Star and Save coexisting?

[thrasbarg]

I used to star songs as a way to be able to, at a quick glance, see what were my favourite tracks on an album or in a playlist while scrolling through or just browsing around my playlists or artists profile pages. It used to be a fun and easy way to help myself remeber what tracks I liked. It used to be a great aid in remebering and (re)discover great music.

I used to. It used to.

Why can't Star and Save coexist next to each other?

Although the starred playlist is still there, it really doesn't do anything anymore now does it? I've longed for the Your Music feature for so long because I want to be able to save albums and actually have them sorted by artist in an easy and attractive way. But I think it was a big mistake removing the starring feature and thinking Your Music would replace it rather than compliment each other.

[chrisdymond]

Starring and saving are very different. The Your Music system does not replace the Starred option and playlist for these reasons:

If I save an album it does not mean that I like every track on the album - but all of them go into my saved songs.

If I save a song it doesn't mean that I like that artist - but the artist goes into my saved artists anyway.

So Your Music is really a hopeless place to listen to the music you like unless you stick to albums - the songs and artists quickly fill up with spam.

When I find a track that I like I want to put it somewhere to listen to later, but if I put it into a playlist it appends it to the end - the starred playlist lists in reverse order, just what you want to quickly listen to tracks you've found recently.

So why remove such a useful and complimentary feature as Starred and think that Your Music behaves similarly?

very very disappointing...

[guiom2510]

---

@thrasbarg wrote:

I used to star songs as a way to be able to, at a quick glance, see what were my favourite tracks on an album or in a playlist while scrolling through or just browsing around my playlists or artists profile pages. It used to be a fun and easy way to help myself remeber what tracks I liked. It used to be a great aid in remebering and (re)discover great music.

I used to. It used to.

Why can't Star and Save coexist next to each other?

Although the starred playlist is still there, it really doesn't do anything anymore now does it? I've longed for the Your Music feature for so long because I want to be able to save albums and actually have them sorted by artist in an easy and attractive way. But I think it was a big mistake removing the starring feature and thinking Your Music would replace it rather than compliment each other.

---

I want the starred option back !!!!

Just keep in mind that apple music have favorite icon and that they add the option to CHOOSE (YES TO CHOOSE !!!) if when you add a song to a playlist / selection, the album and the artist do not appear in the album section!!

apple seems to listen their customers...

[Jo]

I'm not too bothered what happens to Your Music but I would very much like to see the Starred feature return. It was the main thing that made Spotify such a great tool for discovering and sharing new music. Your Music is more of a replacement for how I bought and listened to music pre-Spotify - an online CD collection. Spotify - with the stars - had revitalised my interest. I was listening to new bands again, going to gigs, creating playlists. I can honestly say that with the removal of the stars, I'm doing those things less, using Spotify less and generally listening to music less, and it's a shame.

[meahtenoha]

Hey folks, we're back to confirm we dont' have plans to make the Star feature co-exist with Your Music. You can now Save tracks directly to Your Music by clicking on the + next to each song. 

You can read more about how to organize Your Library right here. Thanks for continuing to bring your feedback to the Idea Exchange, if we have any updates around Your Music we will let you know here. 

[Jo]

But you do understand, don't you, that a one-click 'save to Your Music' doesn't even come close to doing what the stars used to? I am also wondering why I don't see the option to give kudos on this thread anymore. 

[ftwtx]

What feature is there that lets you know you have the song in your music already. So when I go into Discover Weekly and click on an album where does it show I already have particlular songs in my music playlists. It should be visible next to the song. You should not have to drag and see the pop-up "do you want to add/duplicate". 

[Marco]

Updated on 2018-06-16

Hey there!

A similar idea has already been suggested here:

https://community.spotify.com/t5/Closed-Ideas/Bring-Back-Starred-Playlists-System/idi-p/729851

It has been discussed within the Spotify Team in charge and it has sadly been decided that this idea will not be implemented any time soon. However, Spotify will revisit those idea topics from time to time, so hopefully it will be implemented in the future. 😉