downrate songs to attempt to get a selection.

Is there any way we can set spotify to use a varied range of songs, and not necessarily the most popular songs? May as well listen to FM radio if it keeps going like this.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

raincity — Wed, 27 Aug 2014 21:08:35 GMT

For me this is a big annoyance and I'm not willing to pay a monthly fee to be annoyed multiple times an hour. It is not at all uncommon for Spotify to play the same song 3 times in a very short time. I even sometimes hear the same song twice in a row. You'd think a 3 year old is arranging the play list instead of a computer.

Spotify support says the only solution is to give songs I don't want to hear repeatedly a thumbs down. That's not a solution because I want to hear those songs again. While I am sitting here writing this Spotify is repeating a song that has already played twice this morning.

Other radio services, even free ones do not have this issue and I am cancelling my Spotify subscription because of it.

Speaking of bugs, it looks like the forum has some big ones too. This was added to my post after a minor edit:

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

gimme_music — Wed, 27 Aug 2014 20:56:45 GMT

Yep. I'm moving on also.

Deezer
Rdio
Spotify
Pandora
Google

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

raincity — Wed, 27 Aug 2014 21:02:18 GMT

I had been using Google's service for the past 6 months and switched to Spotify because there were some annoying bugs and I thought the Spotify app would be better. It turns out the bugs in Google's android app are minor compared to Spotify's.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

fluxtras — Wed, 14 Sep 2016 06:46:22 GMT

Agree. I thought Spotify was tha bomb. Tried it, thought it was good, until the radio wasn't radio.

I don't know what I like conscerning new stuff... That is why I must have a radio! I'm over to Google Play Music! Too bad app support without android isn't all that great, but ey, the Radio works (even with a refresh button)!

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

nikdra — Tue, 08 Nov 2016 18:35:36 GMT

I completely agree, the "Classical" station has been playing the same ten songs over and over again for months.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

WickedDays — Sat, 11 Mar 2017 00:50:02 GMT

Almost three years later and this is still a problem. Over the course of a day I will here the same songs 4-5 times, even though the radio has dozens of artists with thousands of songs in their discographies. Spotify only seems to pick the most popular song for each artist and then plays that over, and over, and over. I end up having to thumb down a song I actually used to like just so I don't have to listen to it multiple times every single day.

Spotify should implement a button, shaped as a clock, that says "Play this song less often." It can even have multiples. The first time I hit it for a song, don't play that song for 24 hours. The second time, 3 days, the third, a week, and so on, up to a month or so.

Re: Radio repeating songs way too often

carloscastenada — Sat, 11 Mar 2017 16:35:22 GMT

or settings option like "play all songs in playlist before repeating a song"