Spotify Plays a Seemly Random Song Whenever I Click a Song

[FauxMulder]

Whenever I click a song to play in my playlist (playlist is on shuffle, but I want to listen to a specific track), Spotify plays a random song. I've found no relation in track time, artist, or placement in the playlist. This happens on all playlists, artist pages, and albums, but only if it's already on shuffle play. I've refreshed the pages and restarted my computer, but nothing fixes it. I am, of course, using the Web Player on a desktop running Windows 10, and my primary browser is Chrome.