Solved! Go to Solution.
Hey @wills1066, Welcome to the community! 🙂
It sounds like you are using Spotify for free?
In order to play any song you want in any order you want, you need to Subscribe to Spotify Premium 🙂
If you have premium:
To play songs in the normal order (1, 2, 3, etc.) just click on the first song, then look for the Shuffle icon (As seen below) and click on it until it is grey instead if green